Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Jubian

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Jubian [2025] NSWPICMP 815

CLAIMANT:

Aida Jubian

INSURER:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited t/as Allianz

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Terence Stern OAM 

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Shane Moloney

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Margaret Gibson

DATE OF DECISION:

22 October 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; claimant suffered injury in a motor vehicle accident; Medical Assessor (MA) determined the claimant’s disputed treatment was related to the injuries caused by the accident and was reasonable and necessary in the circumstances; dispute about treatment; Held – Review Panel conducted its own examination and confirmed that the proposed referral was not causally related to the motor accident, and was not reasonable and necessary in the circumstances; Briggs v IAG Limited Trading as NRMA Insurance; the certificate of MA was revoked.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

1.     The Panel revokes the certificate issued by Medical Assessor Shahzad of
29 November 2024.

2.     The Panel issues a new certificate stating the proposed referral to Dr Kerdic was not causally related to the motor accident, and not reasonable and necessary as a consequence of the subject accident.  

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Aida Jubian (Ms Jubian),  was involved in a motor vehicle accident (the accident) on
    29 November 2022.

  2. On 30 November 2022, Ms Jubian attended Revesby Family Clinic (RFC) and gave a history of having fallen on a bus the previous day, 29 November 2022.

  3. Ms Jubian complained of neck pain, upper back pain and right shoulder pain radiating to the upper limb. She denied a head injury.

  4. Ms Jubian returned to RFC on 21 December 2022 with complaints of pain in her neck, back, hip and right shoulder. Dr Elhafi completed a Certificate of Capacity when he diagnosed “neck strain/back pain/hip strain/R shoulder strain”.

  5. On 13 January 2023, Ms Jubian applied for personal injury benefits. Ms Jubian alleged that in the subject accident she sustained injuries to her neck, shoulder, hip and knees.
    Ms Jubian also confirmed a history of hip pain.

  6. On 9 January 2024 Ms Jubian was referred to Dr Richard Kerdic for review of lower limb varicosities (R12). It was recorded that the varicosities had been aggravated by the subject accident.

  7. The insurer, Allianz, advised by letter on 13 April 2023 that it did not accept liability of payment for statutory benefits beyond 26 weeks of the accident.

  8. Ms Jubian has applied for a treatment dispute determination by the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) in respect to the insurer’s decision to decline approval for a consultation with vascular surgeon, Dr Kerdic.

RELEVANT LEGISLATION

  1. Section 3.24 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) relates to the provision of treatment and care. The section relevantly provides:

    “(1)    An injured person is entitled to statutory benefits for the following expenses (‘treatment and care expenses’) incurred in connection with providing treatment and care for the injured person—

    (a) the reasonable cost of treatment and care,

    ....

    (2)     No statutory benefits are payable for the cost of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Jubian and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 815
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited brought a challenge against the decision of a Medical Assessor (MA) in the case of Jubian, which concerned the claimant's treatment after a motor vehicle accident. The dispute centred on the insurer's refusal to fund a consultation with a Vascular Surgeon, Dr Richard Kerdic, for the claimant's lower-limb varicosities. The claimant, Ms Jubian, had previously lodged a treatment-dispute application, contesting the insurer's decision dated 31 January 2024. The insurer argued that the proposed treatment was not causally related to the accident injuries and was neither reasonable nor necessary.

The court was tasked with determining whether the MA's determination that the disputed treatment was related to the injuries from the motor accident and was reasonable and necessary was correct. The insurer contended that the claimant's pre-accident history of leg pain and varicosities, along with a normal venous Doppler result in December 2023, demonstrated that the requested treatment was unrelated to the accident. The court reviewed the evidence, including medical records and the MA's certificate, to assess the causal relationship between the treatment and the accident injuries.

After conducting its own examination, the court found that the Review Panel confirmed the MA's conclusion that the proposed referral to Dr Kerdic was not causally related to the motor accident and was not reasonable and necessary in the circumstances. The court relied on the principles set out in Briggs v IAG Limited Trading as NRMA Insurance to assess the reasonableness and necessity of the treatment. The insurer's argument that the referral was unrelated to the accident injuries and was not reasonable or necessary was upheld by the court. As a result, the certificate of the MA was revoked.

