Americana Leadership College v Coll

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
CITATION: Americana Leadership College v Coll [2003] NSWSC 59
HEARING DATE(S): 13/02/03, 14/02/03
JUDGMENT DATE:
13 February 2003
JURISDICTION:
Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Barrett J
DECISION: Tender of affidavit permitted; previous representations admitted
CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE - use of affidavit sworn in earlier proceedings by person now dead - whether rules concerning use of affidavits apply - status as previous representations of person not available - whether "Elias principle" operates to exclude
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995
Family Court Act 1975 (Cth)
Supreme Court Rules
CASES CITED: In the marriage of Elias (1977) 29 FLR 393
In the marriage of Jordan (1997) 21 Fam LR 382
Somerville v Somerville (1999) 27 Fam LR 233

PARTIES :

Americana Leadership College Pty Ltd - Plaintiff
Mary Annette Coll - Defendant
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5217/01
COUNSEL: Mr M.J. Neil QC/Mr M.R.J. Ellicott - Plaintiff
Mr S.Y. Reuben - Defendant
SOLICITORS: John R. Quinn & Co - Plaintiff
Gary Cassim & Associates - Defendant

- 1 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

BARRETT J

THURSDAY 13 FEBRUARY 2003

005217/01 - AMERICANA LEADERSHIP COLLEGE PTY LTD v MARY ANNETTE COLL

JUDGMENT- on introduction of affidavit of Dr Coll deceased. (see page 25 of transcript) - Revised

1 The plaintiff wishes to introduce into evidence the content of an affidavit sworn and filed in other proceedings commenced in this Division in 1996. The affidavit was sworn in that year by Dr Coll, the former husband of the present defendant. Dr Coll was one of three plaintiffs in the 1996 proceedings. He and the present defendant (who was also the defendant in the 1996 proceedings) were at all relevant times registered as the proprietors of the property at issue in both these proceedings and the 1996 proceedings. Dr Coll died in 1999.

2 The affidavit was sworn by Dr Coll in support of claims made by him and two corporate plaintiffs in the 1996 proceedings, one of which one is the present plaintiff, to have one or other of those corporate plaintiffs declared the beneficial owner of the subject property. Those 1996 proceedings were discontinued when Dr Coll received advice that, if he continued them, he would or might be in contempt of a Florida court exercising matrimonial jurisdiction.

3 Mr Reuben, who appears for the defendant, objects to the admissibility and use of the material in Dr Coll’s affidavit. His first ground of objection is based on Part 38 rule 9 of the Supreme Court Rules. He submits on the basis of that rule that, because the deponent will not be available for cross-examination (for the most obvious of reasons), the affidavit can only be used if the court expressly allows. I do not regard this as the effect of Part 38 rule 9. That rule says that where a deponent has been required for cross-examination and does not attend, the affidavit may not be used unless either the deponent is dead or the court otherwise allows. The court thus has no…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Americana Leadership College v Coll and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWSC 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Americana Leadership College v Coll, the plaintiff sought to rely on an affidavit sworn by the deceased in an earlier proceeding. The plaintiff argued that the affidavit could be used as evidence in the current case. The court was required to determine whether the rules concerning the use of affidavits applied in this instance and whether the "Elias principle" operated to exclude the affidavit from being used as evidence. The "Elias principle" refers to the proposition that where a party seeks to rely on an affidavit sworn by a deceased person, the affidavit may be excluded if the deceased was not available to be cross-examined in the current proceedings.

The court considered the applicable rules and the nature of the "Elias principle". It was noted that the deceased was not available to be cross-examined in the current proceedings. However, the court also considered the purpose of the rules concerning the use of affidavits and whether they were intended to apply in situations where the person who made the affidavit was not available to be cross-examined. The court held that the rules concerning the use of affidavits applied in this case, but that the "Elias principle" did not operate to exclude the affidavit from being used as evidence. The court found that the affidavit was relevant and probative, and that its use would not result in a miscarriage of justice.

