Allen v Toowoomba Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2011] QPEC 81

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

JUDGE ROBIN QC

P & E Appeal No 27 of 2011

DAVID JOHN ALLEN Appellant

and

TOOWOOMBA REGIONAL COUNCIL Respondent

and

ADMINISTERING AUTHORITY UNDER THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ACT 1994 Co-Respondent

and

DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND        Co-Respondent
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

and

RODERIC ANGUS LOGAN,                 Co-Respondents
DAMIAN WILLIAM McINNERNEY,
LEAH COLLEEN McINNERNEY,
PETER DAVID MORGAN and
OWENA RUTH REIMERS

P & E Appeal No 92 of 2010

PETER DAVID MORGAN                   Appellant

and

TOOWOOMBA REGIONAL COUNCIL           Respondent

and

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF       Co-Respondent
ENVIRONMENT AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

and

CHIEF EXECUTIVE UNDER THE            Co-Respondent
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ACT 1994

and

DAMIEN WILLIAM McINNERNEY,           Co-Respondents
LEAH COLLEEN McINNERNEY,
GRANT NEWSON,
BARRY REIMERS and
OWENA RUTH REIMERS

P & E Appeal No 559 of 2011

GRANT NEWSON  Appellant

and

TOOWOOMBA REGIONAL COUNCIL           Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 10/06/2011

ORDER

CATCHWORDS

Council decision to approve expansion of a feedlot leads to a conditions appeal by the developer which submitters elected to join as co-respondents - extensions of time for those submitters to launch their own appeals refused - likewise for an objector whose purported submission was made electronically (his appeal and application to co-respond being rejected) - valid submitter appeal recently commenced by a submitter overlooked by Council in notifying its decision - whether an issue of "competence" of the developer was relevant or should had been raised - early limited disclosure by a government entity co-respondent volunteered to facilitate mediation

HIS HONOUR:  The orders tidy up a number of matters that have been left hanging in these appeals.

They finally give effect to the court's views expressed in published reasons that Mr Newson's submission which it is accepted that he made against a development proposal was not a properly made submission, because, albeit timely, it was not signed, having been sent to the Council by electronic means which that council, unlike a handful of others, perhaps Brisbane only, had embraced: Morgan v Toowoomba Regional Council (No. 2) [2011] QPEC 61.

Mr Newson's late appeal and his application to become a
co-respondent in any other appeal must fail.  The court would not have been justified in exercising any discretion it might have (there is none) to allow extra time and deprive Mr Morgan, the developer of the tactical advantage he has of being able to end the court’s involvement by withdrawing his appeal.  Nor should it allow co-respondents by election in it more time to start their own appeals.

Most of the time this morning has been devoted to working out whether there is, or ought to be, in any of the appeals, an issue which the McInnerneys and their counsel, Mr Collins provocatively, and maybe offensively to Mr Morgan, described as "competency".


The notion is that on past performance Mr Morgan's management of the feed lot, which is to be expanded under the relevant development approval the subject of the appeals, has been deficient so that he ought to suffer a consequence of his application for development approvals for expansion being refused.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allen v Toowoomba Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QPEC 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Allen v Toowoomba Regional Council, the Planning and Environment Court was tasked with resolving various appeals concerning the Toowoomba Regional Council's decision to approve an expansion of a feedlot. The appellants, including David John Allen, Peter David Morgan, and Grant Newson, contested the approval, while the Toowoomba Regional Council and other entities were respondents. The core disputes centred around the timing of appeals, the validity of certain submissions, and the introduction of new issues such as the competency of the feedlot operator. The court had to determine whether to allow extensions of time for appeals and submissions, and whether the competency of the developer was a relevant consideration in the approval process.

The court held that Grant Newson's late appeal and his application to join as a co-respondent in another appeal should be dismissed because his submission against the development proposal was not properly made, being unsigned and sent electronically. The court also decided that co-respondents who elected to join an appeal should not be granted additional time to commence their own appeals. The court entertained the issue of the developer's competency, suggesting that while it was not a planning matter per se, the record of the operator's past performance could be relevant. Ultimately, the developer's past management issues were deemed to be outside the scope of the current appeals, which focused on the approval of the development.

In finalising the matters, the court ordered that the appeals proceed as outlined, ensuring that all relevant issues were identified and that the timeline for mediation and disclosure was set. The court accepted early disclosure by the Administering Authority under the Environmental Protection Act 1994, facilitating the mediation process. The orders included specific conditions for the conduct of the appeals and the mediation, ensuring that all parties had the opportunity to address their concerns effectively.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.