[2005] TASSC 81
CITATION: Allan and GDA Plumbing Pty Ltd v Townsley [2005] TASSC 81
PARTIES: ALLAN, Geoffrey David
GDA PLUMBING PTY LTD
v
TOWNSLEY, Wilfred Asquith
HOCKING, Anthony
TILLEY, Raymond Francis
FADER, Geoffrey Clement Francis
COLLINS, Rex Joseph
TUNNEY, Joy Augustine
LUCK, William John
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S: 840A/1984
DELIVERED ON: 26 August 2005
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 4, 15 August 2005
JUDGMENT OF: Hill AJ
CATCHWORDS:
Procedure – Supreme Court procedure – Tasmania – Practice under Rules of Court – Other matters arising before trial – Discontinuance – Leave given to discontinue – Notice of discontinuance not filed – Whether leave effects discontinuance.
Rules of the Supreme Court 1965 (Tas), O29, r1.
Chugg and Chalke v Dwyer A72/1993, followed.
Spies v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1991) 24 NSWLR 691; Logwon Pty Ltd v Warringah Shire Council (1993) 33 NSWLR 13; Tasmanian Outstanding Property Investments Pty Ltd & Anor v Dickenson [2000] TASSC 167; Ainsworth v Wilding [1896] 1 Ch 673; Cooper v Williams [1963] 2 QB 567, referred to.
Aust Dig Procedure [277]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Plaintiffs: P W Tree SC
Defendants: T J Ellis SC
Solicitors:
Plaintiffs: FitzGerald and Browne
Defendants: Director of Public Prosecutions
Judgment Number: [2005] TASSC
Number of paragraphs: 26
Serial No 81/2005
File No 840A/1984
GEOFFREY DAVID ALLAN and GDA PLUMBING PTY LTD v WILFRED ASQUITH TOWNSLEY, ANTHONY HOCKING, RAYMOND FRANCIS TILLEY, GEOFFREY CLEMENT FRANCIS FADER, REX JOSEPH COLLINS, JOY AUGUSTINE TUNNEY and WILLIAM JOHN LUCK
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT HILL AJ
26 August 2005
By letter of 22 December 2004, the solicitors for the plaintiffs wrote to the Registrar of the Supreme Court in the following terms:
"This action went to trial in 1991, before Mr Justice Slicer and a jury. The case was settled with the plaintiffs being given leave to discontinue. A notice of discontinuance was never filed. The plaintiffs have now come into possession of a significant quantity of material that constitutes fresh evidence. They take the view that the settlement in 1991 has been vitiated.
The plaintiffs ask that the action be listed for directions so that they can apply for the following orders:
1That the plaintiffs be given leave to proceed pursuant to rule 56(1).
2That the plaintiffs have leave to use an affidavit on the hearing of this application."
Mr Tree SC and Mr Ellis SC, who appeared for the plaintiffs and defendants respectively at the hearing of the application for leave to proceed, agreed that the relevant rule for consideration was the Rules of the Supreme Court 1965, O29.
The main action has a long history which seems to have culminated on Monday 21 October 1991 when Mr Gunson, then counsel for the plaintiffs (the applicants) had the following exchange with Slicer J, the trial judge:
"MR GUNSON: Your Honour, I am pleased to be able to advise the Court that this action has now been settled and I would seek to announce to the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allan and GDA Plumbing Pty Ltd v Townsley and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] TASSC 81
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the granting of leave to discontinue by the court automatically resulted in the discontinuance of the proceedings, even in the absence of a formal notice of discontinuance being filed. The court was required to interpret the relevant provisions of the Rules of Court and consider the procedural requirements for discontinuing a case. Specifically, the court needed to decide whether the plaintiffs' failure to file a notice of discontinuance despite the court's leave nullified the discontinuance or whether the leave itself sufficed.
In resolving the matter, the court examined the provisions of the Rules of Court that pertain to the discontinuance of proceedings. It concluded that the grant of leave to discontinue by the court does indeed effect the discontinuance of the proceedings, irrespective of whether a formal notice of discontinuance is subsequently filed. The court reasoned that the primary purpose of the leave is to provide a clear and unequivocal indication of the parties' intentions to discontinue the proceedings. As such, the formal notice, while typically required, does not override the effect of the leave granted by the court. The court held that the plaintiffs' failure to file a formal notice did not negate the effect of the leave, and the proceedings were thus properly discontinued.
As a result of the court's decision, the proceedings were formally discontinued, and the case was removed from the court's list. The plaintiffs were no longer required to pursue their claims against the defendant, and the defendant was released from any further obligations in the matter. The court's interpretation of the Rules of Court provided clarity on the procedural requirements for discontinuing proceedings and reinforced the importance of adhering to court-imposed deadlines and requirements.
Background
Background to the litigation
The central dispute in the case revolved around allegations of professional negligence and breach of contract against Townsley. The plaintiffs claimed that Townsley, who was a professional service provider, had failed to deliver the agreed services with the required standard of care, resulting in financial loss and other damages. Townsley, on the other hand, contested these claims, asserting that he had fulfilled his contractual obligations and that any issues arose from factors beyond his control. During the litigation process, the plaintiffs applied for leave to discontinue the proceedings. The court granted this application, allowing the plaintiffs to cease the legal action against Townsley.
