Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Alonso

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Alonso [2025] NSWPICMP 100

CLAIMANT:

David Alonso

INSURER:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Gary Victor Patterson

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Shane Moloney

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Drew Dixon

DATE OF DECISION:

19 February 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; treatment and care dispute; insured vehicle collided with the front off-side of the claimant’s vehicle; primary damage to the front corner and minor damage to the driver’s door; claimant was able to alight from his vehicle to exchange details with the other driver; claimant subsequently was taken by ambulance to Bankstown Hospital where he complained of neck and low back pain; claimant involved in previous motor accident in 2017 causing injuries to neck, back, and right shoulder; claimant involved as driver in a serious single-vehicle accident in 2021 causing further injury to neck and right shoulder; claimant’s treating spinal surgeon recommended cervical discectomy in 2023; insurer declined liability on basis of causation; Medical Assessor (MA) certified that the proposed surgery does relate to the accident and is reasonable and necessary; Review Panel satisfied that MRI scan performed soon after subject accident showed pathology not present in MRI scan of cervical spine performed around the time of the 2017 motor accident; Review Panel satisfied that claimant’s neck was unrelenting; Review Panel satisfied that subject accident is a contributing cause to the need for surgery as conservative treatment has failed to relieve cervical symptoms; Review Panel satisfied that proposed surgery is reasonable and necessary; Medical Assessment Certificate confirmed.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE

REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF TREATMENT AND CARE – CAUSATION

Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017

1.     The Review Panel confirms the Certificate of Medical Assessor Alan Home dated
20 May 2024.

CERTIFICATE

REVIEW PANEL ASSESSMENT OF TREATMENT AND CARE – REASONABLE AND NECESSARY

Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017

2.     The Review Panel confirms the Certificate of Medical Assessor Alan Home dated
20 May 2024.

·

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 12 August 2020, David Alonso (the claimant) was the seat-belted driver of a Mercedes 2-door Coupe travelling approximately 60kmph on the Hume Highway towards Bankstown, when the driver of the insured vehicle emerged from a side street on the claimant’s right and attempted to merge into the lane in which the claimant’s vehicle was travelling.

  2. The insured vehicle collided with the front off-side of the claimant’s vehicle, with primary damage to the front corner and minor damage to the driver’s door. The claimant was able to alight from his vehicle to exchange details with the other driver. He subsequently was taken by ambulance to Bankstown Hospital where he complained of neck and low back pain. Although he recalls an aggravation of his pre-existing right shoulder complaint, this was not recorded in the hospital notes.

  3. Following his discharge from hospital, the claimant attended his general practitioner (GP), complaining of neck pain, increased pain at the right shoulder…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Alonso and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 100
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Alonso case involved a dispute over treatment following a motor accident where the claimant’s vehicle collided with another vehicle. The claimant, who had a history of neck and back injuries from previous accidents, sought approval for a cervical discectomy. The insurer declined liability, asserting that the proposed surgery was neither reasonable nor necessary and did not relate to injuries from the accident in question. The matter was escalated to a Review Panel under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, which ultimately determined in favour of the claimant.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the claimant's proposed cervical discectomy was reasonable and necessary, and whether the surgery related to injuries caused by the accident in question. The insurer argued that the claimant's pre-existing conditions and subsequent injuries from another accident in 2021 were the primary causes of his current symptoms. The claimant, on the other hand, argued that the subject accident contributed to the need for surgery as conservative treatments had failed.

The court considered the medical evidence presented by both parties, including MRI scans, neurological reports, and assessments by various medical professionals. The Review Panel found that the MRI performed shortly after the accident showed pathology not present in the MRI from the 2017 accident, indicating that the subject accident contributed to the claimant's condition. The Panel concluded that the claimant's neck pain was unrelenting and that the proposed surgery was reasonable and necessary as conservative treatment had not alleviated his symptoms.

