Amlin Corporate Member Ltd v Austcorp Project No 20 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Amlin Corporate Member Ltd v Austcorp Project No 20 Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 78

Citation: Amlin Corporate Member Ltd v Austcorp Project No 20 Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 78
Appeal from: Austcorp Project No 20 Pty Ltd v LM Investment Management Ltd, in the matter of Bellpac Pty Ltd (receivers and managers appointed) (in liq) (No 2) [2014] FCA 44
Parties: AMLIN CORPORATE MEMBER LIMITED (UK COMPANY NO 02969411) TRADING AS AMLIN SYNDICATE 2001 AT LLOYD'S and MARKEL CAPITAL LIMITED (UK COMPANY NO 03114572) TRADING AS MARKEL SYDNICATE 3000 AT LLOYD'S AND THE CHANNEL SYNDICATE LLP (UK COMPANY NO OC359898) TRADING AS CHANNEL SYNDICATE 2014 AT LLOYD'S v AUSTCORP PROJECT NO 20 PTY LIMITED ACN 111 470 725, COMPROMISE CREDITORS MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED ACN 122 143 220 and LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LTD (IN LIQ) ACN 077 208 461
File number(s): NSD 189 of 2014
Judge(s): ALLSOP CJ, MIDDLETON & GLEESON JJ
Date of judgment: 30 June 2014
Catchwords:

INSURANCE – professional indemnity insurance – claims made policy – definition of “claim” and “counter-claim” – whether Commercial List Response in NSW Supreme Court proceedings constituted a “claim” to which the insurance policy responds – definition of “civil liability” – principles for determining whether insurer liable to indemnify – appeal dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to appeal interlocutory decision – leave granted

Cases cited: AWA v Exicom (1990) 19 NSWLR 705
Capel v Butler (1825) 57 ER 421
China & South Seas Bank v Tan [1990] 1 AC 536
Chittick v Maxwell (1993) 118 ALR 728
Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397; [1991] FCA 655
Deutsche National Bank v Paul [1898] 1 Ch 283
Ex parte Bucknell (1936) 56 CLR 221, [1936] HCA 67
GE Capital Australia v Davis (2002) 180 FLR 250
Hall v Bonnett [1956] SASR 10
Johnston v Cameron (2002) 124 FCR 160; [2002] FCAFC 251
Kyriackou v ACE Insurance Ltd [2013] VSCA 150
Littlewood v George Wimpey & Co Ltd and BOAC [1953] 1 QB 501
Lord v Direct Acceptance Corporation Ltd (1993) 32 NSWLR 362
Mayne Nickless Limited v Multigroup Distribution Services Pty Limited (2001) 114 FCR 108, [2001] FCA 1620
Minogue v Williams [2000] FCA 125
Myers v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co (1994) 115 DLR (4th) 607
Myers v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co (1994) 18 OR (3d) 475
Pearl v Deacon (1857) 53 ER 328
Strange v Fooks (1863) 66 ER 765
Taylor v Bank of New South Wales (1886) 11 App Cas 596
Ultimate Property Group Pty Ltd v Lord (2004) 60 NSWLR 646
Walton v National Employers’ Insurance Association [1973] 2 NSWLR 73
Watts v Shuttleworth (1861) 158 ER 510
Wulff v Jay (1872) LR 7 QB 756
Date of hearing: 6 May 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 76
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr J E Marshall SC with Mr D H Mitchell
Solicitor for…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Amlin Corporate Member Ltd v Austcorp Project No 20 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCAFC 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Amlin Corporate Member Ltd brought an appeal against the decision of the primary judge in the Federal Court of Australia, challenging the interpretation of a professional indemnity insurance policy. The central issue was whether the Commercial List Response filed in the NSW Supreme Court proceedings constituted a "claim" under the policy, entitling the insurer to indemnify the insured party, Austcorp Project No 20 Pty Ltd. The court had to determine whether the Commercial List Response, which asserted a right to raise certain defences to an action on a guarantee, was a "claim" within the definition provided in the policy.

The court examined the definition of "claim" and "counter-claim" in the policy and considered whether the Commercial List Response met the criteria to be classified as a "claim." The Insurers argued that the Commercial List Response was a "counter-claim" because it was designed to counter the demands of LM against Mr Wong. However, the court found that the Commercial List Response did not contain any express claim of liability of LM to account to Bellpac or any claim for relief made by Bellpac. The expression "Equitable Compensation" in the Commercial List Response referred to a reduction of LM’s claim under the guarantee, not an allegation that LM had to pay an amount by way of equitable compensation to Bellpac. The court concluded that the Commercial List Response did not fall within the definition of "claim" under the policy.

