Allan Menezes v Gyrotonic Sales Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposed application by Gyrotonic Sales Corporation under section 92 to remove 752769(41) GYROTONICS registered in the name of Allan Menezes.

Delegate: Ian Thompson
Representation: Applicants: Simon Williams of Spruson & Ferguson
Opponent:  Carmen Champion instructed by Hodgkinson McInnes Pappas
Decision: s92 proceedings – onus on owner of trade mark to show bona fide intention to use and use within relevant period – use of trade mark within relevant period not established.
Costs ordered against the opponent.

Background

  1. Allan Menezes (‘the owner’ or ‘the opponent’) of North Sydney, New South Wales, owns a registered trade mark, current details of which are:

    App No:  752769

    Registered from:  16 January 1998

    Services:Class: 41 Exercise and fitness programme services

    Trade Mark:  GYROTONICS
      (‘the registered trade mark’)

  2. On 10 March 2003, Gyrotronic Sales Corporation (‘the applicant’) filed application under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) claiming that during the period 10 February 2000 until 10 February 2003 the registered trade mark was not used or used in good faith by either the owner or an authorised user. 

  3. On 27 April 2004, Gyrotronic Sales Corporation filed a second application for removal under section 92(4)(a) of the Act claiming that on the date that the application was filed, the applicant for registration had no intention in good faith to use, or to authorize the use of, the trade mark or to assign the trade mark to a body corporate.

  4. On 14 April 2004 and 4 June 2004 respectively, Allan Menezes, filed notices of opposition to the removal of the registered trade mark alleging that the applicant for removal was not a person aggrieved and that the registered trade mark had been used within the relevant period and it had been used in good faith.

  5. The parties have both served and filed evidence as allowed by the Act and regulations thereto.

  6. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the matters concurrently at a hearing in Sydney on 20 October 2005.  Simon Williams of Spruson & Ferguson appeared for the applicant.  Carmen Champion instructed by Hodgkinson McInnis Pappas appeared in person for the opponent.

    Evidence and discussion

  7. Evidence served and filed in relation to these proceedings comprises:

Declarant Occupation
Known As
Date made Exhibits
Evidence in Support
Allan Menezes Pilates Instructor
‘Menezes’
13 October 2003 AM-1 to AM-3
Evidence in Answer
Michael Anthony Rumore Investigator
‘Rumore’
8 April 2004 A to F
Simon Dudley Williams Solicitor
‘Williams 1’
15 April 2004 A to Z, AA to CC, DD to LL, NN to XX
Matt Aversa Company Secretary
‘Aversa 1’
21 June 2004 A to P
Matt Aversa Company Secretary
‘Aversa 2’
23 July 2004
Simon Dudley Williams Solicitor
‘Williams 2’
21 October 2005 A
  1. This decision is about exercise programs and machines, especially those related to Pilates.  Pilates is a particular exercise regime devised in the 1920s by Joseph H. Pilates who was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allan Menezes v Gyrotonic Sales Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ATMO 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns a trade mark dispute heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The parties were Allan Menezes (the opponent) and Gyrotonic Sales Corporation (the applicant). The dispute arose from the applicant's claim that the opponent had not used the registered trade mark "GYROTONICS" in good faith for the nominated services, nor had an intention to do so, within the period of 10 February 2000 to 10 February 2003. The opponent, who had registered the trade mark in 1998 for "Exercise and fitness programme services," contended that he had indeed used the mark in good faith during the relevant period.

The primary legal issues before the delegate were whether the opponent had genuinely used the registered trade mark "GYROTONICS" in relation to the nominated services within the specified period, and whether the opponent had an intention to use the trade mark in good faith. The applicant sought to demonstrate non-use and lack of good faith intention, while the opponent sought to prove otherwise through adduced evidence.

The delegate considered evidence presented by both parties, including a declaration from an enquiry agent who investigated the use of the trade mark. This agent visited the opponent's premises and was informed by staff that the opponent was overseas, had imported a GYROTONICS exercise machine from the USA approximately eight years prior, and that the machine was for use with Pilates exercises rather than for resale. The delegate noted that the exact nature of the relationship between the applicant and the inventor of the GYROTONICS system, Juliu Horvath, was not clearly established by the evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the matters concurrently at a hearing in Sydney on 20 October 2005. Simon Williams of Spruson & Ferguson appeared for the applicant. Carmen Champion instructed by Hodgkinson McInnis Pappas appeared in person for the opponent.Evidence and discussion Evidence served and filed in relation to these proceedings comprises: This decision is about exercise programs and machines, especially those related to Pilates. Pilates is a particular exercise regime devised in the 1920s by Joseph H. Pilates who was born in Germany and lived in New York. The exercise regime has become quite popular and is widely available from a number of different people and organizations. In 1999, Allan Menezes (the opponent) went to New York to be trained as a trainer in a Pilates-related fitness course called GYROTONICS which based around a particular exercise machine which is called a GYROTONICS machine. This training was provided by Juliu Horvath who devised the machine and the exercise regime which is based around it. I understand from the evidence that Juliu Horvath has some relationship with the applicant for removal, although the exact nature of the relationship does not clearly emerge from the evidence. In 1998, the opponent bought one of the GYROTONICS exercise machines from New York. I would gather that the purchase was from the opponent or Mr Horvath (although this does not emerge from the evidence), and the opponent imported the machine into Australia. On 16 January 1998, the opponent registered the trade mark GYROTONICS trade mark in Australia for ‘Exercise and fitness programme services’ (‘the nominated services’). Put baldly, the opponent claims that his evidence shows that he has used the registered trade mark GYROTONICS in good faith and in relation to the nominated services within the period 10 February 2000 until 10 February 2003. The applicant claims that the evidence shows that the opponent did not have an intention to use the registered trade mark in good faith and has not used the trade mark within the period 10 February 2000 until 10 February 2003. The opponent has adduced evidence which is said to show the use of the registered trade mark and the applicant debates this and has provided evidence which is said to cast doubt on this. The first plank in the bridge the applicant seeks to build is the declaration by Michael Anthony Rumore, a licensed enquiry agent who spent some time from January 2003 investigating whether the trade mark was used by the opponent. On 29 January 2003, Mr Rumore attended at The Pilates Institute of Australia (of which the opponent is a principal) at North Sydney. Mr Rumore was informed by administrative staff that the opponent was absent overseas, that the opponent had imported the GYROTONICS exercise machine from the USA about 8 years previously, that it is on the premises and that the machine was not intended for resale but was for use with the Pilates exercises provided to clients of The Pilates Institute of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established