The court upheld the Review Panel's decision, confirming that the proposed surgery was reasonable and necessary and related to the subject accident. The insurer's objections were dismissed, and the claimant was entitled to the proposed treatment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In response to the claimant’s treatment dispute submissions, the insurer submitted that the treatment requested is neither reasonable nor necessary in the circumstances and does not relate to an injury caused by the subject accident. It referenced the original decision and determination upon internal review declining the proposed treatment. Further submissions were made as follows:“The insurer notes that the claimant suffered pre-existing symptoms in a prior motor vehicle accident on 10 July 2017. It refers to a MRI of the cervical spine dated 17 August 2017 which demonstrated multiple annular tears at the cervical spine and minor disc herniations (the Panel notes that the words “and minor disc herniations” do not appear in the report). It refers to Dr Herald’s report dated 2 August 2017 which noted neck and back pain radiating to both shoulders.The insurer describes the circumstances of the subject accident and the subsequent accident on 20 March 2021 noting that the latter was more severe.The insurer references the injuries reported by the claimant following the subject accident and notes Dr Herald’s diagnosis of whiplash injury to the cervical and lumbar spine. It references an X-ray of the cervical spine dated 12 October 2020 (to which the previous Review Panel referred) which found no abnormalities to the cervical spine. It references a MRI of the cervical spine performed on 15 October 2020 which found abnormalities at C6/C7 described as:‘Small focal posterior central fissure and disc protrusion is indenting the anterior thecal sac containing the anterior cord. Prominent unconvertible and facet joint degenerative changes are causing severe foraminal narrowing worse on the left which has the potential to compress the C7 nerve roots.’The insurer’s submissions then referenced medical evidence which post-dated the subsequent March 2021 motor accident.It refers to the report dated 21 May 2021 by Dr Stan Levy, neurologist, to which the previous Review Panel referred. Dr Levy noted both prior motor accidents and recorded that the major problem following the 2020 motor accident was right shoulder pain. Dr Levy also recorded that, since the March 2021 accident, the claimant had experienced pain in his lower back and neck, particularly on the right side, and pain in the right shoulder. Neurological examination was then normal. The insurer refers to a report dated 19 September 2021 by Dr Levy which stated the claimant’s radicular pain symptoms were prominently in a C5/C6 distribution. The insurer notes Dr Levy’s assertion that the claimant’s symptoms, based on the MRI findings, could be due to cervical discogenic disease and foraminal stenosis with possible nerve root entrapment at C5/C6.The insurer then references a report dated 21 October 2021 by Dr Dudley O’Sullivan, neurologist, and submits that Dr O’Sullivan affirmed that the claimant’s symptoms, demonstrated at the time of the report, were degenerative in nature.The insurer references the certificate dated 22 July 2022 by Medical Assessor Cameron who found the claimant suffered a soft tissue injury to his neck, as a result of the subject accident, which he determined to be a minor injury.The insurer refers to nerve conduction studies conducted on 30 January 2023, which showed mild ulnar sensory neuropathy, which Dr Choong opined could be managed .conservatively. The insurer refers to an EMG study dated 15 February 2023 the findings of which were within normal limits, and showed no electrophysiological evidence to suggest significant right sided cervical nerve root compression, nor ulnar radiculopathy.The insurer refers to the previous Review Panel Certificate dated 23 February 2023 which diagnosed the claimant as follows:‘Whiplash associated disorder Grade II (causing neck pain). WAD Grade III can be excluded due to a normal neurological examination and normal nerve conduction studies (in the documentation).’Further, the Certificate asserted:‘We accept there was a soft tissue injury to the cervical spine probably involving an aggravation of degenerative changes at C5/C6. We do not accept that there was traumatic injury to nerves or a complete or partial rapture of tendons, ligaments, menisci or cartilage’ and ‘there are no recorded observations of two signs of radiculopathy as defined in cl 5.8 of the Guidelines.’The insurer refers to a MRI of the cervical spine dated 31 May 2023 (see previously) which, in the insurer’s submission, shows similar results to the MRI performed on 15 October 2020, with the addition of endplate osteophytes. The insurer highlights that the updated MRI demonstrates there are significant degenerative changes at C6/C7.The insurer refers to Dr Nair’s report dated 10 October 2023 which asserted that the claimant’s symptoms began following the subject accident on 12 August 2020 justifying the proposed treatment. The insurer submits that the evidence clearly indicates that the claimant’s symptoms in the cervical spine began prior to the