Anderson v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Anderson v State of Western Australia [2003] FCA 1058

NATIVE TITLE – practice and procedure – regional claims – South West region of Western Australia – overlapping claims – single claim to incorporate a number of overlapping claims – application to establish new mediation program – whether programming to trial should remain in docket matters – directions for mediation program – connexion evidence – separate determination of issues of law and fact

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)

CEDRIC ANDERSON, DONALD COLLARD, SYLVIA RACHAEL COLLARD AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG6181 OF 1998
MARTHA BORINELLI, MICHAEL EGAN, ARNOLD FRANKS AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG 6192 of 1998
LORRAINE BELLOTTI, JOSEPH NORTHOVER, PETER MICHAEL AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG6274 OF 1998
PATRICIA M MORICH AND OTHERS FOR KORENG, MINANG AND WUDJARI PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG6130 OF 1998
KEN COLBUNG, GLEN COLBUNG, DONALD CORBETT AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG6279, 6085, 6258 AND PART OF 6274 OF 1998
ALLAN BOLTON, GLEN COLBUNG, DALLAS COYNE AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAG 6134, 6286 AND PART OF 6130 OF 1998
ANTHONY BENNELL, ALAN BLURTON AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
W6006 of 2003

FRENCH J
2 OCTOBER 2003
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

 WAG 6134 and WAG 6286 and PART OF 6130 of 1998

BETWEEN:  ALLAN BOLTON, GLEN COLBUNG, DALLAS COYNE
  AND OTHERS
  APPLICANTS

AND:    THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
  RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 OCTOBER 2003

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Before 28 November 2003, the First and Second Applicants are to make an application or applications under s 64 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to combine native title determination applications WAG6286/98 (Wagyl Kaip) and WAG6134/98 (Southern Noongar), to the extent that they geographically overlap with W6006/03 (‘Single Noongar Claim 1’).

2.The directions hearing be adjourned to 16 December 2003 at 9.30am.

3.The Applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 January 2004.  The program is to set out:

(i)        specific issues to be negotiated;

(ii)a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;

(iii)an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;

(iv)provision for the taking of connexion evidence;

(v)identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.

4.A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 31 January 2004.

5.A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.

6.The parties are to comply with the timetable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anderson v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 1058
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Anderson v State of Western Australia, the applicants sought directions from the Court regarding the management and progression of several native title applications. The dispute centred around the handling of these applications, particularly those related to the Noongar people and their claims over traditional lands in Western Australia. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the appropriate procedural steps for these applications.

The central legal issue the Court had to address was the management of multiple overlapping native title applications, particularly in the context of the Noongar people's claims. The Court needed to decide on the best course of action for applications that were geographically overlapping or could be combined into a single claim. This included determining whether certain applications should be struck out, combined, or progressed to trial.

The Court concluded that it would not make specific directions for the Collard polygon applications at that time, as these applications were subsumed in the first single Noongar claim. However, it directed a review hearing on 16 December 2003 to decide their future. For other applications, the Court ordered that a negotiation and mediation program be prepared by the applicants, the State, and the National Native Title Tribunal. This program was to outline the issues to be negotiated, a detailed timetable, a negotiating protocol, provisions for taking connexion evidence, and identification of questions of law or fact that could aid in resolving claims. Additionally, the applicants were directed to combine their applications with the single Noongar claim to the extent that they overlapped geographically.

The Court issued several orders to facilitate the negotiation and mediation of the applications, including the preparation and submission of a program, the provision of a mediation report by the National Native Title Tribunal, and the scheduling of future directions hearings. These orders aimed to streamline the process and ensure that all parties had an opportunity to participate in the resolution of the native title claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Before 28 November 2003, the First and Second Applicants are to make an application or applications under s 64 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to combine native title determination applications WAG6286/98 (Wagyl Kaip) and WAG6134/98 (Southern Noongar), to the extent that they geographically overlap with W6006/03 (‘Single Noongar Claim 1’).

2. The directions hearing be adjourned to 16 December 2003 at 9.30am.

3. The Applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 January 2004. The program is to set out:

(i) specific issues to be negotiated;

(ii) a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;

(iii) an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;

(iv) provision for the taking of connexion evidence;

(v) identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.

4. A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 31 January 2004.

5. A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.

6. The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.

7. Any party may apply to the Court at any time for directions as to the taking of connexion evidence.

8. Any party may apply to the National Native Title Tribunal to refer to the Court, in accordance with the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) any question of law or fact the determination of which may assist in the resolution of the application.

9. Any party may apply to the Court for the separate determination of any question of fact or law in accordance with the Federal Court Rules.

