Amp v Kien Dan Luu Pty Ltd & Ors No. DCCIV-97-9 Judgment No. D3775

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

AUSTRALIAN MUTUAL PROVIDENT SOCIETY V KIEN DAN LUU PTY LTD, KIEN DAN LUU AND VLASSIA SOULA LUU

Civil
Judge Pirone

On the 25th day of February 1998 I published my findings in relation to this matter and my reasons for those findings.

In those reasons I said that the effect of my findings was that both the claim and the counterclaim had been proved, but that the net result would be judgment for the corporate defendant in the sum of $14,994, and judgment for the personal defendants in the sum of $600.  I did not enter final judgment on that occasion because I was anxious that the parties, and their representatives, should be afforded a reasonable opportunity to consider my reasons and, if possible, to file minutes, for orders to be made by consent in conformity with my reasons, as published.

I allowed the parties until close of business on Monday the 2nd day of March 1998 for that purpose and indicated that if, for whatever reason, they should be unable to agree, I would wish to hear further from counsel on any topic not covered in my reasons, and on which they would wish to address me, as well as, and in particular of course, on what precise orders should be made in conformity with those reasons.

The parties have been unable to reach agreement on some of the outstanding issues and the matter came back before me on the 4th day of March 1998 to resolve the dispute on those topics about which the parties remained deadlocked.

I heard arguments, and I received submissions, on that date but, because I had been referred to various authorities, I wanted an opportunity to re-read those authorities and consider the matter further.  With that purpose in mind, I adjourned to today in order to deliver my ruling on the unresolved questions, and to enter final judgment.

Each party claims interest on the judgment to which that party is entitled. Each party accepts that each of them is respectively entitled to interest, which should be calculated in accordance with the provisions of section 39 of the District Court Act. The parties are agreed on the rate at which such interest is to be paid, but remain deadlocked as to the date from which that interest should be calculated. I think that there is a simpler way in which the dispute may be resolved.

Sub-section 3 of Section 39 of the District Court Act provides that:-

“the Court may, without proceeding to calculate interest under subsection (2), award a lump sum instead of interest.”

I propose to exercise my discretion under that Section and accordingly, therefore, I propose to allow a lump sum in lieu of interest.

When fixing that lump sum I have borne in mind that, because the plaintiff’s claim is for a liquidated demand, the period from which interest should run is from when the liability to pay the amount of the claim fell due.  My findings on that topic…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Amp v Kien Dan Luu Pty Ltd & Ors No. DCCIV-97-9 Judgment No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SADC 3969
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a dispute between the Australian Mutual Provident Society (AMPS) and Kien Dan Luu Pty Ltd, Kien Dan Luu, and Vlassia Soula Luu. The AMPS brought a claim against the defendants, and the defendants counterclaimed against the AMPS. The matter was heard in the District Court of South Australia. The primary legal issues before the court were the calculation of interest on the judgments and the allocation of costs between the parties.

The court addressed the issue of interest on the judgments by considering the provisions of Section 39 of the District Court Act. The parties agreed on the rate of interest but disagreed on the date from which the interest should be calculated. The court exercised its discretion under Section 39 and awarded a lump sum in lieu of interest, considering the nature of the claims and counterclaims.

Regarding the allocation of costs, the court examined the parties' submissions and the relevant rules and authorities. The court determined that it had discretion to order a successful party to pay part or all of the opponent's costs, depending on the circumstances. The court considered various factors, including the parties' conduct during the trial and the success or failure on specific issues. The court ultimately ordered that the plaintiff pay 50% of the remaining costs to the corporate defendant and allowed the plaintiff to offset its costs against the corporate defendant's judgment.

Final Orders:
1. The plaintiff is awarded judgment against the defendants in the sum of $23,750.00 inclusive of interest.
2. The personal defendants are awarded judgment against the plaintiff in the sum of $750 inclusive of interest.
3. The corporate defendant is awarded judgment against the plaintiff in the sum of $41,200 inclusive of interest, which is offset against the plaintiff's judgment.
4. The plaintiff shall pay the corporate defendant the balance of $17,450.
5. The plaintiff shall pay 50% of the remaining costs of the proceedings to the corporate defendant.
6. The plaintiff may offset its costs against the corporate defendant's judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established