Alpall v Blue Mountains City Council [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION:

Alpall v Blue Mountains City Council [No 2] [2005] NSWLEC 720

PARTIES:

Applicant:
Alpall Pty Ltd

Respondent:
Blue Mountains City Council

FILE NUMBER(S):

10492 of 2005 of 2005

CORAM:

Roseth SC

KEY ISSUES:

Costs - Development Application :- Principle for awarding costs in merit cases

CASES CITED:

Statewide Developments Pty Limited v Minister for Infrastructure and Planning [2005] NSWLEC 353

DATES OF HEARING: 13/12/2005
 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 


12/21/2005

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

Applicant:
Mr D White, solicotr of Benetatos White

Respondent:
Mr T Cork, solicitor of McPhee Kelshaw


JUDGMENT:

- 5 -

      THE LAND AND
      ENVIRONMENT COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      Roseth SC

      21 December 2005

      10492 of 2005 Alpall Pty Ltd v Blue Mountains City Council

      JUDGMENT

1 Senior Commissioner: This is an application for costs by the Blue Mountains City Council (the council) against Alpall Pty Ltd (the applicant) arising out of an appeal relating to a development for Seniors Living on lot B DP 391940, known as 33 Falls Road, Wentworth Falls. The appeal was determined on 9 November 2005 by refusal.

2 The council’s advocate, Mr T Cork, submitted that the council first indicated that it required information on solar access to the proposed development in its draft Statement of issues of 4 July 2005. The applicant did not supply this information in an acceptable form despite the fact that, in addition to the council, the two Court-appointed experts also requested it on several occasions. Mr Cork drew support from my judgment, in which I stated that:

          …there appears to be no reason for the applicant’s failure to provide it (the information on solar access) at least in time for the hearing.

3 In Mr Cork’s submission, the applicant should pay the council’s legal costs accrued from 4 July 2005, a sum of approximately $8,000. The cost does not include the cost of experts.

4 The applicant’s advocate, Mr A White, submitted that the Court determined the application on a number of matters, not solar access alone. Mr White did not accept that the applicant failed to provide adequate information, but even on the assumption that the applicant was at fault, in Mr White’s submission, the outcome would have been the same with or without adequate information on solar access.


      Costs in merit cases in the Land and Environment Court

5 Pt 16 rule 4(2) of the Court’s Rules applies to proceedings in classes 1, 2 and 3 of the Court’s jurisdiction brought under s95A, 96, 97, 98, 109K, 121ZK, 121ZM and 149F of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979; s176, 177, 178, 182 and 611 of the Local Government Act 1993, and s37 of the Valuation of Land Act 1916. Generally these proceedings may be described as merit and valuation cases. The discussion below deals with merit appeals; however, similar principles would apply to valuation appeals. Rule 4(2) states:

          No order for the payment of costs will be made in proceedings to which…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alpall v Blue Mountains City Council [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWLEC 720
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alpall Pty Ltd brought an appeal against the Blue Mountains City Council, which had refused a development application for Seniors Living on lot B DP 391940, located at 33 Falls Road, Wentworth Falls. The appeal was determined on 9 November 2005 by refusal. The council applied for costs against the applicant, alleging that the applicant had failed to provide information on solar access, despite repeated requests from the council and the court-appointed experts. The applicant argued that the outcome would have been the same regardless of the information on solar access, and that the council's costs in defending the appeal were the same as they would have been if the applicant had provided the information.

The court examined the principle for awarding costs in merit cases in the Land and Environment Court, which differs from other courts where the usual rule is that "costs follow the event." In merit cases, the court generally assumes that an applicant is entitled to test a council's decision to refuse a development application without fear of having to pay the council's costs of defending the appeal, even if the court finds that, on merit, the application should be refused. The court examined the circumstances that would make it fair and reasonable to depart from the underlying presumption. The court found that the council's costs in defending the appeal were the same as they would have been if the applicant had provided the information on solar access. Therefore, it would not be fair and reasonable to award costs against the applicant.

The court dismissed the council's application for costs and returned the exhibits. The applicant did not have to pay the council's legal costs accrued from 4 July 2005, a sum of approximately $8,000. The court emphasised that the purpose of awarding costs in merit cases is not to punish one or more of the parties but to compensate a party for costs that have been incurred as a result of a circumstance, aspect, or type of conduct. The court found that the council's costs in defending the appeal were the same as they would have been if the applicant had provided the information on solar access, and therefore, it would not be fair and reasonable to award costs against the applicant.