10. There is liberty to apply.

11. The next directions hearing after 16 December 2003 is listed for 5 March 2004 at 9.30am.

12. The National Native Title Tribunal is requested to provide a mediation report not less than seven days prior to the relisted directions hearings.

1. The Applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 January 2004. The program is to set out:

(i) specific issues to be negotiated;

(ii) a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;

(iii) an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;

(iv) provision for the taking of connexion evidence;

(v) identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.

2. A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 31 January 2004.

3. A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.

4. The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.

5. Any party may apply to the Court at any time for directions as to the taking of connexion evidence.

6. Any party may apply to the National Native Title Tribunal to refer to the Court, in accordance with the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) any question of law or fact the determination of which may assist in the resolution of the application.

7. Any party may apply to the Court for the separate determination of any question of fact or law in accordance with the Federal Court Rules.

8. There is liberty to apply.

9. The next directions hearing be listed for 5 March 2004 at 9.30am.

10. The National Native Title Tribunal is requested to provide a mediation report not less than seven days prior to the relisted directions hearing.

1. The Applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 January 2004. The program is to set out:

(i) specific issues to be negotiated;

(ii) a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;

(iii) an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;

(iv) provision for the taking of connexion evidence;

(v) identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.

2. A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 31 January 2004.

3. A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.

4. The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.

5. Any party may apply to the Court at any time for directions as to the taking of connexion evidence.

6. Any party may apply to the National Native Title Tribunal to refer to the Court, in accordance with the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) any question of law or fact the determination of which may assist in the resolution of the application.

7. Any party may apply to the Court for the separate determination of any question of fact or law in accordance with the Federal Court Rules.

8. There is liberty to apply.

9. The next directions hearing be listed for 5 March 2004 at 9.30am.

10. The National Native Title Tribunal is requested to provide a mediation report not less than seven days prior to the relisted directions hearings.

1. The Applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 January 2004. The program is to set out:

(i) specific issues to be negotiated;

(ii) a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;

(iii) an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;

(iv) provision for the taking of connexion evidence;

(v) identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.

2. A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 31 January 2004.

3. A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.

4. The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.

5. Any party may apply to the Court at any time for directions as to the taking of connexion evidence.

6. Any party may apply to the National Native Title Tribunal to refer to the Court, in accordance with the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) any question of law or fact the determination of which may assist in the resolution of the application.

7. Any party may apply to the Court for the separate determination of any question of fact or law in accordance with the Federal Court Rules.

8. There is liberty to apply.

9. The next directions hearing is listed for 5 March 2004 at 9.30am.

10. The National Native Title Tribunal is requested to provide a mediation report not less than seven days prior to the relisted directions hearings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
In respect of the Collard polygon applications, I would expect that if, within a short period of time, they are not either discontinued or combined with the single Noongar claim they should be programmed to trial. This would no doubt have the practical effect that they would be struck out. It seems highly unlikely that any party would be prepared to devote resources to progressing those matters to trial as individual applications.Conclusion I propose therefore to make directions to the following effect:A.On the Collard polygon applications I make no specific directions at this time. There is no apparent reason why those should stand as separate claims now that they are subsumed in the first single Noongar claim. I will however bring the applications up for review on 16 December 2003 at 9.30 to determine their future. B.In relation to claims other than Southern Noongar (WAG6134/98) and Wagyl Kaip (WAG6286/98), I propose to make the following orders: 1.The applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the application over the period of twelve months commencing 1 January 2004. The program is to set out: (i)specific issues to be negotiated; (ii)a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context; (iii)an outline of a negotiating protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants; (iv)provision for the taking of connexion evidence; (v)identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims. 2.A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 31 January 2004.3.A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.4.The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.5.Any party may apply to the Court at any time for directions as to the taking of connexion evidence. 6.Any party may apply to the National Native Title Tribunal to refer to the Court, in accordance with the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 any question of law or fact the determination of which may assist in the resolution of the application.7.Any party may apply to the Court for the separate determination of any question of fact or law in accordance with the Federal Court Rules. 8. There is liberty to apply.9.The next directions hearing is listed for 5 March 2004 at 9.30am.10.The National Native Title Tribunal is requested to provide a mediation report not less than seven days prior to the relisted directions hearing. C.In relation to Southern Noongar (WAG6134/98) and Wagyl and Kaip (WAG6286/98) ie South West Area 2, the applicants on or before 28 November 2003 are to make applications under s 64 of the Native Title Act 1993 to combine their applications with the single Noongar application (W6006/03) to the extent that they geographically overlap with it. In addition I will direct the preparation of a mediation program for the combined application along the lines of the directions made for the other applications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J