Alzuain v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

ALZUAIN v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

[2020] SASC 6

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

17 January 2020

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - BAIL - REVOCATION, VARIATION, REVIEW AND APPEAL

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - BAIL - BEFORE TRIAL - SERIOUS AND ORGANISED CRIME SUSPECTS

The appellant is charged with murder. On his application for home detention bail, a Magistrate determined that he was a “serious and organised crime suspect” within the meaning of section 3A of the Bail Act 1985 and refused bail. He applies for review of the decision to refuse bail.

The appellant was determined to be a serious and organised crime suspect because the charge against him is punishable by life imprisonment; the offence was allegedly committed for the benefit and in association with the Hells Angels Motorcycle Club which was allegedly a criminal organisation; and his release on bail would be likely to cause a potential witness to reasonably fear for his safety.

The appellant does not challenge the serious and organised crime suspect determination and accepts that, pursuant to section 10A, he must establish special circumstances justifying his release on bail. He contends that special circumstances have been established.

Held (dismissing the application):

1. In the context in which an applicant is a prescribed applicant because he or she is a serious and organised crime suspect, establishing special circumstances requires an applicant to establish that the applicant’s circumstances place him or her outside of the contemplated risk to the community generally posed by persons falling within the class of serious and organised crime suspects having regard to the criteria for determination that a person is a serious and organised crime suspect (at [68]).

2. The appellant’s contention that he has severed all ties with the Hells Angels Motorcycle Club (and consequentially that he falls outside the risks posed to the community by the class of serious and organised crime suspects) is unsupported by evidence (at [74]-[75]).

3. On the evidence adduced during the bail review, the appellant has failed to establish the existence of special circumstances (at [81]).

4. Application for review of bail decision dismissed (at [83]).

Bail Act 1935 (SA) ss 3, 3A, 4, 10, 10A, 12; Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) ss 5, 83D, 127; Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA); Serious and Organised Crime (Control) Act 2009 (SA), referred to.
R v Lombardi (2013) SASR 577; R v Webb [2019] SASC 8, considered.

ALZUAIN v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
[2020] SASC 6

Criminal: Bail Review

BLUE J:

  1. The appellant Musa Alzuain (Mr Alzuain) has been charged with the murder of Jason De Ieso on 21 November 2012. On his application for home detention bail, a Magistrate determined that he was a “serious and organised crime suspect” within the meaning of section 3A of the Bail Act 1985 (SA) (the Act) and refused bail. This is his application for review of the decision to refuse bail.

  2. Mr Alzuain…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alzuain v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an application by Mr Alzuain to review a decision of the Magistrates Court to refuse him bail. Mr Alzuain, along with four others, is charged with the murder of Mr De Ieso, which is alleged to be part of a cycle of retribution between rival motorcycle clubs, the Hells Angels and the Finks. The primary legal issue was whether Mr Alzuain, who has been designated a serious and organised crime suspect, could establish special circumstances to justify his release on bail. The court was required to assess the evidence presented by both Mr Alzuain and the Director of Public Prosecutions, and determine whether the serious and organised crime suspect determination should be revoked or varied.

The court examined the evidence and found that Mr Alzuain had not demonstrated special circumstances warranting his release on bail. The court noted that Mr Alzuain had accepted the serious and organised crime suspect determination and thus needed to establish special circumstances to justify his release. The court considered various affidavits and letters tendered by Mr Alzuain, including claims about the impact on his transport business, but found these to be insufficiently detailed or directly relevant to the special circumstances required. The prosecution presented evidence supporting the organised crime allegations and the serious nature of the charge. The court concluded that the evidence did not support a finding of special circumstances, and therefore upheld the decision to refuse bail.

The court dismissed Mr Alzuain’s application for review of the bail decision, noting that the serious and organised crime suspect determination would expire on 6 May 2020. At that time, Mr Alzuain could make a fresh application for bail in the Magistrates Court or Supreme Court, depending on the status of the criminal proceedings. The court did not find it necessary to consider further the impact on Mr Alzuain’s transport business due to the lack of detailed evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

