Allen and Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2015] AATA 808 (16 October 2015)
Division
GENERAL DIVISION
File Number
2014/4428
Re
Brian Allen
APPLICANT
And
Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Miss E A Shanahan, Member
Date 16 October 2015 Place Melbourne The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
...............................................................
Miss E A Shanahan, Member
COMPENSATION – claim for aggravation of pre-existing cervical spondylosis due to trauma to the cervical spine – claimed faulty vehicle – expert evidence as to safety of the vehicle – conflicting non-expert mechanical evidence – credit of applicant – applicant maintains fault lays with the truck rather than his perhaps unfamiliarity with seat controls – decision affirmed
Legislation
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 sections 5A, 5B and 14
Cases
Re Liu and Comcare [2004] AATA 617
REASONS FOR DECISION
Miss E A Shanahan, Member
16 October 2015
Mr Allen lodged an application for worker’s compensation on 6 June 2014, the nature of the claim being for damage to C4/5, C5/6 causing pain and numbness in the left arm and pain in the neck. The injury was attributed to a malfunctioning seat in the garbage collection vehicle he was driving on 3 June 2014. The vehicle in question had been a replacement vehicle as his usual very modern rear end loader was being serviced.
On 17 July 2014 a senior case manager of the respondent, Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd (Transpacific) made a determination declining liability for workers’ compensation. Mr Allen sought review of this decision by a reconsideration delegate. Mr Mark Simpson, the reconsideration delegate, on behalf of Transpacific affirmed the determination on 14 August 2014. While he considered all the evidence in detail Mr Simpson’s decision rested primarily on the evidence of independent experts and the mechanical assessment by staff of Transpacific who had found no defects or faulty performance of the seat of the truck Mr Allen drove on 3 June 2014.
Mr Allen made an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 25 August 2014 for a review of the decision of the reconsideration delegate.
Mr Mark Carey of counsel instructed by Zaparas Lawyers appeared for the applicant and Mr Steven Whybrow of counsel instructed by HBA Legal appeared for Transpacific. The Tribunal was provided with the documentation filed in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T-documents) which were tendered as Exhibit R1. Both parties tendered considerable volumes of documents a list of which is appended to this decision. Evidence before the Tribunal was given by the applicant Mr Brian Allen, Mr A Aliashkevich, neurosurgeon, Dr D Rillstone, general practitioner, Mr R McDonald, consulting engineer, Mr G Khurana, neurosurgeon, Dr S Richardson, mechanical engineer, Mr B Layton, the workshop manager of Transpacific, Mr G Barns, the operations supervisor for Transpacific at their Clayton depot and Mr C Baunton, diesel mechanic employed by Transpacific at their Clayton depot.
BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION
Mr Allen claims that on 3 June 2014 he was required to drive a truck…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allen and Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] AATA 808
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Mr Allen alleged that he hit his head on the roof of the truck several times during his rounds, which he attributed to the poor condition of the driver's seat. Transpacific, on the other hand, argued that Mr Allen's injuries were not work-related but rather a result of his failure to properly adjust the seat or use the seatbelt. The Tribunal examined the evidence, including testimonies from Mr Allen, his supervisors, and medical experts, as well as reports from various sources. The Tribunal noted that Mr Allen had a history of pre-existing cervical spondylosis, which could cause recurring symptoms. However, the Tribunal also found that the injuries Mr Allen sustained in June 2014 were consistent with the patterns of his pre-existing condition. Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that while Mr Allen's injuries were genuine, they were not caused by the compensable event. The Tribunal found that Mr Allen's failure to properly adjust the seat or use the seatbelt contributed to his injuries. As a result, the Tribunal dismissed Mr Allen's claim for compensation.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I asked Mr Layton if it was possible to have a partially open valve-like effect in the air-compression tubing to the seat, to which he responded that the pressure would take a longer time to reach its ideal level and again in response to my question stated they had no means of checking as to whether there was an obstruction in the air-compressor system. According to Mr Layton, the only other report of problems with the Acco truck had occurred in 2015 after its transfer to Morwell when it was reported that the seat in the Acco truck bounced excessively. This was found to be due to the so called shocker or dampener button being turned off and once turned on the problem was solved. This report had occurred in the early hours of the morning by virtue of phone connection between the driver and the workshop and had been corrected by advice given by telephone. Mr Layton advised that all drivers had his telephone number and while he started work at 6:00 am and finished at 6:00pm, he was on call 24 hours a day and readily contactable by all of Transpacific’s drivers.Mr Gary Barns, Operations Supervisor, Clayton Depot Mr Barns has been the operations supervisor dealing with Mr Allen for the past two years and has been employed by Transpacific at their Clayton depot for eight years. He explained that all of Transpacific’s drivers check their truck when they arrive for duty and if anything is amiss the workshop is contacted and the truck inspected. At the end of the work day the driver performs a further check of the vehicle and completes a vehicle report. If there is any defect detected he takes the report to the workshop. On 3 June 2014, Mr Barns said he had been telephoned by Mr Allen who reported that he had hit his head on the roof of the Acco truck on several occasions. Mr Barns’ evidence was that he told Mr Allen to ring the workshop and they would come out to him and inspect the truck or he could bring it into the workshop. Mr Barns denied that he had said suck it up princess in response to Mr Allen, as attested by Mr Allen in his evidence. On his arrival at the Clayton depot Mr Allen walked into Mr Barns’ office and asked for the injury book. Mr Barns notified the workshop that the vehicle may have a defect and also telephoned the branch manager. He did not inspect the vehicle himself as he is not a qualified mechanic. Mr Barns said that Mr Allen’s work performance had always been satisfactory or good but that he appeared to have mood swings. Mr Barns had noted that he was easily upset, referred to Mr Allen as varying from day to day and described by him as good Brian and bad Brian. Mr Allen would ring Mr Barns during his rounds and make comments such as I’ve had enough of this and I’m just over it and then hang up. He would not explain what he meant by these statements. In accordance with company policy Mr Barns had driven Mr Allen to the Interhealth Medical Clinic on 4 June 2014 in order to see the facility preferred doctor. Mr Barns had sat in the waiting room while Mr Allen was examined and was then called into the doctor’s office to be told of any work restrictions that would be in place and to provide information about light duties that might be available.