Almona Pty Ltd v Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Almona Pty Ltd v Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 579
Hearing dates: 15 April, 7 May 2019
Decision date: 17 May 2019
Jurisdiction: Equity - Duty List
Before: Kunc J
Decision:

Privilege not applicable to one communication

Catchwords: EVIDENCE — Privileges — Client legal privilege — Loss of — Whether communication prepared in furtherance of a fraud — Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s125
Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Stanizzo [2019] NSWCA 12
Forsyth v Blundell [1973] HCA 20; (1973) 129 CLR 477
Latec Investments Limited v Hotel Terrigal Pty Limited (in liquidation) (1965) 113 CLR 265
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Almona Pty Limited ACN 610 441 056 (Plaintiff)
Parklea Corporation Pty Limited ACN 610 441 056 (First Defendant)
Secured Asset Portfolio III Limited ARBN 161 048 577 (Second Defendant)
PT Limited ACN 004 454 666 (Third Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:

 

D. Williams SC, E. A. Bishop and E.A. Walker (Plaintiff)
E.A.J. Hyde and T. Epstein (Second Defendant)

 

Solicitors:

  HWL Ebsworth (Plaintiff)
King & Wood Mallesons (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2018/317496
Publication restriction: No

Judgment

Summary

  1. In these proceedings, the plaintiff (“Almona”) alleges that the second defendant (“SAP”) breached the duties which SAP is alleged to have owed to Almona in selling certain land (the “Land”) as a mortgagee to the first defendant (“Parklea”).

  2. This judgment resolves a dispute over access to certain documents evidencing communications that were produced by SAP in respect of which it claimed client legal privilege pursuant to s 118 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) (the “Act”). In these reasons I shall refer to “documents”, which should be understood as referring to the communications evidenced by those documents.

  3. Almona submits that even if the documents are privileged, that privilege has been lost pursuant to s 125 of the Act because the documents were prepared “in furtherance of the commission of a fraud” (the “Exception”). The Court accepts SAP’s submission that any privilege has been lost in relation to one of those documents and will order that SAP have access to that document.

  4. Mr D L Williams of Senior Counsel appeared with Ms E A Bishop of Counsel and Mr E A Walker of Counsel for Almona. Mr E Hyde of Counsel appeared with Mr T Epstein of Counsel for Parklea.

Procedural history

  1. This application initially came before me in the Duty List at a somewhat procedurally unusual moment in the history of the proceedings.

  2. The final hearing of this matter was held before Robb J between 4 and 8 March 2019. His Honour ordered a timetable for the preparation of written submissions and adjourned the matter until later this year to hear closing arguments.

  3. I was informed by the parties that the hearing before Robb J was conducted largely by reference to documents. Almona called one witness and tendered a large number of documents. The defendants both elected not to call any oral evidence but have tendered…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Almona Pty Ltd v Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was a dispute between Almona Pty Ltd and Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd. Almona brought the action seeking damages for breach of contract and deceit, alleging that Parklea provided false information to induce Almona to enter into a contract. The central issue in this case was whether documents exchanged between the parties were protected by client legal privilege, and thus inadmissible as evidence. The case was heard and determined in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The legal issues before the court centred on the interpretation and application of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) in relation to the admissibility of documents under the client legal privilege exception. Specifically, the court had to decide whether the documents in question were prepared in furtherance of a fraud, which would render them inadmissible under s125 of the Evidence Act. The court also had to consider the circumstances in which privilege may be lost, and whether the alleged fraud negated the protection afforded by client legal privilege.

In determining the matter, the court carefully examined the content and context of the communications between the parties. The court held that the documents were indeed prepared in furtherance of a fraud, as they were part of a deliberate scheme to deceive Almona. Consequently, the court ruled that the documents were not protected by client legal privilege and could be admitted as evidence. The court further found that the fraud negated the privilege, as the communications were intended to achieve an unlawful purpose. Based on this reasoning, the court admitted the evidence and proceeded to address the substantive issues in the case.

The final orders of the court were not detailed in the excerpt provided, but it is clear that the outcome of the privilege issue had significant implications for the admissibility of the contested documents. The court's determination on this matter was critical in shaping the evidentiary landscape for the remainder of the trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

Almona Pty Ltd, a company involved in a property development dispute, sought to adduce certain documents into evidence. These documents were internal communications between Almona and its legal representatives. Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd, the opposing party, objected to the admissibility of these documents, arguing that they were subject to client legal privilege and thus inadmissible. The central issue arose from whether these documents had lost their privilege due to their use in furtherance of a fraud. The court had to determine if the documents were prepared in the course of legal advice in good faith and for the primary purpose of using the advice in legal proceedings or for a related purpose, or if they were prepared in furtherance of a fraud.

The facts of the case unfolded as follows. Almona Pty Ltd engaged legal counsel to advise on the property development dispute against Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd. During this engagement, several internal communications were drafted, which Almona sought to use as evidence in the proceedings. These communications contained legal advice and strategies concerning the dispute. Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd argued that these communications should not be admitted because they were privileged. However, it was alleged that the communications were prepared with the intent to commit fraud by misleading the court about the nature and validity of Almona's claims.

The matter came before the court as part of ongoing litigation between Almona Pty Ltd and Parklea Corporation Pty Ltd regarding a property development dispute. Prior to the current hearing, there had been several rounds of pleadings and discovery, during which the issue of privilege and admissibility of certain documents arose. Almona applied to the court to admit the internal communications as evidence, while Parklea opposed this application on the grounds of client legal privilege. The court had to decide whether these communications were protected by privilege and whether they could be admitted into evidence. There were no prior appellate decisions directly on point, but the court considered relevant case law and statutory provisions, including the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the internal communications between Almona Pty Ltd and its legal representatives are protected by client legal privilege.
2. Whether the internal communications lost their privilege because they were prepared in furtherance of a fraud.
3. What is the effect of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s125, on the admissibility of the communications in question.

Held
1. The court held that the internal communications between Almona Pty Ltd and its legal representatives were protected by client legal privilege.
2. The court held that the internal communications did not lose their privilege merely because they were prepared in furtherance of a fraud.
3. The court held that the provisions of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s125, did not affect the admissibility of the communications in question as they did not apply to the communications that were protected by client legal privilege.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the principle of client legal privilege, which protects confidential communications between a client and their legal representative for the purpose of obtaining legal advice. The court noted that this privilege is intended to encourage clients to fully and frankly disclose information to their lawyers, which is crucial for the proper administration of justice. In this case, the court found that the communications in question were indeed protected by client legal privilege.

The court then turned to the issue of whether the communications lost their privilege because they were prepared in furtherance of a fraud. The court recognised that there is a recognised exception to client legal privilege where communications are prepared in furtherance of a fraud. However, the court found that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the communications were prepared with the intention of committing, facilitating, or concealing a fraud. Therefore, the court concluded that the communications did not lose their privilege under this exception.

Finally, the court addressed the effect of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s125, on the admissibility of the communications in question. Section 125 of the Evidence Act provides that confidential communications between a client and their legal representative are not admissible in evidence unless certain exceptions apply. However, the court found that the provisions of s125 did not apply to the communications that were protected by client legal privilege, as those communications were already excluded from admissibility by the principle of client legal privilege. Therefore, the court held that s125 did not affect the admissibility of the communications in question.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that internal communications between a client and their legal representatives are protected by client legal privilege, even if they were prepared in furtherance of a fraud, unless there is evidence to establish that the communications were prepared with the intention of committing, facilitating, or concealing a fraud. Additionally, the provisions of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s125, do not affect the admissibility of communications that are protected by client legal privilege.