Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Whitehurst

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Whitehurst [2023] NSWPICMP 4
CLAIMANT: Margaret Dorothy Whitehurst
INSURER: Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd
REVIEW Panel
PRINCIPAL MEMBER: John Harris
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Shane Moloney
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Margaret Gibson
DATE OF DECISION: 12 January 2023

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – The claimant suffered injury in a motor accident on 3 May 2018 when her vehicle was rear-ended by the insured vehicle; the medical disputes concerned the degree of impairment of the injury caused by the motor accident was greater than 10% and the provision of various physiotherapy; the claimant had ongoing dysmetria in the cervical spine assessed at 5%; the claimant had a pre-existing condition in the lumbar spine by reason of the prior L5/S1 fusion which is assessed at 20%; the pre-existing condition is evident from the CT scan dated 29 December 2017 which showed previous L5/S1 laminectomy and fusion; the current symptoms are at the same level of the impairment as the pre-existing impairment and there is no additional impairment; there was no injury to the femoral nerve because this is medically inexplicable from a rear-end collision; the claimant had consistent complaints of femoral nerve discomfort prior to the motor accident; ongoing complaints after the motor accident are explained in their entirety by the pre-existing condition; the report by the claimant was that shoulder loss of movement was due to interscapular pain; clinically, interscapular pain should not cause loss of shoulder movement; the interscapular pain was muscular related and probably due her kyphosis/posture; there was no traumatic injury to either shoulder; the present examination did not establish loss of shoulder movement due to the cervical spine injury; accordingly, there is no shoulder impairment caused by the motor accident; findings made that the physiotherapy under the treatment plan were reasonable and necessary and caused by the accident; Held – claimant assessed at 5% permanent impairment in respect of the cervical spine.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

Medical Assessment – Permanent Impairment
WHETHER THE DEGREE OF permanent impairment OF THE INJURED PERSON AS A RESULT OF THE INJURY CAUSED BY THE MOTOR ACCIDENT IS GREATER THAN 10%
THE ASSESSMENT MADE BY THE REVIEW PANEL UNDER S 7.23(1) OF THE MOTOR ACCIDENT INJURIES ACT 2017 IS AS FOLLOWS:

The Panel revokes the certificate dated 15 March 2022 and a combined certificate dated 12 May 2022 and issues a new certificate and combined certificate determining that the injuries caused by the motor accident give rise to a whole person impairment NOT GREATER THAN 10%:

Medical Assessment –Treatment and Care

Review Panel Assessment of Treatment and Care and
Replacement Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

The Review Panel confirms the certificate dated 15 March 2022.

REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Ms Dorothy Whitehurst (the claimant) suffered injury on 3 May 2018 when the insured vehicle struck the rear of the claimant’s vehicle pushing it into a vehicle in front.[1]

    [1] Insurer’s bundle, p 12.

  2. Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (the insurer) insured the owner and/or driver of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Whitehurst and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMP 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Whitehurst involved a dispute concerning the degree of impairment resulting from a motor accident that occurred on 3 May 2018, when the claimant’s vehicle was rear-ended by an insured vehicle. The core medical issues focused on whether the degree of impairment caused by the accident was greater than 10% and the necessity of various physiotherapy treatments. The claimant argued for higher impairment and the need for ongoing physiotherapy, while Allianz contended that the claimant's impairments were either pre-existing or not caused by the accident.

The court had to address several legal issues, including determining the extent of impairment caused by the accident, differentiating between pre-existing conditions and those arising from the accident, and assessing the reasonableness and necessity of the physiotherapy treatments. Specifically, the court needed to decide whether the claimant's cervical spine impairment, lumbar spine condition, femoral nerve discomfort, and shoulder pain were causally related to the motor accident. The court also had to evaluate the claimant’s complaints and medical reports to ascertain the validity of the physiotherapy treatments provided.

In its decision, the court found that the claimant had a pre-existing lumbar spine condition from a prior L5/S1 fusion, assessed at 20%. The current symptoms in the lumbar spine were at the same level as the pre-existing impairment, indicating no additional impairment from the accident. The court ruled that the claimant's femoral nerve discomfort was not caused by the rear-end collision but rather was related to a pre-existing condition. Additionally, the court determined that the claimant's shoulder loss of movement was not due to the cervical spine injury but likely related to muscular issues and posture. The court found the physiotherapy treatments under the treatment plan to be reasonable and necessary, directly resulting from the accident. Consequently, the claimant was assessed at 5% permanent impairment in respect of the cervical spine.

The court ordered that Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was liable for the reasonable and necessary physiotherapy treatments provided to the claimant as a result of the motor accident. The claimant was assessed at 5% permanent impairment in respect of the cervical spine, with no additional impairment found for the lumbar spine, femoral nerve, or shoulder conditions.