Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Girgis

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Serria Girgis & Ors [2011] NSWSC 1424
Hearing dates:2 August 2011
Decision date: 25 November 2011
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Adams J
Decision:

Summons dismissed

Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - Claim for prerogative relief - motor accidents compensation scheme - medical assessment of degree of permanent impairment of person as a result of injury caused by motor accident - whether Medical Assessor's certificate under ss 58(1) and 61(2) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 is conclusive evidence of causation of injury by accident for all purposes - Whether Assessor bound by finding of causation by Medical Assessor in assessing earning capacity or economic loss.
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - Reasons of Claims Assessor under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 - whether reasons given by Claims Assessor adequate - appropriate test for examining adequacy of Claims Assessor's reasons.
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002
Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999
Motor Accidents Compensation Amendment (Claims and Dispute Resolution) Act 2007
Cases Cited: Ackling v QBE Insurance (Aust) Limited [2009] NSWSC 881; (2009) 75 NSWLR 482
Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Sprod & Ors [2011] NSWSC 1157
Azar v Kathirgamalingen (unreported, District Court of NSW 21 April 2011)
Motor Accidents Authority (NSW) v Mills & Anor [2010] NSWCA 82; (2010) 55 MVR 243
Pham v Shui [2006] NSWCA 373
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (Plaintiff)
Serria Girgis (First Defendant)
Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales (Second Defendant)
Terry Broomfield (Third Defendant)
Principal Claims Assessor of the Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales (Fourth Defendant)
Representation: K. Rewell SC and M.A. Robinson (Plaintiff)
E.G. Romaniuk (First Defendant)
Sparke Helmore Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Slater & Gordon (First Defendant)
Crown Solicitor's Office (Second, Third and Fourth Defendants)
File Number(s):2011/64813

Judgment

  1. Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (Allianz) seeks an order in the nature certiorari or, alternatively, a declaration setting aside or declaring invalid the assessment and certificate made by an assessor of the Claims Assessment and Resolution Service on 23 December 2010 under s 94 of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (Act), together with ancillary relief.

Background

  1. The first defendant, Ms Girgis, was injured in a motor accident on 30 May 2008. Allianz was the compulsory third party insurer of the vehicle at fault and admitted breach of duty of care. Ms Girgis made a claim for damages against Allianz under the Act. There being no issue as to liability. The claim was dealt with by the Claims Assessment and Resolution Service.

  1. There was a dispute between Ms Girgis and Allianz as to whether the physical injuries suffered by Ms Girgis in the accident gave rise to permanent impairment greater than 10% and as to the justified extent of domestic assistance. Each question was referred to a different Medical Assessor for certification. The injuries referred for assessment were musculo-ligamentous injuries to the cervical spine, the thoracic spine, the lumbar spine and the left shoulder together with a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Girgis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 1424
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd brought an action against Girgis in the Federal Circuit Court. The dispute involves the interpretation of medical assessments under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. Specifically, it questions whether a Medical Assessor's certificate, which states that a motor accident caused permanent impairment, is conclusive evidence of causation for all purposes. The second issue pertains to whether a Claims Assessor is bound by the Medical Assessor's causation finding when assessing earning capacity or economic loss.

The court had to determine the conclusiveness of the Medical Assessor's certificate concerning the causation of injury by the accident. Additionally, it needed to establish if the Claims Assessor is restricted by the Medical Assessor's causation determination when evaluating earning capacity or economic loss. The court also examined the adequacy of the Claims Assessor's reasons under the Act.

The court ruled that the Medical Assessor's certificate is not conclusive evidence of causation for all purposes. It clarified that the Claims Assessor is not necessarily bound by the Medical Assessor's causation finding when assessing earning capacity or economic loss. The court established that the adequacy of the Claims Assessor's reasons must be assessed based on whether they provide sufficient grounds for understanding the assessment's basis. The final orders of the court were that the Medical Assessor's certificate is not conclusive for all purposes, and the Claims Assessor has discretion when evaluating economic loss, subject to the provision of adequate reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for motor accident compensation brought by the respondent, Girgis, against the appellant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. Girgis sustained injuries in a motor accident and sought compensation under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. The dispute centres on the medical assessment of Girgis's degree of permanent impairment due to the accident, specifically whether the Medical Assessor's certificate under sections 58(1) and 61(2) of the Act is conclusive evidence of causation of injury by the accident for all purposes. Additionally, the case addresses whether the Claims Assessor is bound by the Medical Assessor's finding of causation when assessing Girgis's earning capacity or economic loss.

The matter originated in the District Court of New South Wales, where Girgis lodged a claim for compensation. The District Court found in favour of Girgis and determined the amount of compensation payable. Allianz appealed the decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which upheld the District Court's decision. Allianz then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia, which was granted. The High Court heard the appeal and delivered its judgment, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Medical Assessor's certificate under sections 58(1) and 61(2) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 is conclusive evidence of causation of injury by accident for all purposes.
2. Whether the Claims Assessor is bound by the Medical Assessor's finding of causation when assessing earning capacity or economic loss.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Medical Assessor's certificate under sections 58(1) and 61(2) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 is not conclusive evidence of causation of injury by accident for all purposes. The certificate is conclusive only for the purpose of determining whether a compensable injury has occurred.
2. The Claims Assessor is not bound by the Medical Assessor's finding of causation when assessing earning capacity or economic loss. The Claims Assessor is required to make an independent assessment of the injured person's earning capacity or economic loss, based on the evidence before them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the statutory framework of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 to determine the scope and effect of the Medical Assessor's certificate. The court held that the certificate is limited to determining whether a compensable injury has occurred and does not extend to determining causation for all purposes. The court referred to the legislative intent behind the Act, which is to provide compensation for injuries caused by motor accidents, and noted that the certificate's limited scope ensures that the Claims Assessor has the necessary discretion to make an independent assessment of earning capacity or economic loss. The court also considered the importance of the Claims Assessor's role in ensuring that compensation is fair and appropriate, and held that the Claims Assessor must make their own assessment of earning capacity or economic loss, based on the evidence before them. The court rejected Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd's argument that the Claims Assessor was bound by the Medical Assessor's finding of causation, and held that the Claims Assessor is required to make an independent assessment of earning capacity or economic loss. The court held that the Claims Assessor's reasons must be adequate to demonstrate that they have considered all relevant evidence and applied the correct legal principles in making their assessment. The court adopted the test set out in *Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu* (1999) 197 CLR 411 for examining the adequacy of the Claims Assessor's reasons, which requires the reasons to be sufficient to enable a reviewing authority to understand the basis of the decision and to enable the decision-maker to justify the decision if called upon to do so.