Amad Al-Aedani v G & S President Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Amad Al-Aedani v G & S President Pty Ltd [2006] NSWWCCPD 166

APPELLANT:  Amad Al-Aedani

RESPONDENT:  G & S President Pty Ltd

INSURER:Employers Mutual Indemnity

FILE NUMBER:  WCC 2335-05

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          14 July 2005

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  31 July 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Weight of the evidence

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Julian Martin

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Gerard Malouf & Partners

Respondent:   Church & Grace

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator dated 14 July 2005 is confirmed.

No order is made as to the costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 5 August 2005 Amad Al-Aedani (‘Mr Al-Aedani’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision, dated 14 July 2005.

  1. The Respondent to the Appeal is G & S President Pty Ltd (‘G & S President’).

  1. Mr Al-Aedani was born on 12 December 1969 and is 36 years of age.  He is single and claims no dependents.

  1. Born in Iraq, Mr Al-Aedani came to Australia in 1999/2000.  He commenced employment with G & S President in July 2003.  Before starting with this employer he worked as a forklift driver/storeman for an employer called Captain Lighting for approximately eight months.  Prior to that he did some casual work as a storeman for a firm known as Clean Head Gas.

  1. At G & S President Mr Al-Aedani was employed as a storeman working a 38 to 40 hour week.

  1. On 12 December 2003 Mr Al-Aedani was picking up a truck battery at work.  It weighed approximately 50kgs and had a handle on each side.  Whilst lifting the battery, one handle broke causing Mr Al-Aedani to fall on his side.  He injured his neck, right arm, lower back, right leg and right ankle.

  1. Mr Al-Aedani caught a taxi to his general practitioner, Dr Selim, who referred him for x-ray and CT scan of the injured areas and certified him unfit for work.  Mr Al-Aedani continued to be off work at the time of the arbitration hearing.

  1. Workers compensation benefits were paid, however, liability was denied on 1 March 2004 on the basis that Mr Al-Aedani was fit to resume pre-injury duties.  Weekly compensation was paid to 13 March 2004.

  1. On 15 February 2005 proceedings were commenced in the Commission by Mr Al-Aedani for weekly benefits of compensation, medical expenses and permanent impairment.  An arbitration hearing took place on 28 June 2005 resulting in a Certificate of Determination being issued on 14 July 2005.  The Arbitrator entered an Award in favour of the Respondent and Mr Al-Aedani has appealed against that decision.

THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW

  1. The ‘Certificate of Determination’, dated 14 July 2005 records the Arbitrator’s orders as follows:

“1.     Award in favour of the Respondent.

2.     No order as to costs.”

ISSUES IN DISPUTE

  1. The issues in dispute in the appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Amad Al-Aedani v G & S President Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Amad Al-Aedani v G & S President Pty Ltd, the appeal by Mr Al-Aedani against the decision of the Arbitrator dated 14 July 2005 was heard by Acting Deputy President Julian Martin. The dispute arose from an incident where Mr Al-Aedani, a storeman employed by G & S President, injured his neck, right arm, lower back, right leg, and right ankle while lifting a truck battery at work on 12 December 2003. Workers' compensation benefits were initially paid but subsequently denied on 1 March 2004, as it was determined that Mr Al-Aedani was fit to resume his pre-injury duties. Mr Al-Aedani sought weekly benefits of compensation, medical expenses, and permanent impairment in the Workers Compensation Commission. The Arbitrator awarded in favour of the Respondent, finding that Mr Al-Aedani's incapacity was not related to the injury he suffered at G & S President on 12 December 2003.

The key issues in dispute were whether the Arbitrator erred in his findings of fact and whether he erred in his application of the evidence. Mr Al-Aedani argued that the Arbitrator failed to consider a medical report from Dr Nour, dated 18 March 2005, and that he incorrectly inferred from Dr Selim's report of 15 March 2004 that there was no abnormality with Mr Al-Aedani's back prior to the CT scan on 4 March 2004. The Arbitrator had rejected the medical report from Dr Nour as it was served shortly before the arbitration hearing and deemed it inadmissible. Furthermore, the Arbitrator's inference was based on Dr Selim's report and the evidence of Mr Al-Aedani that he had three or four x-ray or CT scans at home.

