Amaca Pty Limited v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CITATION: Amaca Pty Limited v Brisbane City Council [2004] NSWSC 574
HEARING DATE(S): 24/06/04
JUDGMENT DATE:
1 July 2004
JUDGMENT OF: Barr J at 1
DECISION: 1. An order pursuant to Section 8 of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 that proceedings numbered 6104 of 2002 pending in the District Court of New South Wales between Brisbane City Council (the defendant) as plaintiff and Amaca Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) as defendant be removed into the Common Law Division of this Court; 2. An order pursuant to Section 5(2)(b) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 that the District Court proceedings when removed into this Court be transferred to the Supreme Court of Queensland; 3. The defendant must pay the plaintiff's costs.
LEGISLATION CITED: Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 NSW
CASES CITED: James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited v Barry and Anor (2000) 50 NSWLR 357
Broken Hill Proprietary Co Limited v Zunic [2001] NSWSC 561
Bankinvest AG v Seabrook (1998) 14 NSWLR 711
Dawson v Baker (1994) 120 ACTR 11
Goliath Portland Cement Co Ltd v Bengtell (1994) 33 NSWLR 414

PARTIES :

Amaca Pty Limited (formerly known as James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited) v Brisbane City Council
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 11059/03
COUNSEL: Plaintiff: J Gleeson SC/J Sheller
Defendant: J Sharpe
SOLICITORS: Plaintiff: McInnes Wilson
Defendant: Turner Freeman

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      GRAHAM BARR J

      Thursday, 1 July 2004

      11059/03 AMACA PTY LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS JAMES HARDIE & COY PTY LIMITED) v BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL

      JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: This is a summons in which the plaintiff, Amaca Pty Limited (formerly known as James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited) (“Amaca”) claims orders under the New South Wales Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act for the transfer of certain proceedings in which it is the defendant from the District Court of New South Wales to this Court and from this Court to the Supreme Court of Queensland.

2 The plaintiff in the District Court, Brisbane City Council (“the Council”), was between 1962 and 2001 the employer of Mr Peter John Nolan. Mr Nolan was at all times a “worker” within the meaning of that term as used in relevant Workers Compensation and industrial legislation. He was a surveyor and ultimately a surveyor-planner. During the course of his employment with the Council, and particularly between 1962 and 1969, Mr Nolan regularly handled and cut asbestos cement fibro sheeting. The Council asserts that that sheeting was manufactured by Amaca, some of it in New South Wales.

3 In December 2001 Mr Nolan was diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma and became entitled to recover compensation from the Council. It paid him the sum of $300,000 to compensate him for his injury.

4 The Council’s case is that Amaca was negligent in a number of respects in its supply of the sheeting used by Mr Nolan. It sues to recover from Amaca the compensation money paid. By common consent it has the right to bring…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Amaca Pty Limited v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWSC 574
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Amaca Pty Limited, formerly known as James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited, sought an order for the transfer of proceedings from the District Court of New South Wales to the Supreme Court of Queensland. The Brisbane City Council, the original plaintiff in the District Court, sued Amaca to recover compensation paid to a former employee who was diagnosed with mesothelioma after exposure to asbestos. The Council alleged that Amaca was negligent in its manufacture and supply of asbestos cement fibro sheeting. The legal issues involved the applicability of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (NSW) and whether the transfer of proceedings would serve the interests of justice.

The court considered various factors in determining whether the transfer was appropriate. It found that the substantive law applicable to the case did not favor either court, as the law of torts is uniform across Australia. The procedural laws of both courts were also comparable, with no significant advantage to either jurisdiction. The Council's choice of the New South Wales forum was not strongly justified, as Amaca was present in New South Wales and had its offices there. However, the court found a more substantive connection with Queensland, where the injury occurred, and all relevant events and witnesses were located.

The balance of convenience to the parties and witnesses favored transferring the case to Queensland, as most witnesses lived and worked there, and moving them to Sydney would cause significant inconvenience and expense. The court also found no merit in the Council's argument that Amaca's conduct delayed the proceedings. After weighing these factors, the court concluded that the interests of justice favored transferring the case to the Supreme Court of Queensland.

Amaca Pty Limited v Brisbane City Council [2004] NSWSC 574

1. An order pursuant to Section 8 of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (NSW) that proceedings numbered 6104 of 2002 pending in the District Court of New South Wales between Brisbane City Council (the defendant) as plaintiff and Amaca Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) as defendant be removed into the Common Law Division of this Court.
2. An order pursuant to Section 5(2)(b) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (NSW) that the District Court proceedings when removed into this Court be transferred to the Supreme Court of Queensland.
3. The defendant must pay the plaintiff's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim brought by Brisbane City Council against Amaca Pty Limited, previously known as James Hardie & Coy Pty Limited. The Council was the employer of Mr. Peter John Nolan between 1962 and 2001. Mr. Nolan, a surveyor, was exposed to asbestos cement fibro sheeting during his employment, which he regularly handled and cut, particularly between 1962 and 1969. The Council asserts that the asbestos sheeting was manufactured by Amaca, some of it in New South Wales. In December 2001, Mr. Nolan was diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma and received $300,000 in compensation from the Council. The Council sues Amaca to recover the compensation paid to Mr. Nolan, alleging negligence on Amaca's part in supplying the asbestos sheeting. Amaca has filed a defence and a cross-claim against the Council, asserting that the Council was negligent in failing to provide a safe system of work and in breaching statutory obligations.

The case was originally filed in the District Court of New South Wales, with Amaca as the defendant and the Council as the plaintiff. Amaca has now applied to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for an order to transfer the proceedings to the Supreme Court of Queensland, pursuant to the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (NSW). The application was heard by Justice Barr, who considered various factors, including the application of substantive law, procedural advantages, the choice of forum by the plaintiff, the substantive connection with the forum, the balance of convenience to the parties and witnesses, and other relevant matters.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proceedings should be removed from the District Court of New South Wales to the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
2. Whether the proceedings, once removed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, should be transferred to the Supreme Court of Queensland.
3. Whether the defendant should be ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs.

Held
1. The court held that the proceedings numbered 6104 of 2002 should be removed from the District Court of New South Wales to the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
2. The court held that the proceedings, once removed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, should be transferred to the Supreme Court of Queensland.
3. The court held that the defendant must pay the plaintiff's costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision was based on a broad and flexible approach to the concept of the "interests of justice," which was deemed to be the paramount consideration in determining whether the proceedings should be transferred. The court reviewed various factors to assess the suitability of each court to hear the case. The substantive law of negligence was found to be equally applicable in both New South Wales and Queensland, and neither court had a significant procedural advantage over the other. The court considered the choice of forum made by the plaintiff, the substantive connection of the case with each jurisdiction, the balance of convenience to the parties and witnesses, and other relevant matters. The court found that the balance of convenience favoured a hearing in Queensland, where most witnesses resided and worked, and where the substantive events of the case occurred. Therefore, the court concluded that the interests of justice required the transfer of the proceedings to the Supreme Court of Queensland. The court also noted that there was no merit in the defendant's argument that the plaintiff had caused unnecessary delay and expense, and that the plaintiff's actions were reasonable in the circumstances. The ratio decidendi of the case is that the transfer of proceedings under cross-vesting legislation should be determined by a holistic assessment of the interests of justice, taking into account various factors such as the choice of forum, substantive connection, convenience to witnesses, and procedural considerations.