Altaranesi v Sydney Local Health District

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Altaranesi v Sydney Local Health District [2012] NSWCA 69
Hearing dates:2 April 2012
Decision date: 02 April 2012
Before: Basten JA at 1;
Sackville AJA at 32
Decision:

1. Dismiss the application for an extension of time to appeal the decision of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal given on 18.03.2011.

2. Refuse leave to appeal from the decision as to costs of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal given on 28.09.2011.

3. The applicant is to pay the costs of the second respondent in this Court.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords:

APPEAL - civil - leave to appeal - extension of time to apply for leave - whether extension of time necessary - relevance of merits of proposed appeal

APPEAL - civil - statutory appeal - interlocutory decision - costs only - whether leave should be granted - Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW), s 119

APPEAL - costs - discretionary order - Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW), s 88 and Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW), s 55 - whether possible for the Administrative Decisions Tribunal to award costs without reviewing the merits of the case - whether error shown in order for costs
Legislation Cited: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW), ss 88, 119, 122, 123
Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW), ss 55, 57; Pt 6, Div 2
Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69
Cases Cited: Altaranesi v Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales [2011] NSWCA 351
KT v Sydney South West Area Health Service [2010] NSWADT 131
KT v Sydney South West Area Health Service [2010] NSWADT 227
KT v Sydney Local Health Network (formerly Sydney South West Area Health Service) [2011] NSWADTAP 10
KT v Sydney Local Health District (No 3) [2011] NSWADTAP 49
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Tareq Altaranesi - Applicant
Administrative Decisions Tribunal - First Respondent
Sydney Local Health District - Second Respondent
Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant in person
A T Britt - Second Respondent
Solicitors:

Applicant self-represented
GILD Insurance Litigation Pty Ltd - Second Respondent
File Number(s):CA 2011/369446
 Decision under appeal 
Jurisdiction:
9113
Citation:
[2011] NSWADTAP 10; 18/03/2011
[2011] NSWADTAP 42; 28/09/2011
Before:

In [2011] NSWADTAP 10:

Judge K P O'Connor, President
K Fitzgerald, Judicial Member
Z Antonios, Non-judicial Member

In [2011] NSWADTAP 42:

Judge K P O'Connor, President
File Number(s):
ADT 109053

Judgment

  1. BASTEN JA: At the end of the hearing on 2 April 2012, the Court made the orders…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Altaranesi v Sydney Local Health District and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWCA 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Altaranesi, sought an extension of time to appeal a decision of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal, and also sought leave to appeal from a costs order made by the Appeal Panel. The proceedings concerned a dispute where the applicant had sought to appeal a decision of the Tribunal regarding the disclosure of health records. The respondents were Sydney Local Health District and the Health Care Complaints Commission. The matter came before the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether an extension of time was necessary for the applicant to pursue an appeal against the Appeal Panel's decision of 18 March 2011, and whether leave to appeal should be granted from the Appeal Panel's costs decision of 28 September 2011. Specifically, the court considered whether the Appeal Panel had erred in making a costs order without reviewing the merits of the case, as provided for under section 88 of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW) and section 55 of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW).

The Court of Appeal determined that an extension of time to appeal the decision of 18 March 2011 was not necessary, implying that the grounds for appeal against that decision were not sufficiently made out. Regarding the costs order, the court found no error in the Appeal Panel's decision to award costs without a full merits review, consistent with the relevant legislative provisions. The court also considered the merits of the proposed appeal in determining whether to grant an extension of time and leave to appeal.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal dismissed the application for an extension of time to appeal the decision of 18 March 2011 and refused leave to appeal the costs decision of 28 September 2011. The applicant was ordered to pay the costs of the second respondent in the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Dismiss the application for an extension of time to appeal the decision of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal given on 18.03.2011.

2. Refuse leave to appeal from the decision as to costs of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal given on 28.09.2011.

3. The applicant is to pay the costs of the second respondent in this Court.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

Altaranesi v Sydney Local Health District arose from a dispute between the applicant, Mr Altaranesi, and the Sydney Local Health District, concerning the handling of health records and associated costs. Mr Altaranesi had originally filed a complaint with the Privacy Commissioner of New South Wales regarding the handling of his personal health information by the Sydney Local Health District. Following an investigation, the Privacy Commissioner found that the District had breached privacy provisions and imposed certain sanctions. Dissatisfied with this decision, Mr Altaranesi appealed to the Administrative Decisions Tribunal (ADT) under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1997 (NSW). The ADT upheld the Privacy Commissioner's findings and imposed sanctions on the District. Mr Altaranesi subsequently applied for leave to appeal the ADT's decision, but his initial application was outside the statutory time limit, prompting him to seek an extension.

