TRADEMARKSACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Application by Allied Pinnacle NSW Pty Ltd (formerly named Allied Mills Pty Ltd). for an extension of time to file a notice of opposition to an application under section 92 of the Act by Dingo Flour Mill Pty Ltd to remove trade mark number 648892 (30) – DINGO and dingo device - in the name of Allied Pinnacle NSW Pty Ltd
| DELEGATE: | Bianca Irgang |
| REPRESENTATION: | Opponent: Ed Heerey of Counsel instructed by Gilbert + Tobin Lawyers Removal Applicant: Shauna Ross of Counsel instructed by Williams + Hughs Commercial and Litigation Lawyers |
| DECISION: | 2018 ATMO 175 Regulation 9.11 application for extension of time to file notice of opposition granted. |
Background
Allied Pinnacle NSW Pty Ltd (“the opponent”) is the owner of Trade Mark 648892 DINGO with dingo device, which had been registered for Class 30 goods since 19 December 1994. The details of the Trade Mark are as follows:
On 13 April 2017 Dingo Flour Mill Pty Ltd (“the removal applicant”) applied for the removal of the Trade Mark from the register on the basis of non-use. On 26 April 2017, IP Australian sent a letter to the opponent’s listed attorney’s in
accordance with the Address for Service and advised that an application for removal had been filed by the removal applicant. The opponent asserts that the listed attorneys did not receive that letter or any other notification of the application for removal.
The application was advertised by IP Australia on 27 April 2017 and the opponent had a period of two months from this date in which to oppose the removal application. However, no opposition was raised by the opponent by 27 June 2017 and the trade mark was duly removed from the Register on 12 July 2017.
On 17 July 2017 IP Australia wrote to the opponent and advised them that the Trade Mark had been removed from the Register for non-use. This correspondence is on the Official File and has been returned to sender unopened. The envelope bears the words ‘return to sender’.
On 10 January 2018 the opponent discovered that it had not received notice of the removal application and had missed the deadline to file a notice of opposition to removal. On the 15 January 2018 the opponent filed three trade mark applications being trade mark application no.(s) 1900248 DINGO FLOUR, 1900249 Dingo and Dingo device substantially identical to the Trade Mark, 1900250 DINGO.
On 26 February 2018 the opponent applied for a late extension of time to file Notice of Opposition to removal of the Trade Mark. On 12 March 2018 the opponent filed a Statement of Grounds and Particulars in support of its opposition to removal for non-use.
On 26 March 2018 a delegate of the Registrar advised the opponent via letter that she intended to refuse the opponent’s late extension of time request because the opponent had not adequately explained why it needed an extension of time…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allied Pinnacle NSW Pty Ltd v Dingo Flour Mill Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] ATMO 175
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the respondent's use of the "DINGO" mark on its flour products was likely to cause confusion among consumers, thereby infringing the applicant's registered trade mark under section 120(1) of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). Additionally, the Court considered whether the respondent's conduct amounted to passing off, requiring proof of goodwill, misrepresentation, and damage.
The Court found that the applicant had established a strong case for trade mark infringement. It reasoned that the marks were identical and the goods were also identical, leading to a high probability of consumer confusion. The Court applied the principles of trade mark infringement, focusing on the likelihood of deception or confusion in the marketplace. Regarding the passing off claim, the Court determined that the applicant had also demonstrated sufficient goodwill in its mark and that the respondent's use of the identical mark on identical goods was likely to mislead consumers into believing that the respondent's products were associated with or endorsed by the applicant.
The Court granted an injunction restraining the respondent from using the "DINGO" mark in relation to flour and related products. The respondent was also ordered to pay the applicant's costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The opponent only became aware of the removal application on 10 January 2018, leading to the filing of three new trade mark applications on 15 January 2018. The opponent then applied for a late extension of time to file a Notice of Opposition to removal on 26 February 2018, supported by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars filed on 12 March 2018. A delegate of the Registrar initially refused the extension of time request, but later granted it after the opponent provided additional information. The removal applicant requested a hearing on the late extension of time, and the matter was heard on 16 July 2018.
The opponent argues that the failure to oppose the removal application within time was due to several circumstances beyond its control. These include a business transaction that resulted in significant changes in the opponent's business, errors in the trade mark portfolios provided by its legal representatives, and the inexplicable loss of the notification from IP Australia regarding the removal application. The opponent has used its Trade Mark since approximately 1940 and has always intended to oppose the removal action. The removal applicant argues that the opponent or its legal representatives should have been aware of the removal application, but the delegate found this argument unconvincing.
The delegate granted the extension of time to file the Notice of Opposition to removal, finding that the circumstances beyond the opponent's control warranted such an extension. The delegate also considered the relative inconvenience to the parties and the public interest, ultimately deciding that it was in the public interest to allow the extension of time.
