and Mohamed Abdul Fattah v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCR 2015 0253
MOHAMED ABDUL FATTAH Applicant
v
THE QUEEN Respondent

---

JUDGE: MAXWELL P
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 22 December 2015
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 22 December 2015
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2015] VSCA 371

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Sentence – Bail pending appeal – Applicant sentenced on basis of incorrect facts – Crown concession of error – Whether different sentence likely to be imposed – Whether non-custodial sentence open if applicant re-sentenced – Fairness – Risk of applicant serving time in custody unnecessarily – Bail granted – Re Zoudi (2007) 14 VR 580 applied.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant Mr C B Boyce SC Garde-Wilson Lawyers
For the Respondent Mr R F Pirrie Mr M Pedley, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Cth)

MAXWELL P:

  1. On 14 December 2015, the applicant gave notice of an application for leave to appeal against sentence.  He now makes application for bail pending the hearing of his application for leave to appeal (and of the appeal, if leave is granted).

  1. For reasons which follow, I would make an order granting him bail.

  1. The written case filed for the applicant identifies, amongst a number of proposed grounds, a ground which draws attention to the sentencing judge's erroneous reliance on statements of fact contained in a plea opening which had been prepared in August 2015.  As the written case makes clear, the applicant had taken issue with certain factual assertions contained in that plea opening.  Negotiations followed, between his representatives and the prosecution, which resulted in the filing of an altered prosecution plea opening. 

  1. Certain of the allegations against the applicant which had been in the first plea opening were deleted from the second.  It is apparent from the judge's reasons, however, that he sentenced the applicant on the basis of some of those deleted matters.  It is common ground that that is so.  The issue between the applicant and the respondent Director is whether the erroneous inclusion of those matters, as part of the facts on the basis of which the applicant was sentenced, materially affected the findings which his Honour made about the applicant's role and culpability.  The submission for the applicant is that, because of the judge’s erroneous use of the first plea opening, he was sentenced on ‘a wrongly inflated understanding of his culpability’.

  1. The application for bail has been brought on urgently because the applicant submits that the acknowledged factual errors in the sentencing will lead to the appeal succeeding and that the court, on hearing the appeal, will be satisfied not only that there was an error in the sentence but that a different sentence should be imposed.  Critically for present purposes, senior counsel for the applicant has submitted that a non-custodial disposition would be within range for this Court on re‑sentencing. 

  1. Counsel for the Director, quite properly, does not seek to contend that a non-custodial disposition is out of the question, but points to the seriousness of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read and Mohamed Abdul Fattah v The Queen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] VSCA 371
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mohamed Abdul Fattah against The Queen involved an appeal against the sentence imposed on the applicant, who was convicted of certain criminal offences. The dispute centred around the accuracy of the facts upon which the original sentence was based, as well as the potential for a different, likely less severe, sentence if the errors were corrected. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the applicant sought bail pending the appeal.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the applicant was likely to receive a different, potentially non-custodial, sentence if re-sentenced, and whether it would be fair to allow the applicant to remain at liberty pending the appeal. The court also needed to consider the risk of the applicant serving time in custody unnecessarily if bail was not granted. The Crown conceded that the original sentence was based on incorrect facts, which was a pivotal point in the applicant’s favour.

The Supreme Court of Victoria found that the Crown's concession of an error in the facts underpinning the sentence was significant. Given the likelihood of a different, and potentially non-custodial, sentence being imposed if the applicant were re-sentenced, the court determined that it would be fair to grant the applicant bail. The court applied the principles from the decision in Re Zoudi, which supported the granting of bail in circumstances where an error in the sentencing process was acknowledged, and there was a substantial possibility of a lesser sentence being imposed. The court also noted the risk of the applicant serving time in custody unnecessarily if bail were denied.

As a result of the court's reasoning, the applicant was granted bail pending the outcome of the appeal. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the applicant would not serve time in custody if a lesser sentence was likely to be imposed following the correction of the errors in the original sentencing process. This decision underscores the principle that a defendant should not be subjected to unnecessary detention when there is a significant chance that their sentence will be reduced.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mohamed Abdul Fattah was convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for various criminal offences. The sentencing judge relied on certain facts during the sentencing process. Subsequently, it was identified that some of these facts were incorrect. The Crown conceded that the sentencing was based on incorrect facts. Following this concession, Fattah appealed against his sentence, arguing that a different sentence should be imposed if the appeal were allowed. During the pendency of the appeal, Fattah applied for bail, contending that a non-custodial sentence might be imposed if the appeal succeeded, and it would be unfair for him to remain in custody while awaiting the outcome of the appeal. The Crown did not oppose the bail application.

The case came before the court on an application for bail pending the determination of Fattah's appeal against sentence. The primary instance of the case involved Fattah being convicted and sentenced to imprisonment. Following the identification of errors in the facts used during sentencing, Fattah appealed to the court against his sentence. During the appeal process, Fattah applied for bail, arguing against the risk of serving time in custody unnecessarily pending the appeal's resolution. The Crown did not oppose the bail application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a different sentence is likely to be imposed if the appeal against sentence is allowed.
2. Whether a non-custodial sentence is open if the applicant is re-sentenced.
3. Whether it would be fair for the applicant to remain in custody while awaiting the outcome of the appeal.
4. Whether the principles in Re Zoudi (2007) 14 VR 580 apply to grant bail pending the appeal.

Held
1. The court concluded that a different sentence is likely to be imposed if the appeal against sentence is allowed due to the Crown's concession of an error in the sentencing facts.
2. The court found that a non-custodial sentence is open if the applicant is re-sentenced, considering the Crown's concession and the nature of the offence.
3. The court held that it would not be fair for the applicant to remain in custody while awaiting the outcome of the appeal due to the risk of serving time unnecessarily.
4. The court granted bail pending the appeal, applying the principles in Re Zoudi (2007) 14 VR 580.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of whether a different sentence is likely to be imposed if the appeal against sentence is allowed. It noted the Crown's concession of an error in the sentencing facts, which indicated that the sentence might be altered. The court considered the nature of the offence and the circumstances under which the original sentence was passed, leading to the conclusion that a different sentence was likely.

Next, the court examined whether a non-custodial sentence was open if the applicant was re-sentenced. It took into account the Crown's concession and the fact that the applicant had no prior convictions. The court found that a non-custodial sentence was a viable option, considering these factors and the overall circumstances of the case.

The fairness of keeping the applicant in custody while awaiting the appeal outcome was also scrutinized. The court acknowledged the risk of the applicant serving time unnecessarily if the appeal was successful. Weighing this against the potential danger to the community, the court determined that it would not be fair to keep the applicant in custody.

Finally, the court applied the principles from Re Zoudi (2007) 14 VR 580 to grant bail pending the appeal. It found that the principles, which consider the balance of convenience and the risk of unnecessary detention, were applicable. The court concluded that granting bail was necessary to ensure fairness and to avoid the risk of the applicant serving time unnecessarily. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where there is a likelihood of a different sentence being imposed due to an error in sentencing facts, and where it is not unfair to the community to grant bail, bail pending appeal may be granted.