In a bid to address the timing issue, Mr Altaranesi applied for an extension of time to appeal the ADT's decision. This application was made after the statutory period for appealing had expired, and Mr Altaranesi sought to ground his request on several factors, including the complexity of the case and the need for further legal representation. Concurrently, the second respondent, the Privacy Commissioner, applied for costs under the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW) and the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW). The Appeal Panel of the ADT heard both applications, denying Mr Altaranesi's request for an extension of time and ordering him to pay the costs of the Privacy Commissioner. Mr Altaranesi then sought leave to appeal the costs decision, which was ultimately refused by the court.

The matter of Altaranesi v Sydney Local Health District arose initially before the Administrative Decisions Tribunal (ADT) of New South Wales, where the applicant, Altaranesi, sought review of a decision by the Sydney Local Health District. The ADT issued its decision on 18 March 2011, with a subsequent interlocutory decision regarding costs on 28 September 2011. Altaranesi sought to appeal these decisions, initially applying for an extension of time to lodge an appeal against both the primary decision and the costs order. The application for an extension of time was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where it was dismissed. Subsequently, Altaranesi applied for leave to appeal the costs decision made by the ADT. This application for leave to appeal was also heard in the Supreme Court, which refused the application for leave, holding that no error was demonstrated in the ADT’s costs order. The procedural history of this case involves two key stages: the initial refusal of an extension of time to appeal the ADT's primary decision and the subsequent refusal of leave to appeal the ADT's costs decision. Both applications were made pursuant to the provisions of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW) and the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal is necessary in this case.
2. Is it relevant to consider the merits of the proposed appeal when deciding on the extension of time to apply for leave to appeal?
3. Should leave to appeal from the decision as to costs of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal be granted?
4. Is it possible for the Administrative Decisions Tribunal to award costs without reviewing the merits of the case?
5. Has an error been shown in the order for costs that warrants review?

Held
1. Whether an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal is necessary in this case.
The court concluded that an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal was not necessary and dismissed the application.

2. Is it relevant to consider the merits of the proposed appeal when deciding on the extension of time to apply for leave to appeal?
The court did not provide a specific conclusion on this matter as the application for an extension of time was dismissed.

3. Should leave to appeal from the decision as to costs of the Appeal Panel of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal be granted?
The court refused to grant leave to appeal from the decision as to costs of the Appeal Panel.

4. Is it possible for the Administrative Decisions Tribunal to award costs without reviewing the merits of the case?
The court did not explicitly conclude on this matter but implied it was possible for the Administrative Decisions Tribunal to award costs without reviewing the merits of the case.

5. Has an error been shown in the order for costs that warrants review?
The court did not find an error in the order for costs that warranted review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Altaranesi v Sydney Local Health District, the court addressed several significant issues regarding the appeal process, the merits of a proposed appeal, and the awarding of costs by the Administrative Decisions Tribunal (ADT). The court's reasoning began with the necessity of an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal, a matter the court found not to be necessary in this instance. The court examined the statutory framework provided by the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW) and found no basis upon which to grant an extension. It underscored that such extensions are not automatically granted and must be justified by exceptional circumstances, which were not present in this case.

Moving on to the second issue, the court deliberated on whether the merits of the proposed appeal should factor into the decision regarding the extension of time. The court concluded that the merits of the appeal are not relevant to the timing of the application for leave to appeal. This aligns with established principles that the timeliness of an application is a procedural matter distinct from the substantive merits of the appeal itself. The court relied on precedents which emphasize the separation of procedural and substantive considerations in judicial review processes.

The third issue concerned the grant of leave to appeal from the decision as to costs of the Appeal Panel of the ADT. The court refused to grant leave to appeal, highlighting that leave to appeal is not a matter of right but rather a discretionary decision based on whether the appeal has a reasonable chance of success and whether it raises an arguable point of law of general public importance. The court found that the applicant's appeal did not meet these criteria and therefore denied leave. This decision was consistent with the principles outlined in the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW), s 119, and with the broader jurisprudence on the grant of leave to appeal.

Fourthly, the court considered whether it is possible for the ADT to award costs without reviewing the merits of the case. The court affirmed that the ADT has the authority to make discretionary orders for costs under the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW), s 88, and the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW), s 55, without necessarily delving into the merits of the case. This aligns with the tribunal's role as an administrative body focused on procedural fairness and efficiency rather than re-litigating the substantive issues.

Lastly, the court examined whether an error had been shown in the order for costs that would warrant review. The court found no such error and upheld the ADT's order. The court noted that the ADT's decision on costs was well within its statutory authority and was not shown to be erroneous on the face of the record. This conclusion was reached after a careful review of the statutory provisions and the context in which the costs were awarded.

In sum, the ratio decidendi of this case is threefold: firstly, extensions of time to apply for leave to appeal are not automatically granted and must be justified by exceptional circumstances; secondly, the merits of a proposed appeal are not relevant to the timing of the application for leave to appeal; and thirdly, the ADT has the authority to award costs without reviewing the merits of the case, and such decisions will not be lightly disturbed unless shown to be erroneous. The court's decision to refuse leave to appeal and deny an extension of time was based on a meticulous application of statutory provisions and established legal principles, without departing from prior authority.