Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The amount owed to unsecured Creditors at the time of the relevant event was approximately $1,265,560.00. [6][6]Report to Creditors of Ashton Brailey & Co dated 4 June 2015.Evidence Mr Anderson gave evidence at the hearing. The materials relied upon by Mr Anderson were made Exhibits in the proceeding, to which I have referred. In particular, forming part of Exhibit 1 is a Statutory Declaration of Mr Anderson dated 11 July 2015. Mr Mohamed Radwan, Chartered Accountant, gave evidence for Mr Anderson. A statutory Declaration by Mr Radwan dated 10 July 2015 forms part of Exhibit 1. Mr Radwan also gave a statement dated 30 August 2016 forming part of Exhibit 3. Also included in the documents compiled as part of Exhibit 1 is a Statutory Declaration of Margaret Markellos, Bookkeeper, dated 8 July 2015. Ms Markellos was not called to give evidence. Mr Ryan Baker, Senior Licence Entitlement Officer, QBCC, gave evidence. Mr Baker first assessed the Permitted Individual Application. That decision was the subject of an internal review by the QBCC. Mr Baker filed a further statement made on 15 December 2016 – Exhibit 5. Materials relied upon by the QBCC were made Exhibits in the proceeding, to which I have referred. In particular, the QBCC Statement of Reasons forms part of Exhibit 6.Circumstances that resulted in the happening of the relevant eventWhat Mr Anderson says were the circumstances In the Permitted Individual Application[7], Mr Anderson attributes the main cause of the relevant event to be the liquidation of a company Glenzeil Pty Ltd (Glenzeil) on 8 September 2014.[7]ID5 to ID 8 of the Respondent’s Index of Documents dated 28 April 2016 - Exhibit 6 in the proceedings. Mr Anderson attributes other secondary causes of the relevant event to be:(a)negligence by a subcontractor Slipstop Australia Pty Ltd (Slipstop);(b)non-payment of contract moneys and liquidated damages claim by the Applicant against Buildcorp Pty Ltd (Buildcorp); and(c)increased pressure by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO):(i) for the Company to pay outstanding taxation; and(ii) personally, on the applicant to pay Director Penalty Notices (DPNs). A relevant timeline of events emerges from the uncontested evidence as follows:(a)2012 – 2013 Classic Stone ceased building work due to poor trading conditions as a result of the global financial crisis;(b)23 March 2013 – Classic Stone debt to ATO - $18,609.93[8];[8]Australian Taxation Office Tax Agent Portal – Itemised account attached to the Statutory Declaration of Mohamed Radwan – Exhibit 3.(c)24 August 2013 debt to ATO increased to $45, 286.19[9] taking into account general interest charges, pay as you go tax withheld and a penalty for failure to lodge a business activity statement;[9]Ibid.(d)26 August 2013 - Classic Stone entered a written subcontract with Glenzeil for the supply and installation of tiling for the Plaza South Brisbane Project. Contract price $1,165,824.29 plus GST;(e)10 April 2014 - Classic Stone entered into a $619,816.00 written Subcontract with Buildcorp for the supply and installation of tiling at 140 Creek Street;(f)mid-June 2014 Buildcorp required a slip test after 35% of tiling had been completed. Buildcorp was not satisfied and a subcontractor, Slipstop was engaged to treat the tiled floor by applying a slip-resistance material onto the newly installed 1,100m2 granite floor. Losses of $574,869.57 were incurred by Classic Stone over the period to May 2015 as a result of the following:·Slipstop used a chemical which stained and edged the floor causing the whole of the floor to require honing with repair costs in excess of $100,000.00; Slipstop abandoned the project and referred the matter to its Insurer;·as a result of delays, Buildcorp incurred a liability to the building owner for liquidated damages. It claimed liquidated damages from Classic Stone and refused to make the final payment of $188,563.21, plus retentions due under the Subcontract;·recovery attempts made against insurers and by adjudication against Buildcorp were unsuccessful.(g)18 July 2014 the debt to the ATO increased to $60,024.85 taking into account general interest charges and penalties for failure to lodge activity statements;(h)invoice No 0554, dated 28 July 2014 to Glenzeil Pty Ltd in the amount of $294,407.70 due September 2014;(i)invoice No 0559, dated 26 August 2014 to Glenzeil Pty Ltd in the amount of $223,588.73 due October 2014;(j)8 September 2014 – Glenzeil unexpectedly put into liquidation leaving Glenzeil invoices unpaid;(k)12 September 2014 - Classic Stone issued a Subcontractors Charge pursuant to the Subcontractors Charges Act 1974 (Qld) and engaged lawyers to recover the debt;(l)23 September 2014 - Peter Green Accountants lodged all outstanding taxation returns with the ATO following 9 months of work by Classic Stone’s bookkeeper correcting data entry;[10] [10] Evidence in chief of Derek Anderson; Statement of Mohamed Radwan dated 30 August 2016 part of Exhibit 3.