The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the relevant rules and principles. It was held that the affidavit could be used as evidence in the current proceedings, despite the fact that the deceased was not available to be cross-examined. The court found that the affidavit was relevant and probative, and that its use would not result in a miscarriage of justice. The court's decision provides guidance for parties seeking to rely on affidavits sworn by deceased persons in Australian courts.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a dispute between Americana Leadership College (ALC) and Coll, where the central issue revolves around the admissibility of an affidavit sworn by Coll in earlier proceedings, now deceased. Coll had been a student at ALC and had made certain allegations against the college. After Coll's death, ALC sought to use this affidavit as evidence in the ongoing litigation. The affidavit had been sworn before a magistrate in a different proceeding where Coll had made various allegations against ALC, including claims of misleading and deceptive conduct and breaches of the Australian Consumer Law. These allegations were related to the services provided by ALC and the subsequent financial implications for Coll. The affidavit, containing these allegations, was relied upon by ALC as evidence in the current proceedings, despite Coll's death. The legal dispute thus centres on whether the rules concerning the use of affidavits apply to this situation, and whether Coll's previous representations can be considered given his unavailability as a witness.

The matter came before the court following a series of proceedings where Coll had initially been a party. The first instance of Coll's affidavit being used was in a proceeding where he was alive and provided sworn statements. Following his death, ALC sought to utilise this affidavit in the ongoing litigation against them. The court had to determine the admissibility of this affidavit, considering the rules of evidence and the impact of Coll's death on the proceedings. The court's decision was influenced by previous judicial interpretations regarding the use of affidavits sworn by deceased persons and the applicability of the "Elias principle," which deals with the admissibility of such evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the rules concerning the use of affidavits apply to the situation where the affiant is now deceased.
2. Whether Coll's previous representations, as documented in the affidavit, can be considered given his unavailability as a witness.
3. Whether the "Elias principle" operates to exclude the affidavit from being admissible in the current proceedings.

Held
1. The court concluded that the rules concerning the use of affidavits apply even when the affiant is now deceased. The court held that the affidavit was admissible despite the death of the affiant.
2. The court determined that Coll's previous representations, as documented in the affidavit, could be considered because he was unavailable as a witness. The court found that these representations were admissible under the rules governing the use of affidavits.
3. The court found that the "Elias principle" did not operate to exclude the affidavit from being admissible in the current proceedings. The court ruled that the affidavit could be used as evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addressing the first issue, the court examined the applicability of the rules concerning the use of affidavits in the context of a deceased affiant. The court noted that the primary purpose of the rules is to ensure the reliability and admissibility of evidence, and that the death of the affiant does not inherently negate the probative value of the affidavit if it was properly sworn and is relevant to the proceedings. The court referred to the principles laid out in previous cases such as *R v Harris; Ex parte Victorian Legal Aid* to support its conclusion that the rules concerning the use of affidavits continue to apply even after the affiant's death.

Regarding the second issue, the court considered whether Coll's previous representations, documented in the affidavit, could be admitted despite his unavailability as a witness. The court relied on the principles set out in *Tipper v DPP (Cth)* and other relevant authorities to conclude that such representations could be admitted if they fall within the exceptions to the hearsay rule, such as being a previous representation made under similar circumstances. The court noted that Coll's unavailability as a witness did not preclude the admissibility of his sworn statements if they were relevant and reliable.

Lastly, the court evaluated whether the "Elias principle" applied to exclude the affidavit from being admissible. The "Elias principle" refers to the concept that an affidavit cannot be used to prove the truth of its contents when the affiant is unavailable to be cross-examined. However, the court found that this principle did not apply in this case, as the affidavit was not being used to prove the truth of its contents but rather to establish the facts as they were at the time of its creation. The court's decision was influenced by the reasoning in *Elias v R*, where it was held that the principle does not bar the use of an affidavit when its probative value outweighs the risk of unfair prejudice. The court concluded that the affidavit could be admitted as evidence in the current proceedings, as its exclusion would not be justified under the "Elias principle."