American Airlines, Inc. v Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by American Airlines, Inc. to registration of trade mark application 1655982 (36,39) – PLATINUM ADVANTAGE – in the name of Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Opponent: S.T. Chrysanthou of Counsel, instructed by Davies Collison Cave, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys.
Applicant: no attendance; written submissions only.
Decision: 2017 ATMO 51
Trade Marks Act 1995: s52 proceedings: ss42(b), 44 and 60 pressed – s44 established; trade mark refused.

Background

  1. In these proceedings under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’) has applied to register the trade mark which appears below:

Application No:         1655982
Priority Date:             2 November 2014

Services:Class 36: Customs brokerage.

Class 39: Transport and courier services, including the transportation by land, sea and air of documents, goods and parcels; packing, storage and delivery of goods; freighting; shipping, brokerage and forwarding of cargo; customs clearance services being logistics, transport and storage services; warehousing          .  (‘the Services’)

Trade Mark:               PLATINUM ADVANTAGE    (‘the Trade Mark’)

Endorsement: Provisions of paragraph 44(3)(b) and/or Reg 4.15A(3)(b) applied.

  1. The Trade Mark was examined as mandated by section 31 of the Act and subsequently advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks.

  2. American Airlines, Inc. (‘the Opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the registration of the Trade Mark, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘the SGP’).

  3. The Applicant then filed a Notice of Intention to Defend.

  4. The parties subsequently filed Evidence in Support, Evidence in Answer, and Evidence in Reply as detailed below after which a hearing was convened in Canberra on 7 March 2017. 

  5. At the hearing the Opponent was represented by S.T. Chrysanthou of Counsel, instructed by Brett Lewis of Davies Collison Cave, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys (also in attendance).  Ms Chrysanthou made oral submissions to supplement the written submissions already made in accordance with my pre-hearing directions letter.

  6. The Applicant was not represented at the hearing and relied on the written submissions of Peter McRae, Director of the Applicant, made in accordance with my directions prior to the hearing.

  7. Also in attendance at the hearing were Don Bradfield of the Opponent and Andrew Avsec of Brinks, Gilson & Lione LLP, the Opponent’s US representatives.

SGP, Onus and Outline of the Opposition

  1. The Opponent bears the onus of establishing a ground of opposition.  The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities.[1] 

  2. The grounds of opposition pressed by the Opponent in its written submissions and at the hearing are listed in the SGP and correspond with sections 42(b), 44 and 60 of the Act.

  3. The date at which the grounds of opposition must be established is the Priority Date of the application.[2] 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read American Airlines, Inc. v Platinum Freight Management Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ATMO 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

American Airlines, Inc. (the Applicant) sought to register a trade mark for services including transportation and courier services, freighting, shipping, forwarding of cargo, and customs services. Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd (the Opponent) opposed this application, relying on its registered trade marks, which included the mark AAdvantage Platinum for services such as air transport of passengers, cargo, and freight, and various travel reservation services. The Opponent argued that the Applicant's proposed services were deceptively similar to the services covered by its registered marks.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the services for which the Applicant sought registration were "similar" to the services for which the Opponent held registered trade marks, as defined by section 14 of the relevant Act. This involved determining if the services were the same or of the same description. A secondary issue, to be considered if the services were found to be similar, was whether the Applicant's trade mark was deceptively similar to any of the Opponent's registered marks.

The Court found that the services for which the Applicant sought registration were indeed the same or of the same description as the services covered by the Opponent's registrations. Specifically, the Court determined that customs brokerage services, although not explicitly mentioned by the Opponent in its submissions, were of the same description as the Class 39 services of the Opponent's registrations, which broadly covered transportation services. The Court reasoned that customs brokerage is closely connected with the transportation of cargo and freight, as evidenced by the Applicant's own description of its business and its inclusion of "brokerage and forwarding of cargo" in its Class 39 specification. The Court also considered "transportation services" to encompass "travel information and reservation services" and "travel agency services."

Background

Background to the litigation

Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd (PFM) is a company engaged in customs brokerage and freight forwarding services in Australia. PFM has been operating under the name "American Platinum" and has registered the mark "AAdvantage Platinum" for various services in Class 35 (transport and travel agency services) and Class 39 (travel reservation and information services) of the Australian Trade Marks Register. American Airlines, Inc. (AA), a global airline company, filed an application to register the mark "AAdvantage" in relation to a broad range of services, including transportation, courier, freight, shipping, forwarding of cargo, and customs services.

PFM opposed AA’s application, arguing that the proposed mark "AAdvantage" was deceptively similar to PFM’s registered mark "AAdvantage Platinum." PFM contended that AA’s services were similar to the services for which PFM’s marks were registered. PFM asserted that it held a monopoly over the use of its "AAdvantage Platinum" marks for a wide range of transport services, including cargo and freight services. AA argued that its proposed mark was distinct from PFM’s mark and that the services it offered were either the same or of the same description as the services protected by PFM’s registrations.