(m)23 September 2014, Classic Stone owed the ATO $267,158.11 taking into account general interest charges and penalties for failure to lodge activity statements. The significant increase over a period of 2 months from July 2014 related to pay as you go tax withheld, in an amount of approximately $122,952.00. The effective or due dates for pay as you go tax withheld shown on the ATO integrated account[11] are August, September, November and December 2013 totalling $34,114.00 and February, May, June and August 2014 totalling $68,240.00. Mr Anderson’s evidence is that pay as you go tax withheld related to staff engaged for the Glenzeil project.[11] Attachment 1 to the Statutory Declaration of Mohamed Radwan made 10 July,2015 – Exhibit 1. The document is barely legible. Figures extracted are intended as approximate amounts to take account of discrepancies arising from legibility.(n)invoice No. 0562 to Glenzeil, dated 25 September 2014 in the amount of $24,377.00 which went unpaid;(o)late September 2014 - Mr Anderson instructed Mr Radwan, Chartered Accountant to negotiate a payment arrangement with the ATO;(p)from July 2013 to December 2014 Directors Penalty Notices were issued to Mr Anderson, totalling $154,034.09.(q)February 2015 - Mr Anderson assumed conduct of the negotiations with the ATO;(r)27 February 2015 Classic Stone’s bookkeeper lodged a late progress claim with Hutchinson Builders delaying payment of $160,000.00 until the end of the following month which impacted on the ability of Classic Stone to make an instalment payment to the ATO;(s)10 March 2015 - Mr Anderson negotiated a payment arrangement with the ATO based upon anticipated recovery of funds from Slipstop and its insurance company;(t)mid-April 2015 - it was becoming obvious that it was increasingly less likely there would be any recovery of moneys to Classic Stone sufficient to pay the ATO;(u)negotiations continued with the ATO to allow Classic Stone time to recover moneys owed by Glenzeil, Classic Stone’s Insurer, Slipstop and Buildcorp;(v)advice from Classic Stone’s Accountant and a range of Solicitors and Liquidators to pay the ATO the outstanding amount or place the company into liquidation;(w)mid-April 2015 – unsuccessful attempt to borrow funds to pay the ATO debt;(x)from 13 October 2014 to 8 April 2015, 10 payments were made to the ATO totalling $95,576.00.(y)6 May 2015 - advice received that the sum of $69,982.02 would be recovered from Glenzeil in liquidation. Mr Anderson anticipated recovery of a further amount of $140,000.00 at the completion of the Defects Liability Period in September 2015;(z)in the period from September 2014 to 8 May 2015 the debt to the ATO increased to $559,627.34 taking into account general interest charges and pay as you go tax withheld;(aa)from 1 July 2014 to the date of liquidation Mr Anderson lent Classic Stone $162,222.56;(bb)at the time Classic Stone was placed into liquidation it was completing a subcontract with Lend Lease at The Green Residential Apartments Project worth approximately $1.6 million. Classic Stone had been awarded 2 subcontracts with Hutchinson Builders valued at $1,340,750.78 and $2,725,791.74 respectively to start in mid and late 2015.(cc)15 May 2015 - decision to wind-up Classic Stone’s business;(dd)1 June 2015 appointment of liquidator;(ee)total amount owing to unsecured creditors as at the date of liquidation $1,265,560.98. Total receivables as at the date of liquidation alleged to be $865,422.72. In addition, Classic Stone was entitled to recover retention moneys on projects totalling $103,328.00.What QBCC says were the circumstances
Decision
Reasons for decision
I find that Mr Anderson did not make appropriate provision for Commonwealth taxation debts.Conclusion Considering my findings in relation to the matters set out in s56AD(8A) of the QBCC Act and accepting the QBCC’s evidence in relation to a lack of appropriate levels of capital in the company, I find that Mr Anderson did not take all reasonable steps to avoid the coming into existence of the circumstances that resulted in the happening of the relevant event. I therefore do not need to exercise my discretion to classify Mr Anderson as a permitted individual. Mr Anderson gave evidence that he has an unblemished record with the QBCC over a long career in the building and construction industry. Over 30 years he has worked on many well- known projects and has undertaken high quality work in luxury developments. Mr Anderson’s evidence is that the knowledge he has obtained during 34 years in the building trade takes a lifetime of dedication, sweat, study, learning and time. I accept that Mr Anderson is a highly qualified tradesperson. I found him to be straightforward and honest and has done his best to provide a comprehensive application and supporting documents. In his closing submissions, Mr Anderson said that he has remained proactive and that all staff have been paid, including their entitlements. After the liquidation, he saw that all creditors were paid by himself or that there was an agreed settlement entered. Nothing remains owing to the ATO. That is a remarkable effort and should be acknowledged. However, these matters do not alter my finding that Mr Anderson did not take all reasonable steps to avoid the coming into existence of the circumstances that resulted in the happening of the relevant event. In the circumstances, I confirm the decision of the QBCC.