In conclusion, the court ruled in favour of the insurer, affirming that the treatment in dispute was neither related to the accident injuries nor reasonable and necessary. The claimant's application for funding the vascular consultation was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Panel summarises the submissions of the insurer by reference to paragraph numbers:[Preface] The insurer submits that liability for statutory benefits beyond 26 weeks was denied by notice dated 11 April 2023. Ms Jubian lodged a treatment-dispute application on 15 March 2024 concerning the insurer’s decision of 31 January 2024 to decline a consultation with Vascular Surgeon Dr Richard Kerdic, which was affirmed on internal review on 14 February 2024. The insurer submits the disputed treatment is neither reasonable nor necessary and is not causally related under s 3.24(2).[1] Pre-accident medical evidence[1.1] – [1.3] Bankstown Medical Practice (BMP) records since March 2012 show intermittent low-back pain (April 2012), back and knee pain (March 2013), and increased left-shoulder pain (July 2013). On 3 September 2013 Ms Jubian reported leg pain with varicose veins, was advised compression stockings, and was referred to Vascular Surgeon Dr Anthony Freeman.[1.4] – [1.6] On 9 and 30 September 2013 she reported back and left-leg pain attributed to a January 2013 fall. Further entries document back and knee pain in 2015 and persistent back pain by March 2017.[1.7] – [1.9] On 28 February 2018 she reported a rear-end collision of 22 February 2018 with neck, back and chest-wall pain. In September 2018 she complained of leg pain since that accident together with bilateral foot pain and night calf cramps. A physiotherapy note of 19 February 2020 records nocturnal leg numbness and knee and shoulder pain.[1.10] – [1.12] A venous Doppler on 3 January 2020 showed no deep venous thrombosis, and a lumbar CT demonstrated right L5 nerve-root impingement. She ceased attending BMP after September 2020. RFC records note attendances since 2017, including a 2017 can-drop injury to the left ankle.[1.13 ]– [1.15] On 22 February 2018 she attended Bankstown Hospital after a low-speed motor vehicle accident and was diagnosed with a seatbelt-related musculoskeletal soft-tissue injury. On 25 May 2018 she reported the accident and body numbness. A left-shoulder ultrasound on 28 May 2018 showed supraspinatus tendinitis/impingement.[1.16] – [1.18] Between 20 and 29 June 2018 records note shoulder and neck pain with arm referral, later improving neck pain, bilateral dorsal-foot pain and night cramps, and physiotherapy observations of persistent multi-region pain. On 27 September 2020 she complained of right ankle and foot pain, and on 3 March 2021 of left-calf pain; a venous duplex that day was normal.[1.19] – [1.21] On 31 March 2021 she reported a home fall with back pain radiating to the lower limbs. A lumbar CT on the same date showed L5/S1 foraminal narrowing affecting the descending left L5 root. Entries from April to June 2021 record ongoing back pain radiating to the limbs and a rheumatology review.[1.22] – [1.24] Physiotherapy on 23 June 2021 recorded increased low-back, bilateral-hip and right-shoulder pain after a fall and only minimal improvement. RFC diagnosed left trochanteric bursitis on 2 July 2021, which ultrasound confirmed on 6 July 2021. A further ultrasound on 15 November 2021 showed gluteus minimus/medius tendinopathy.[1.25] – [1.27] On 2 December 2021 RFC recorded chronic hip pain, and on 22 February 2022 further hip and low-back pain. A home fall on 24 March 2022 resulted in right knee and foot pain; on 21 April 2022 she had right-heel pain with ultrasound consistent with plantar fasciitis. On 6 September 2022 a lower-back cortisone injection was recommended, although she was hesitant.[1.28] – [1.31] On 13 September 2022 she reported generalised aches and pains, insomnia and low mood. A whole-body bone scan on 16 September 2022 showed mild osteoarthritic changes and degenerative disease at L5/S1 with facet-joint activity. In October 2022 she experienced chronic pain and right-knee pain with ultrasound showing minimal effusion, and a DEXA scan on 28 October 2022 showed osteopenia.[1.32] – [1.35] Rheumatologist A/Prof Thakkar on 1 and 29 June 2021 documented a slip/fall at home with right low-back pain extending to both legs, mild lumbar spondylosis and discovertebral degeneration at L4/5–L5/S1, and sacroiliac dysfunction. A prior CTP file relating to the 22 February 2018 accident recorded lower-leg and foot inflammation. An AHRR of 26 April 2019 noted pain in the left shoulder, hips, knees and feet described as stabbing, aching, tight, sharp and pulling.2) Post-accident treating evidence[2.1] – [2.3] On 30 November 2022, the day after the bus incident, RFC recorded neck, upper-back and right-shoulder pain radiating to the arm and no head injury. Imaging that day showed multilevel cervical disc disease, thoracic osteophytes and moderately severe right acromioclavicular joint arthropathy. On 21 December 2022 the general practitioner (GP) diagnosed neck strain, back pain, hip strain and right-shoulder strain.[2.4] – [2.6] Similar complaints continued to 7 February 2023. An AIB of 13 January 2023 claimed neck, shoulder, hip and knee injuries, with a history of hip pain confirmed. Orthopaedic surgeon Dr Maniam on 30 January 2023 recorded cervical, lumbar and right-shoulder injuries with normal lower-limb neurology and diagnosed an aggravation of lumbar degenerative disease.[2.7] – [2.9] Physiotherapy on 6 February 2023 documented pronounced pain-avoidant behaviour approximately five weeks after the bus incident. A lumbar MRI on 15 February 2023 showed multilevel facet arthropathy and degenerative disc disease worst at L5/S1 and L4/5 (left). A venous Doppler on 11 December 2023 was normal.[2.10] – [2.11] On 9 January 2024 Ms Jubian was referred to Dr Kerdic for lower-limb varicosities said to have been aggravated by the accident. On 21 February 2024 the GP asserted feet and lower-limb injuries and left-calf pain with Doppler revealing varicosity and no prior leg pain, assertions that the insurer submits are inconsistent with prior records and the December 2023 Doppler.3) Response to treatment in dispute[3.1] – [3.3] The insurer submits that the dispute concerns its refusal to fund a vascular consultation and that the requested treatment is neither reasonable and necessary nor accident-related given the pre-existing leg pain and varicosities and the absence of evidence of accident-related aggravation.[3.4] – [3.6] The insurer submits that there were no post-accident vascular-leg complaints until February 2024—over a year after the incident—and that the December 2023 Doppler was normal. Accordingly, it submits the referral to Dr Kerdic is unrelated to accident injuries and is not reasonable or necessary.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established