| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
| CITATION: | Alleman v Gunnedah Shire Council & Ors [2024] NSWPIC 70 |
| APPLICANT: | Tatiana Alleman |
| FIRST RESPONDENT: SECOND RESPONDENT: THIRD RESPONDENT: FOURTH RESPONDENT: FIFTH RESPONDENT: | Gunnedah Shire Council Helena Rosalind Anne Jones Claudia Elizabeth Jones Isabella Alice Jones Cecily Susannah Margaret Gunn |
| MEMBER: | Rachel Homan |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 20 February 2024 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION - Application for compensation in respect of death of worker; deceased worker had a pre-existing bipolar affective disorder and comorbid alcohol use disorder; excessive drinking at a work conference; subsequent stressful events in workplace; Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch, AV v AW, and BGV v Waverley Council referred to; Held – applicant failed to discharge onus of demonstrating on the balance of probabilities that employment was the main contributing factor to an aggravation of the deceased worker’s disease; award for the first respondent employer. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | The Commission determines: 1. Award for the first respondent. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
BACKGROUND
Mr Paul Christian Jones (the deceased worker) was employed by Gunnedah Shire Council (the first respondent) as an Economic Development Manager. On 3 June 2021, the deceased worker died due to the combined effects of acute alcohol intoxication and mixed drug effect.
On 22 June 2021, solicitors acting on behalf of the deceased worker’s wife, Ms Tatiana Alleman (the applicant), wrote to the first respondent seeking compensation pursuant to ss 25 and 26 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) in respect of the death.
Liability to pay compensation was disputed in a notice issued pursuant to s 78 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act) on
11 May 2022. That decision was maintained following internal reviews on 25 October 2022 and 4 April 2023.The present proceedings were commenced by the applicant by lodgement of an Application in Respect of Death of Worker (the Application) lodged in the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) on 3 August 2023.
The Application identified the applicant’s three daughters (the second, third and fourth respondents) as dependants.
The Application was subsequently amended, amongst other things, to name the deceased worker’s daughter from a previous relationship as fifth respondent.
PROCEDURE BEFORE THE PERSONAL INJURY COMMISSION
The parties appeared for conciliation conference and arbitration hearing in Sydney on
15 December 2023.The applicant was represented by Mr BSO Parker instructed by Ms Sabrina Morrell.
The first respondent was represented by Mr John Catsanos SC instructed by Mr Mick Franco.
The second respondent was represented by Mr Luke Morgan instructed by Mr Toby Tancred.
The third respondent was represented by Mr John Gaitanis instructed by Mr Toby Tancred.
The fourth respondent was represented by Mr Graham Barter instructed by Mr Toby Tancred.
The fifth respondent was represented by Ms Lyn Goodman instructed by Ms Ana Jaglic.
I am satisfied that the parties to the dispute understand the nature of the application and the legal implications of any assertion made in the information supplied. I have used my best endeavours…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alleman v Gunnedah Shire Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWPIC 70
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had successfully demonstrated on the balance of probabilities that the deceased worker's employment was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of their pre-existing conditions. This required the court to consider whether the workplace environment and events could be said to have significantly contributed to the worker's condition deteriorating to the point of death. Relevant cases such as Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch, AV v AW, and BGV v Waverley Council were referred to in the analysis of the onus of proof and the nature of the connection between work and the aggravation of the conditions.
The court found that the applicant had not discharged the onus of proving on the balance of probabilities that the employment was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of the worker's conditions. The court noted that while there were stressful events in the workplace, there was insufficient evidence to establish a direct causal link between the employment and the aggravation of the worker's conditions, particularly given the worker's excessive drinking at a work conference and other personal factors. The court emphasised that the applicant needed to demonstrate that the work was the main contributing factor, which was not achieved in this instance. Consequently, the application for compensation was dismissed, and the award was made in favour of the Gunnedah Shire Council.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the court as an application for compensation in respect of the death of a worker. The application was filed by the applicant, who sought compensation for the deceased worker. The matter was heard by the court, which examined the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. The court considered the relevant legal principles and precedents, including the cases of Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch, AV v AW, and BGV v Waverley Council.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the applicant has discharged the onus of demonstrating on the balance of probabilities that employment was the main contributing factor to an aggravation of the deceased worker's disease.
2. If the applicant has not discharged the onus, whether the award should be made for the first respondent employer.
Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant failed to discharge the onus of demonstrating on the balance of probabilities that employment was the main contributing factor to an aggravation of the deceased worker's disease.
2. Given the failure to discharge the onus, the court determined that the award should be made for the first respondent employer.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the complex interplay between the deceased worker's pre-existing conditions, his excessive drinking at a work conference, and subsequent stressful events in the workplace. The key issue was whether the employment was the main contributing factor to the aggravation of the worker's disease, specifically his bipolar affective disorder and comorbid alcohol use disorder. The court noted the significance of the onus of proof on the applicant, which required a demonstration on the balance of probabilities. In examining the evidence, the court referenced several authorities including Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch, AV v AW, and BGV v Waverley Council, which established precedents for determining the causative link between employment and aggravation of pre-existing conditions. The court concluded that the applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to meet the onus of proof, particularly in distinguishing the effects of the pre-existing conditions and the impact of the work environment and events. Consequently, the court determined that the award should be made for the first respondent employer, recognising the lack of clear causation attributable to the employment circumstances. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, is that in cases of pre-existing conditions exacerbated by work-related factors, a clear and convincing demonstration of causation by the applicant is required to shift the award liability from the employer to the applicant. This decision aligns with previous authorities that emphasize the need for strong evidence to establish a direct link between employment and the aggravation of disease.