No deponent was cross-examined and no oral evidence was adduced.Background The facts set out below are based on the evidence adduced to the extent that it was not contradicted or challenged at the hearing of the bail review. Obviously, if such evidence were adduced in a different context (for example in the criminal proceeding), its admissibility and/or accuracy may be challenged. The facts, and the identification of the prosecution case, set out below are set out purely for the purpose of the bail review. On 2 August 2019 Mr Alzuain was arrested for the murder of Mr De Ieso. On about the same date, his older brothers Hussain and Mohamed Alzuain, together with Daniel Jalleh and Ross Montgomery, were also arrested for the murder of Mr De Ieso. On 5 August 2019 an information was laid in the Magistrates Court charging those five men with the murder of Mr De Ieso. On 21 November 2012 Mr De Ieso was shot and died at his workshop premises at Pooraka. The police subsequently recovered CCTV footage from the Pooraka premises which allegedly shows the arrival at approximately 1.40 pm of nine men in two cars, being a white Nissan Pulsar and a white Mazda. The CCTV footage from the Pooraka premises allegedly shows six of the men holding firearms, one of which was a sawn off shotgun. The prosecution case is that Mr De Ieso was shot in the head with a shotgun and that Mr Alzuain was the man seen in the CCTV footage holding a sawn off shotgun. The prosecution case is that, at the time of the shooting, Hussain Alzuain was a full member, and the Sergeant at Arms, of the Hells Angels Motorcycle Club’s North Crew; Mohamed Alzuain, Mr Montgomery and Mr Jalleh were each “prospects”; and Mr Alzuain was an associate who spent time at the clubrooms and associating with full members and prospects. The prosecution case is that the shooting was intended as retribution for a firebombing of the Alzuain brothers’ parents’ house on the previous evening believed to have been undertaken by the rival Finks Motorcycle Club. The prosecution case is that antipathy between the Hells Angels and the Finks pre-dated 2012. On 3 March 2012 there was an affray between Hells Angels members and associates and Finks members and associates outside Strats Nightclub at Hindley Street, Adelaide, in the course of which two shots were fired towards the Hells Angels members and associates. The prosecution case is that Mr Alzuain and Hussain Alzuain were present but not that they participated in the affray. On 17 November 2012 there was an affray between Hells Angels members and associates and Finks members and associates at the entrance to a kick boxing event at the Adelaide Arena, Findon. The prosecution case is that Mr Alzuain and Hussain Alzuain were present but not that they participated in the affray. On the evening of 20 November 2012, the front doors of the Alzuain brothers’ parents’ house were forced open and a Molotov cocktail was thrown into the house, causing a small fire in the kitchen. No one was home when this occurred. Later Mr Alzuain and Hussain Alzuain returned home and declined to speak to police. The prosecution case is that Hells Angels North Crew members and associates believed that the attack was made by the Finks Motorcycle Club.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Alzuain does not challenge the serious and organised crime suspect determination and accepts that, pursuant to section 10A, he must establish special circumstances justifying his release on bail. He contends that special circumstances have been established.Evidence Mr Alzuain tendered, and I received, six affidavits by his solicitor, Harry Patsouris, sworn on 11 November, 21 November, 16 December, 17 December, 18 December and 19 December 2019 (which also exhibited various documents) together with two affidavits by his partner’s mother Emma Barolo and one affidavit by his boxing trainer Friday Nwaiwu. He also tendered a reference by Phillip Goods, a former president of Boxing Australia SA, and a letter by Joe Palladino. The respondent Director of Public Prosecutions tendered, and I received, an affidavit by a solicitor in the Director’s office, Samantha Ive, sworn on 21 November (which in turn exhibited multiple affidavits by police and civilian witnesses and other documents) together with affidavits by Detective Brevet Sergeants Daniel Richardson and Daniel Ford each sworn on 18 December 2019. No deponent was cross-examined and no oral evidence was adduced.Background The facts set out below are based on the evidence adduced to the extent that it was not contradicted or challenged at the hearing of the bail review. Obviously, if such evidence were adduced in a different context (for example in the criminal proceeding), its admissibility and/or accuracy may be challenged. The facts, and the identification of the prosecution case, set out below are set out purely for the purpose of the bail review. On 2 August 2019 Mr Alzuain was arrested for the murder of Mr De Ieso. On about the same date, his older brothers Hussain and Mohamed Alzuain, together with Daniel Jalleh and Ross Montgomery, were also arrested for the murder of Mr De Ieso. On 5 August 2019 an information was laid in the Magistrates Court charging those five men with the murder of Mr De Ieso. On 21 November 2012 Mr De Ieso was shot and died at his workshop premises at Pooraka. The police subsequently recovered CCTV footage from the Pooraka premises which allegedly shows the arrival at approximately 1.40 pm of nine men in two cars, being a white Nissan Pulsar and a white Mazda. The CCTV footage from the Pooraka premises allegedly shows six of the men holding firearms, one of which was a sawn off shotgun. The prosecution case is that Mr De Ieso was shot in the head with a shotgun and that Mr Alzuain was the man seen in the CCTV footage holding a sawn off shotgun. The prosecution case is that, at the time of the shooting, Hussain Alzuain was a full member, and the Sergeant at Arms, of the Hells Angels Motorcycle Club’s North Crew; Mohamed Alzuain, Mr Montgomery and Mr Jalleh were each “prospects”; and Mr Alzuain was an associate who spent time at the clubrooms and associating with full members and prospects. The prosecution case is that the shooting was intended as retribution for a firebombing of the Alzuain brothers’ parents’ house on the previous evening believed to have been undertaken by the rival Finks Motorcycle Club.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Alzuain contends that his transport business has suffered as result of his being in custody and will continue to suffer if he remains in custody. He relies on a letter by Mr Paladino addressed to whom it may concern. Mr Alzuain does not contend that this comprises a special circumstance, but rather that it is a matter to be taken into account if special circumstances are otherwise established in determining whether bail should be granted. Given my conclusion above, it is not necessary to further consider Mr Paladino’s letter. However, I observe that the letter is vague concerning Mr Paladino’s dealings with Mr Alzuain since Mr Alzuain’s arrest, the conduct of the transport business since that time and the precise reasons why the business has suffered and will continue to suffer if Mr Alzuain remains in custody. If Mr Alzuain wished to rely on such hardship, it was incumbent on him to adduce evidence in relation to it, such as by obtaining a detailed affidavit from Mr Paladino.Conclusion Mr Alzuain’s application for review of the bail decision is dismissed. I observe that the serious and organised crime suspect determination will in the ordinary course expire on 6 May 2020, being six months after it was made. If that occurs, Mr Alzuain can make a fresh application for bail in the Magistrates Court (or in the Supreme Court if an ex officio information in this Court has by then been laid) in a context in which he is no longer a prescribed applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established