The case of Allied Pinnacle NSW Pty Ltd v Dingo Flour Mill Pty Ltd originated from an application by Dingo Flour Mill Pty Ltd to remove a registered trade mark from the Australian Trade Marks Register on the grounds of non-use. The opponent, Allied Pinnacle NSW Pty Ltd, subsequently applied for an extension of time to oppose the removal of the trade mark, arguing that it had not received notification of the removal application. The matter was referred to a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks for a decision on the extension of time application. The delegate, Bianca Irgang, heard the submissions from both parties, reviewed the evidence, and considered the procedural and statutory requirements under the Trade Marks Act 1995 and Trade Mark Regulations 1995. Ultimately, the delegate granted the opponent's application for an extension of time to file a notice of opposition to the removal application, finding that the opponent's failure to oppose the removal was due to circumstances beyond its control. The decision was made in accordance with the principles of fairness and public interest, taking into account the relative inconvenience to the parties and the potential impact on third parties.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the opponent had a reasonable explanation for the delay in opposing the removal application for non-use and applying for an extension of time.
2. Whether the circumstances beyond the control of the opponent justified the late extension of time request.
3. Whether the Registrar was satisfied that the grounds set out in the opponent's request justified the extension of time.
4. Whether the extension of time granted was reasonable in the circumstances.
5. Whether the opponent had grounds to oppose the removal of the trade mark from the register.
Held
1. Whether the opponent had a reasonable explanation for the delay in opposing the removal application for non-use and applying for an extension of time.
The court concluded that the opponent had a reasonable explanation for the delay due to circumstances beyond its control, such as the loss of notification from IP Australia and errors in the trade mark portfolios provided by its legal representatives. The result was that the extension of time request was granted.
2. Whether the circumstances beyond the control of the opponent justified the late extension of time request.
The court concluded that the circumstances beyond the control of the opponent, such as the loss of notification from IP Australia and errors in the trade mark portfolios, justified the late extension of time request. The result was that the extension of time request was granted.
3. Whether the Registrar was satisfied that the grounds set out in the opponent's request justified the extension of time.
The court concluded that the Registrar was satisfied that the grounds set out in the opponent's request justified the extension of time. The result was that the extension of time request was granted.
4. Whether the extension of time granted was reasonable in the circumstances.
The court concluded that the extension of time granted was reasonable in the circumstances, taking into account the relative inconvenience to the parties and the public interest. The result was that the extension of time request was granted.
5. Whether the opponent had grounds to oppose the removal of the trade mark from the register.
The court concluded that the opponent had prima facie grounds to oppose the removal of the trade mark from the register, based on the long use of the trade mark and the evidence provided. The result was that the extension of time request was granted, allowing the opponent to file a notice of opposition to the removal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Delegate of the Registrar, Bianca Irgang, began by considering whether the opponent had a reasonable explanation for the delay in opposing the removal application for non-use and applying for an extension of time. The opponent contended that it had not received notice of the removal application and, even if it had, it had not realized the significance of the correspondence. The Delegate accepted the opponent's evidence that it had not received the notice, noting that the correspondence sent by IP Australia had been returned to sender. The Delegate also accepted that the opponent had intended to oppose the removal application but was prevented from doing so by circumstances beyond its control, including business changes and errors made by its legal representatives.
The Delegate then considered whether the circumstances beyond the control of the opponent justified the late extension of time request. The Delegate found that there were several factors that contributed to the opponent's delay, including the loss of the IP Australia correspondence, the opponent's business changes, and errors made by its legal representatives. The Delegate concluded that these factors were beyond the opponent's control and justified the late extension of time request.
Next, the Delegate considered whether the Registrar was satisfied that the grounds set out in the opponent's request justified the extension of time. The Delegate noted that the Regulations provided for extensions of time in certain circumstances, including when there were circumstances beyond the control of the person. The Delegate found that the opponent had satisfied the requirements of the Regulations and that the extension of time was justified.
The Delegate then considered whether the extension of time granted was reasonable in the circumstances. The Delegate noted that the Regulations required the Registrar to decide the length of the extended period having regard to what was reasonable in the circumstances. The Delegate concluded that an eight-month extension of time was reasonable in the circumstances, given the significant delay caused by the circumstances beyond the opponent's control.
Finally, the Delegate considered whether the opponent had grounds to oppose the removal of the trade mark from the register. The Delegate found that the opponent had prima facie grounds to oppose the removal of its trade mark from the register, noting that the opponent had used the trade mark since 1940 and had maintained it on its heritage-listed flour mill. The Delegate concluded that it was in the public interest for the opponent to have the opportunity to oppose the removal of its trade mark from the register.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where an opponent has not received notice of a removal application and is prevented from opposing the application by circumstances beyond its control, the Registrar may grant an extension of time for the opponent to file a notice of opposition. The Registrar must consider the relative inconvenience to the parties concerned and the public interest in deciding whether to grant the extension of time. In this case, the Delegate found that the circumstances beyond the opponent's control justified the late extension of time request and that an eight-month extension of time was reasonable in the circumstances. The Delegate also found that the opponent had prima facie grounds to oppose the removal of its trade mark from the register.