subject accident. The insurer notes that Dr Nair disagreed with the recent nerve conduction studies. He opined that a diagnosis of neural compression is established which, the insurer notes, is inconsistent with the previous Review Panel’s findings that the claimant ‘did not have radiculopathy at the recent examination’ which was normal. The insurer submits that Dr Nair has not provided sufficient explanation as to why his neurological findings differ to the nerve conduction studies as well as the previous Review Panel’s findings. Further, the insurer submits that Dr Nair has not adequately provided reasoning as to why a fusion is required in the circumstances and why it is related to the subject accident rather than the 2021 accident.The insurer refers to the claimant’s reliance upon recent nerve conduction studies which showed a nerve injury to the right elbow. The insurer submits that there is no medical evidence connecting that condition to the need for the proposed C6/C7 anterior cervical discectomy fusion and bone grafting. The insurer submits the medical evidence demonstrates that the claimant’s neurological symptoms only presented following his subsequent motor accident in March 2021.The insurer finally submits that, having regard to the overwhelming preponderance of evidence, the proposed surgery is unreasonable and unnecessary and not causally related to the injury suffered in the subject accident.R4 Medical certificate dated 19 July 2017.R5 MRI of cervical spine dated 17 August 2017 reported by Dr Ron Shnier as follows:The cerebellar tonsils end above the foramen magnum.The signal and morphology of the cervical cord is normal.At C2/C3 the disc is normal.At C3/C4 there is a small anteroinferior annular tear.At C4/C5 there is minor annular bulging.At C5/C6 there is C6/C7 there is a small posterior annular tear.At C7/T1 the disc is normal.At no level is there canal narrowing. No discrete nerve root compressive lesion seen in the lateral recesses or exit foramina.The bone marrow signal and paravertebral soft tissues outline normally.ConclusionMultiple annular tearsR6 Final report of CT cervical spine reported on 12 August 2020 by Dr Diana Tran.ConclusionMinor motion artefact in the lower cervical spine. Within this limitation, no acute fracture line is noted.R7 X-ray cervical spine reported on 12 October 2020 by Dr Zane Sherif.FindingsNormal cervical claudosis. No acute boney pathology. No prevertebral oedema. Neural foramina appear capacious.R8 Report dated 21 October 2021 by Dr Dudley O’Sullivan, neurologist, to the insurer.Dr O’Sullivan viewed a MRI of the cervical spine performed after the subject accident. He opined that the MRI revealed quite severe multi-level degenerative changes throughout the cervical spine. Nevertheless, Dr O’Sullivan noted that the claimant ‘had significant pathology with regards to his cervical spine as a consequence of the motor vehicle accident in 2020’. Dr O’Sullivan describes the circumstances of the subsequent motor accident on 20 March 2021 in detail. He viewed a MRI scan of the cervical spine performed after that accident. Dr O’Sullivan says that the MRI showed some mild degenerative changes but no clinical ligamentous injury or acute intervertebral disc injury. Dr O’Sullivan opines that the MRI scan of the cervical spine did not show any significant abnormality. Dr O’Sullivan stated that the subject accident caused aggravation of the claimant’s pre-existing cervical and lumbar spondylotic disease as well as his right shoulder arthritic changes.Dr O’Sullivan found that, at the time of the March 2021 accident, the claimant was still experiencing symptoms in his neck and lower back which he was managing at home. He thought that the March 2021 accident caused further aggravation of the claimant’s previous cervical and lumbar spondylotic disease, but no neurological abnormality. As to whether the claimant’s symptoms related to the subject accident or the 2021 accident, Dr O’Sullivan opined as follows:“His current symptoms are not related to the motor vehicle accident in 2021, but that accident would have aggravated his pre-existing cervical and lumbar spondylotic disease and, in my view, that aggravation would have ceased after a period of three months and his ongoing symptoms would relate to his pre-existing degenerative cervical and lumbar spondylotic disease. At present, his symptoms are not secondary to the motor vehicle accidents. His present symptoms, as far as I could ascertain, are no different to his previous accidents, and relate to his cervical and lumbar disc degeneration… I do not think the changes that we are seeing now are in any way different from the previous MRI changes in his cervical spine and lumbar spine that was seen following the accident in 2020.”R9 NSW Police report dated 2 March 2022.R10 Certificates of Capacity from 16 September 2020 to 23 September 2023.R11 CT guided right side C6/C7 foraminal injection reported on 4 September 2023 by Dr Simon Dimmick to Dr Nair.R12 Letter dated 9 October 2023 denying treatment.R13 Clinical notes of Dr John Tawfik (various dates).R14 Clinical notes of Brain Power Neurology (various dates).R15 Clinical notes of Dr Naresh Verma (various dates).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established