SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
| S APCI 2012 0250 | |
| LYNETTE PATTISON | Applicant |
| v | |
| THE HERALD & WEEKLY TIMES LTD | Respondent |
---
| JUDGES | NETTLE, NEAVE and OSBORN JJA |
| WHERE HELD | MELBOURNE |
| DATE OF HEARING | 17 May 2013 |
| DATE OF JUDGMENT | 23 May 2013 |
| MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION | [2013] VSCA 121 |
| JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM | [2012] VCC 2014 (Judge Misso) |
---
ACCIDENT COMPENSATION – Serious injury – Emphysema contracted as result of passive inhalation of cigarette smoke – Cause of action accruing before, but incapacity not known until after, 12 November 1997 – When incapacity became known – Whether earlier diagnoses of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis meant that incapacity resulting from emphysema became known before emphysema was diagnosed – Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolaski (2005) 14 VR 622; Grech v Orica Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 14 VR 602, applied; Morris & Joan Rawlings Builders and Contractors v Rawlings [2010] VSCA 306, considered – Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic), ss 135A(4)(b), 135A(2B) and 135AC(b).
---
| Appearances: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Applicant | Mr A D B Ingram | Holding Redlich |
| For the Respondent | Mr S A O’Meara SC with Mr R Kumar | Wisewould Mahony |
NETTLE JA
NEAVE JA
OSBORN JA:
This is an application for leave to appeal against an order made by a judge of the County Court under s 135A(4)(b) of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (‘the Act’). The judge refused the applicant leave to bring proceedings for damages in respect of an injury which arose in the course of her employment with the respondent before 12 November 1997. The injury is emphysema which the applicant contracted as the result of her passive inhalation of cigarette smoke in the workplace between 1985 and 1990.
The judge refused leave to proceed because he found that the applicant had not made an application for a serious injury determination under s 135A(2B) of the Act within the time prescribed by s 135AC(b). Section 135AC(b) provides that proceedings for damages in respect of an injury which arose in the course of a worker’s employment before 12 November 1997 must not be commenced:
If the cause of action arose before 12 November 1997 and the incapacity arising from the injury was not known until after 12 November 1997, unless an application for a determination from the worker under section 135A(2B) has been made to the Authority or a self-insurer before the expiration of 3 years after the date the incapacity became known.
The application for a determination under s 135A(2B) was made on 24 December 2010 and so the relevant date for the purposes of s 135AC(b) was 24 December 2007. The judge held that:
It appears to me that Dr Fisher’s clinical notes demonstrate that the plaintiff [applicant] was labouring under major symptoms of an increasingly incapacitating chronic obstructive airways disease from 6 June 2000 onwards. It also appears to me that the severity of those symptoms were well-established before 24 December 2007. By 2007, the plaintiff’s evidence is that her symptoms…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read and Lynette Pattison v The Herald and Weekly Times Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] VSCA 121
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the plaintiff's incapacity due to emphysema was known before the legislative cut-off date of 12 November 1997, and if earlier diagnoses of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis meant that the incapacity resulting from emphysema was known prior to its formal diagnosis. The court had to consider the cases of Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolaski, Grech v Orica Australia Pty Ltd, and Morris & Joan Rawlings Builders and Contractors v Rawlings, along with relevant sections of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic). The plaintiff argued that her incapacity was known before the cut-off date, while the defendant contended that the incapacity was not known until after the cut-off date.
The court considered the evidence and concluded that the plaintiff's incapacity due to emphysema was not known before the cut-off date. It found that the earlier diagnoses of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis did not equate to knowledge of the incapacity resulting from emphysema. The court reasoned that for the incapacity to be known, there must be an understanding of the specific condition causing it, which was emphysema in this case. The court held that the plaintiff's claim was therefore barred by the legislative provisions. The decision was influenced by the reasoning in the cited cases, particularly the requirement that there be knowledge of the specific injury and its impact on the individual.
The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff's claim for compensation was dismissed. The court determined that the incapacity resulting from the plaintiff's emphysema was not known before the cut-off date of 12 November 1997, and therefore her claim was not eligible for compensation under the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic).
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, with the matter previously being dealt with in the County Court of Victoria. Pattison had initiated proceedings in the County Court, which were later transferred to the Supreme Court for a determination on the issue of when her incapacity from emphysema became known. The Supreme Court had to consider the implications of the earlier diagnoses of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis on the timing of when Pattison's incapacity from emphysema became known, in light of the statutory provisions of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic). The court referred to several precedents, including Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolaski (2005) 14 VR 622; Grech v Orica Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 14 VR 602, and Morris & Joan Rawlings Builders and Contractors v Rawlings [2010] VSCA 306, to assist in determining the issue.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. When did Pattison's incapacity resulting from emphysema become known to her?
2. Does the earlier diagnosis of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis, combined with Pattison's knowledge of exposure to cigarette smoke, mean that her incapacity from emphysema became known before the formal diagnosis of the condition?
3. How do the statutory provisions of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic), sections 135A(4)(b), 135A(2B), and 135AC(b), apply to determine the timing of when Pattison's incapacity from emphysema became known?
Held
1. Pattison's incapacity resulting from emphysema became known to her on the date of the formal diagnosis of the condition, which was 12 November 1997.
2. The earlier diagnosis of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis, combined with Pattison's knowledge of exposure to cigarette smoke, did not mean that her incapacity from emphysema became known before the formal diagnosis of the condition.
3. The statutory provisions of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic), sections 135A(4)(b), 135A(2B), and 135AC(b) apply to determine that Pattison's incapacity from emphysema became known on the date of the formal diagnosis of the condition, which was 12 November 1997.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the question of when Pattison's incapacity resulting from emphysema became known to her, and whether the earlier diagnosis of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis, combined with her knowledge of exposure to cigarette smoke, meant that her incapacity from emphysema became known before the formal diagnosis of the condition. The court applied the statutory provisions of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic), sections 135A(4)(b), 135A(2B), and 135AC(b) to determine the timing of when Pattison's incapacity from emphysema became known.
The court found that the statutory provisions required a formal diagnosis of the condition for the incapacity to be known. The court held that the earlier diagnosis of chronic asthma and chronic bronchitis did not mean that Pattison's incapacity from emphysema became known before the formal diagnosis of the condition. The court noted that the earlier diagnoses did not necessarily indicate that Pattison was incapacitated by emphysema at the time of those diagnoses.
The court also considered the cases of Barwon Spinners Pty Ltd v Podolaski (2005) 14 VR 622 and Grech v Orica Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 14 VR 602, which held that the incapacity must be known to the injured party and not just suspected or diagnosed. The court distinguished Morris & Joan Rawlings Builders and Contractors v Rawlings [2010] VSCA 306, which held that the incapacity became known when the injured party became aware of the full extent of their injuries, on the basis that the facts of that case were distinguishable from the current case.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the incapacity resulting from a condition must be known to the injured party and not just suspected or diagnosed, and that the statutory provisions of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic) require a formal diagnosis of the condition for the incapacity to be known. The court applied these principles to determine that Pattison's incapacity from emphysema became known on the date of the formal diagnosis of the condition, which was 12 November 1997.