However, despite the court granting leave to discontinue, the plaintiffs did not file the necessary notice of discontinuance with the court registry. This failure to file the notice of discontinuance led to the question of whether the court’s grant of leave effectively resulted in the discontinuance of the proceedings, or if the formal filing of the notice was an essential step that the plaintiffs had omitted. The case thus hinged on the interpretation of procedural requirements and the implications of not adhering to them, setting the stage for the court to address these procedural intricacies.
The matter of Allan and GDA Plumbing Pty Ltd v Townsley originated as a proceeding in the Supreme Court of Tasmania. Initially, the plaintiffs, Allan and GDA Plumbing Pty Ltd, sought relief against the defendant, Townsley, in relation to a contractual dispute arising from a plumbing services agreement. Following the filing of originating documents, the case was assigned to the Supreme Court list and scheduled for a case management conference. During the subsequent case management process, the plaintiffs applied for leave to discontinue the proceedings under the Supreme Court Rules, citing a resolution of their claims outside of court. The application for leave to discontinue was heard by Justice Smith, who granted the requested leave on certain conditions. Despite the court's order granting leave to discontinue, the plaintiffs did not subsequently file a notice of discontinuance. This omission led to the present procedural query, namely whether the granting of leave by the court itself effects the discontinuance of the proceedings or whether a formal notice of discontinuance is additionally required. The matter was subsequently brought before the court to resolve this procedural issue, which is distinct from the substantive merits of the original claim.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the granting of leave to discontinue a proceeding by the Supreme Court of Tasmania effectively result in the discontinuance of the proceeding, notwithstanding that the required notice of discontinuance has not been filed?
2. What are the implications of not filing the notice of discontinuance when the court has already granted leave to discontinue the proceeding?
3. Is there a requirement for the notice of discontinuance to be filed in addition to obtaining leave from the court, or is the grant of leave sufficient to effect a discontinuance?
Held
1. The court concluded that the granting of leave to discontinue a proceeding by the Supreme Court of Tasmania does not effectively result in the discontinuance of the proceeding if the required notice of discontinuance has not been filed. As such, the appeal was allowed on this issue.
2. The implications of not filing the notice of discontinuance, even after the court has granted leave to discontinue the proceeding, is that the proceeding remains active and is not legally discontinued. Consequently, the court ruled that the proceeding could still be pursued.
3. The court held that there is a requirement for the notice of discontinuance to be filed in addition to obtaining leave from the court. The grant of leave alone is not sufficient to effect a discontinuance; the notice of discontinuance must also be filed to legally discontinue the proceeding. Therefore, the application to discontinue was dismissed due to the failure to file the notice of discontinuance.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Allan and GDA Plumbing Pty Ltd v Townsley, the Supreme Court of Tasmania examined the procedural nuances of discontinuance in litigation under the Rules of Court. The central issue revolved around the efficacy of a court's grant of leave to discontinue a proceeding when the formal notice of discontinuance has not been filed. The court commenced its analysis by considering whether the granting of leave to discontinue a proceeding by the Supreme Court of Tasmania effectively results in the discontinuance of the proceeding, notwithstanding the absence of a filed notice of discontinuance. The court delved into the procedural framework established by the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (Tas), which stipulate that discontinuance must comply with certain formal requirements to be effective. These requirements include the filing of a notice of discontinuance, which serves as a formal notification to the court and the other party that the proceeding is being discontinued.
The court then addressed the implications of not filing the notice of discontinuance when the court has already granted leave to discontinue the proceeding. It was observed that the Rules explicitly require the filing of a notice of discontinuance to be effective, suggesting that the mere grant of leave by the court does not suffice. The court reasoned that the Rules' insistence on the filing of a notice of discontinuance underscores the importance of formal notification and the need for clear and unambiguous documentation of the discontinuance. This requirement ensures that both parties are aware of the status of the proceeding and can plan accordingly. The court further emphasized that the Rules' requirement for the filing of a notice of discontinuance is not merely procedural but serves a substantive purpose in maintaining the integrity of the judicial process.
In exploring whether there is a requirement for the notice of discontinuance to be filed in addition to obtaining leave from the court, or if the grant of leave is sufficient to effect a discontinuance, the court drew on relevant authorities and precedents. The court noted that the Rules of Court are clear in their stipulation that the grant of leave is not the sole mechanism for discontinuance; the formal notice of discontinuance must also be filed. The court distinguished between the procedural steps of obtaining leave and filing the notice, highlighting that the former is a preliminary step that allows the court to assess whether discontinuance is appropriate, while the latter is a substantive step that actualizes the discontinuance. This distinction was supported by the court's interpretation of previous decisions, which consistently held that the formal filing of the notice of discontinuance is essential for the discontinuance to be effective.
The ratio decidendi of Allan and GDA Plumbing Pty Ltd v Townsley is that the granting of leave to discontinue a proceeding by the Supreme Court of Tasmania does not, in itself, effect the discontinuance of the proceeding. Instead, the formal filing of a notice of discontinuance is a mandatory requirement under the Rules of Court. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to procedural requirements to ensure clarity and finality in litigation. This decision aligns with prior authority, which has consistently emphasized the necessity of the formal notice of discontinuance. The court's adherence to established legal principles and its clarification of the procedural steps involved in discontinuance provide valuable guidance for practitioners navigating similar issues in Tasmanian litigation.