| [2024] FWC 2675 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Amit Singhal
v
National Australia Bank Limited
(U2024/3994)
| COMMISSIONER FOX | MELBOURNE, 8 OCTOBER 2024 |
Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objections raised by the respondent – objection that applicant is not employed by the respondent and not an Australian-based employee – exception found under s.35(3) – application dismissed.
On 7 April 2024, Mr Amit Singhal (the Applicant) filed a remedy for unfair dismissal application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act). In his application, the Applicant named the Respondent as National Australia Bank Limited (the Respondent).
The Respondent filed a Form F3 in which it raised three jurisdictional objections to the application. The objections are as follows:[1]
1. The Respondent is not the employer of the Applicant;
2. The Applicant is not an Australian-based employee; and
3. The Applicant resigned from his employment.
This Decision deals with the first two jurisdictional objections.
I conducted a Hearing of the matter on 3 September 2024. The parties filed material in accordance with Directions, which was then compiled into a Digital Hearing Book. The Digital Hearing Book was accepted into evidence at the Hearing without objection from either party.
In considering the evidence of the parties, I uphold the two jurisdictional objections of the Respondent. The reasons for my decision follow.
Background and Submissions
The Applicant, in his unfair dismissal application, names National Australia Bank Limited (NAB) as his employer.
The Respondent submits that the Applicant is employed by NAB Global Innovation Centre India Private Limited (NICI). NICI is a wholly owned subsidiary of NAB.[2] Both parties made submissions about the nature and structure of NICI and its relationship to NAB.
The Respondent submits that the Applicant cannot seek a remedy for unfair dismissal as he was not employed by the Respondent, and therefore not employed by a national system employer within the meaning of s.14 of the Act.[3]
The Respondent further submits that the Applicant was not an Australian-based employee under s.35 of the Act.
The Applicant submits that NICI is a foreign corporation and submits that ‘any corporation which is formed outside of Australia is termed as a foreign corporation to the parent. Such [sic] foreign corporation when employs an employee to work in its Australian business is likely to be a national system employer and therefore fall within the jurisdiction of the Fair Work Commission.’[4] He cites ss.13 and 14 of the Act and refers to Glenn Gardner v Milka-Ware International Ltd[5] (‘Gardner’).
The Applicant’s reliance on ss.13 and 14 of the Act and Gardner is misconceived. NICI is not a national system employer under s.14 of the Act. Gardner determined that a foreign corporation may be covered by s.14 to the extent that it employs employees to work in Australia.[6] There is no evidence that NICI employs employees to work in Australia.
The Applicant’s reliance on Gardner
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Amit Singhal v National Australia Bank Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWC 2675
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issues were whether the Applicant was employed by the Respondent and whether he was an Australian-based employee under the Fair Work Act 2009. The Respondent contended that the Applicant was employed by its wholly-owned subsidiary, NAB Global Innovation Centre India Private Limited (NICI), and not by the Respondent itself. The Applicant argued that NICI, being a foreign corporation employing him to work in Australia, should be considered a national system employer within the meaning of the Act. The Respondent further argued that the Applicant was not an Australian-based employee as his primary place of work was in India and the exemption in s.35(3) of the Act applied.
The Commission found that the Applicant was indeed employed by NICI and not by the Respondent, as evidenced by the clear terms of the employment contract signed in India. The contract identified NICI as the employer and specified that the primary place of work was in India. Additionally, the Commission held that the exemption in s.35(3) applied, as the Applicant's employment contract was formed and executed in India, and he performed his duties exclusively in India. Therefore, the Applicant did not meet the criteria to be considered an Australian-based employee under s.35(2) of the Act.
The Commission upheld the Respondent's jurisdictional objections and dismissed the Applicant's unfair dismissal application, concluding that it did not have jurisdiction over the matter. An Order to this effect will be issued with this Decision.