The appeal was dismissed with costs, and the primary judge's decision was upheld. The court found that the Commercial List Response did not constitute a "claim" within the meaning of the insurance policy, and therefore, the insurer was not liable to indemnify the insured party. The court granted leave to appeal but dismissed the appeal, affirming the primary judge's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal be granted.

2. The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There are several difficulties with this argument:a)There is no express claim in the Commercial List Response of any liability of LM to account to Bellpac;b)There is no claim for relief made by Bellpac in the Commercial List Response;c)There is no express claim by Mr Wong for any relief based upon LM’s alleged liability to account to Bellpac;d)When used in paragraph 105 of the Commercial List Response, the expression “Equitable Compensation” appears to refer to an amount by which Mr Wong claims to be entitled to a reduction of LM’s claim under the relevant guarantee. Contrary to the submission of Senior Counsel for the Insurers, it does not contain an allegation that LM has to pay an amount by way of equitable compensation to Bellpac (or Mr Wong);e)The entitlement of a surety to a pro tanto discharge of liability under a guarantee does not arise solely from an equitable set off but also from the same principle by which a surety may be entitled to a complete discharge. The general proposition is that equity intervenes to protect a surety: China & South Seas Bank v Tan [1990] 1 AC 536 at 544. See also Watts v Shuttleworth (1861) 158 ER 510 at 510-511, Capel v Butler (1825) 57 ER 421, Strange v Fooks (1863) 66 ER 765, Wulff v Jay (1872) LR 7 QB 756, Pearl v Deacon (1857) 53 ER 328, and Taylor v Bank of New South Wales (1886) 11 App Cas 596.f)As explained above, to the extent that the Commercial List Response did assert a liability on the part of LM to account to Bellpac, that assertion was made in support of the existence of an equitable defence and did not involve or require the establishment by judgment of LM’s responsibility in law to Bellpac.Conclusion The primary judge answered the separate question correctly. The appeal must be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Senior Counsel for the Insurers acknowledged that the Commercial List Response did not contain any relevant allegation that LM had breached a duty owed to Mr Wong (although the existence of such a duty was pleaded at paragraph 60 of the Commercial List Response). It was not suggested that the Commercial List Response fell within the insuring clause because it contained a “Claim” made against LM by Mr Wong. Rather, the Insurers’ primary contention was that paragraph 65 of the Commercial List Response involves an allegation that Bellpac would be entitled to the taking of an account. As Senior Counsel for the Insurers put it, by the Commercial List Response, Mr Wong “counterclaimed Bellpac’s claim against LM”. ConsiderationIs the Commercial List Response a “Claim”? The Insurers maintained that the Commercial List Response fell within both sub-clauses (a) and (b) of the definition of “Claim” although, as to sub-clause (a), they acknowledged that the Commercial List Response did not claim “compensation or damages”. On that basis, the Commercial List Response does not fall within sub-clause (a). As to sub-clause (b), the issue is whether the Commercial List Response is “a suit, civil … proceedings [or a] counter-claim…brought against [LM]”. The Insurers did not suggest that the Commercial List Response was a suit or civil proceeding per se. Rather, the Insurers argued that the Commercial List Response is a “counter-claim” because it was “designed to counter the demands of LM” against Mr Wong. It was not suggested that the Commercial List Response was a “suit” or “civil proceedings” on any separate basis. The applicants relied on the decision of Myers v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co (1994) 18 OR (3d) 475 (“Myers”), affirmed on appeal: Myers v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co (1994) 115 DLR (4th) 607. In Myers, it was held that a claim for set off was a “civil suit” within the relevant insurance policy. That case involved a claim by architects for professional fees. The clients claimed, by way of set off, damages resulting from the architects’ negligence. In its reasons for dismissing an application for leave to appeal, the Ontario Court of Appeal noted that the damages claimed by way of set off, when assessed, would represent damages which the architects “would be required to pay or assume in the form of diminution of their claim for fees and disbursements”. Myers does not support a conclusion that the Commercial List Response is a suit, civil proceedings or a counter-claim within the meaning of the definition of “Claim” in the policy. In Myers, the issue was the insured’s entitlement to coverage under a provision by which the insurer agreed to defend the insured “in any civil suit…arising out of a claim for which coverage” was provided by the policy. Thus, the issue concerned the construction of a different form of insuring clause. Further, in Myers the matters pleaded by way of set off could have been (and had been) pleaded by way of a separate counter-claim for damages. In contrast, in the Commercial List Response, Mr Wong asserted a right to raise certain defences to an action on a guarantee. He did not claim any relief against LM Investment Management in the Commercial List Response.