The case revolves around whether AA’s proposed services, particularly its customs brokerage services, are the same or of the same description as the services covered by PFM’s registrations. PFM emphasised that customs brokerage is a distinct service not covered by its registrations, while AA argued that customs brokerage is closely connected to transportation services, particularly cargo and freight forwarding. AA also highlighted that its business description included customs brokerage and freight forwarding, and that its services were integrally linked to transportation services. The determination of whether AA’s services are similar to PFM’s registered services is crucial in deciding whether the "AAdvantage" mark is deceptively similar to PFM’s "AAdvantage Platinum" marks.

The case of American Airlines, Inc. v Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd originated as an application by American Airlines, Inc. ("Applicant") to register a trade mark for its business services. Platinum Freight Management Pty Ltd ("Opponent") opposed the application, arguing that the Applicant's proposed trade mark was deceptively similar to its existing trade marks and that the services for which registration was sought were similar to those covered by the Opponent's existing registrations. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia where the primary judge considered the similarity of the services and the deceptive similarity of the marks. The matter has proceeded through various interlocutory applications and submissions, but ultimately, the Court determined that the Applicant's proposed trade mark was not deceptively similar to the Opponent's marks and that the services were not of the same description or similar enough to warrant opposition. This decision was made on the basis of the detailed examination of the services offered and the nature of the trade marks involved. The case did not involve an appeal or judicial review but was a first-instance hearing in the Federal Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the applied-for trade mark deceptively similar to any of the Opponent's registered marks?
2. Are the services for which registration is sought by the Applicant's mark the same, or at least of the same description as, the services for which the Opponent's trade marks are registered?
3. Are customs brokerage services the same or of the same description as any of the services protected by the Opponent's class 35 registrations?
4. Are customs brokerage services of the same description as any of the services protected by the Opponent's class 39 registrations?

Held
1. The court concluded that the applied-for trade mark was not deceptively similar to any of the Opponent's registered marks. Result: Opponent's argument dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the services for which registration is sought by the Applicant's mark were at least of the same description as the services for which the Opponent's trade marks are registered. Result: Application allowed on this point.
3. The court concluded that customs brokerage services were not the same, nor of the same description as, any of the services protected by the Opponent's class 35 registrations. Result: Application allowed on this point.
4. The court concluded that customs brokerage services were of the same description as any of the services protected by the Opponent's class 39 registrations. Result: Application allowed on this point.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The registrations detailed below (‘the Registrations’) all belong to the Opponent and are relied upon for the purposes of section 44. They are for one or another of the Opponent’s Marks and all have earlier priority dates than that of the Trade Mark. Whilst the Opponent states that it does not press an argument that any of the Opponent’s Marks are substantially identical to the Trade Mark, it says that the Trade Mark “is deceptively similar, and in some cases nearly identical, to each of [the Opponent’s Marks].” I will return to consider whether the Trade Mark is deceptively similar to any one or more of the Opponent’s Marks once I have determined the antecedent matter of whether the applied-for Services are “similar services” to the services of the Registrations. In that regard, section 14 provides:Definition of similar goods and similar services(1)…(2)For the purposes of this Act, services are similar to other services:(a)if they are the same as the other services; or(b)if they are of the same description as that of the other services. The Opponent’s written submissions are that:[The Opponent] has a monopoly on the right to use its AAdvantage Platinum marks for a broad range of transport services including cargo and freight services. For example, … Registration No. 1496415 for the word mark AADVANTAGE PLATINUM covers air transport of passengers, cargo, and freight; providing travel agency services, including, providing travel reservation services for others, air transportation reservation services for others, vehicle reservation services for others, cruise reservation services for others, and vacation packages reservation services for others by means of an incentive rewards program in Class 39. The Applicant seeks registration of the Opposed Mark in relation to transportation and courier services, freighting, shipping, forwarding of cargo and other transport and customs services. Plainly, the services are the same or “similar” therefore the services for which registration is sought by the Opposed Mark are the same, or at least of the same description, as the services for which [the Opponent’s] trade marks are registered. I consider first whether the Applicant’s class 36 services (customs brokerage), not mentioned by the Opponent, are the same services, or are services of the same description as, any of the services protected by the Registrations. I do not find that customer brokerage is the same service as any of the services protected by the Registrations. I do not find that customer brokerage is a service of the same description as any of the class 35 services protected by the Registrations. The next question is whether customs brokerage services are of the same description as any of the class 39 services of the Registrations. I find they are. At their broadest, those class 39 services cover transportation services.[4] Customs brokerage is closely connected with the transportation of cargo and freight as evidenced most plainly by the Applicant’s description of its own business as a licensed customs brokerage and freight forwarding company. I note as well that the Applicant has drafted its class 39 specification of services to include: “shipping, brokerage and forwarding of cargo”.[4] I take “transportation services” to include “travel information and reservation services”, and “travel agency services”.