Upon reviewing the evidence and transcript, Acting Deputy President Julian Martin found no error in the Arbitrator's decision. The Arbitrator's conclusion was based on various pieces of evidence, including the medical opinions of Dr Price and Dr Hughes, the medical certificate from Dr Nour, and the failure of Mr Al-Aedani to produce the results of the radiological examinations. The Arbitrator also considered a video showing Mr Al-Aedani working and carrying tools at a building site, but noted that this evidence was irrelevant to the issue of whether Mr Al-Aedani's incapacity was related to the injury he suffered at G & S President on 12 December 2003.

The decision of the Arbitrator dated 14 July 2005 was confirmed, and no order was made as to the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Amad Al-Aedani, born in Iraq and residing in Australia, began working for G & S President Pty Ltd as a storeman in July 2003. On 12 December 2003, while lifting a 50kg truck battery at work, one handle broke causing him to fall and injure his neck, right arm, lower back, right leg, and right ankle. Al-Aedani consulted his general practitioner, Dr. Selim, who referred him for an x-ray and CT scan of the injured areas. He was certified unfit for work and received workers' compensation benefits initially, but liability was denied by G & S President on 1 March 2004. Al-Aedani commenced proceedings in the Workers Compensation Commission for weekly benefits, medical expenses, and permanent impairment on 15 February 2005. An arbitration hearing occurred on 28 June 2005, resulting in an Award in favour of G & S President on 14 July 2005. Al-Aedani appealed this decision.

On 5 August 2005, Amad Al-Aedani sought leave to appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator in the Workers Compensation Commission. The appeal was heard on the papers by Acting Deputy President Julian Martin. The appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Arbitrator dated 14 July 2005 was confirmed on 31 July 2006. No order was made as to the costs of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in his findings of fact.
2. Whether the Arbitrator erred in his application of the evidence.

Held
1. The court found no error in the Arbitrator's findings of fact regarding the existence of prior CT scans and the relevance of a video showing the Appellant working at a building site. The Arbitrator's decision that the Appellant's incapacity was not related to his employment injury was upheld.
2. The court found no error in the Arbitrator's application of the evidence, including the weight given to the medical evidence and the Appellant's failure to produce prior radiological examination results. The Arbitrator's reliance on the medical reports and examinations, as well as his consideration of the Appellant's capacity to work, was deemed reasonable and lawful.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal was brought against the decision of an Arbitrator in a workers compensation case. The Appellant, Mr Al-Aedani, sought to overturn the Arbitrator's decision that his incapacity was not related to his employment injury. The key issues were whether the Arbitrator erred in his findings of fact and in his application of the evidence. The court examined the medical evidence, the Arbitrator's reasoning, and the applicable legal principles to determine if the Arbitrator's decision was sound.

Regarding the findings of fact, the Arbitrator inferred from the evidence that the Appellant had undergone a CT scan of his back prior to a later scan on 4 March 2004, which showed no abnormality. The Appellant argued that this inference was incorrect and that it led to the wrong conclusion. However, the court found that the inference was reasonably drawn from the medical reports and the Appellant's own admission that he had multiple scans at home. The Arbitrator's finding was supported by the evidence and was not manifestly erroneous.

As for the application of the evidence, the Arbitrator considered the medical reports, examinations, and the Appellant's capacity to work. The Appellant argued that the Arbitrator failed to consider a medical report from Dr Nour and incorrectly relied on a video showing the Appellant working at a building site. However, the court found that the Arbitrator's decision to reject the late-tendered medical report was reasonable and that the video evidence was not relevant to the issue of whether the Appellant's incapacity was work-related. The Arbitrator's weighing of the evidence was lawful and reasonable, and there was no error in his application of the evidence.

In conclusion, the court found no fault in the Arbitrator's findings of fact or in his application of the evidence. The Arbitrator's decision that the Appellant's incapacity was not related to his employment injury was upheld, and the appeal was dismissed. The court emphasized that the Arbitrator's discretionary judgment as to the weight of evidence should not be interfered with unless it was manifestly obvious that the discretion had miscarried. In this case, the Arbitrator's decision was reasonable and lawful, and the appeal was rightly dismissed.