Alistair v Brisbane City Council (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Alistair v Brisbane City Council (No 2) [2025] QIRC 139

PARTIES:

Alistair, Annabelle
(Applicant)

v

Brisbane City Council
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

TD/2024/73  

PROCEEDING:

Application for Reinstatement – application in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

30 May 2025

HEARING DATES: 

20 March 2025
19 May 2025

MEMBER:

Hartigan DP
HEARD AT:

Brisbane

ORDER:

1.     The application in existing proceedings filed 11 February 2025 by the Respondent is granted.

2.     The proceeding, being TD/2024/73, is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – QUEENSLAND – DISMISSALS – UNFAIR DISMISSAL – JURISDICTION – DISMISSAL – where the Applicant filed an application for reinstatement – where the Respondent raised a jurisdictional objection – where the Applicant's contract of employment was terminated before the nominal end date – whether the Applicant was engaged for a "specific period or task" – whether s 315 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) applies to the Applicant – whether the Applicant was participating in a "labour market program" – application in existing proceeding granted – the proceedings dismissed.

LEGISLATION:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 386

Further Education and Training Act 2014 (Qld), sch 1

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), s 315, s 316, s 317, sch 5

CASES:

Alouani-Roby v National Rugby League Ltd (2024) 307 FCR 65

Andersen v Umbakumba Community Council (1994) 56 IR 102

R v A2; R v Magennis; R v Vaziri (2019) 269 CLR 507

SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 262 CLR 362

APPEARANCES: 

Ms A. Alistair, appearing in person as the Applicant.

Mr A. Herbert of Counsel, instructed by Wotton Kearney Lawyers appearing for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. The Applicant, Ms Annabelle Alistair, has filed an application for reinstatement seeking, inter alia, reinstatement to her former position ('the proceeding').

  2. The Respondent, Brisbane City Council ('Council') raises a jurisdictional objection and applies for an order that the application for reinstatement be dismissed on the basis that Ms Alistair is not a person to whom the Commission may grant relief from unfair dismissal, by reason of the exclusion in s 315(1)(d) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ('IR Act').

  3. Ms Alistair objects to the granting of the application in existing proceedings filed               11 February 2025 by the Council and relies on the further exception contained in
    s 315(1)(d)(ii) of the IR Act in support of her position.

  4. Section 315(1)(d) of the IR Act operates to exclude an employee from relief for unfair dismissal if, inter alia, they were employed for a specific period or specific task. The issue to be determined is whether Ms Alistair is excluded from relief for unfair dismissal by operation of s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act.

    Relevant Background

  5. Ms Alistair commenced employment as a Bus Driver Trainee Level 1 with the Council on 23 June 2023. Ms Alistair was employed on a temporary contract of employment for the purpose of her undertaking a traineeship in driving operations. Ms Alistair's contract of employment had a nominal termination date of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alistair v Brisbane City Council (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QIRC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Alistair v Brisbane City Council (No 2), the applicant, Ms Alistair, filed an application for reinstatement against the Brisbane City Council, following her termination of employment. The central issue before the court was whether Ms Alistair's employment was for a specific period or specific task, thereby excluding her from the unfair dismissal protection under s 315(1)(d) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld). Ms Alistair was employed on a temporary contract for a traineeship as a Bus Driver Trainee Level 1 with a nominal termination date of 23 June 2025, though it could be terminated earlier if she completed her traineeship requirements. The Council argued that Ms Alistair's employment was for a specific period and/or specific task, which would exclude her from unfair dismissal relief.

The court considered the statutory interpretation of "specific period or task" and whether Ms Alistair's traineeship qualified as a "labour market program". The court found that Ms Alistair's contract, while nominally set to end on 23 June 2025, was effectively for a specific period because it was expected to terminate upon the expiry of the nominal term, regardless of other potential modes of earlier termination. Additionally, the court determined that Ms Alistair's employment was also for a specific task, as it was contingent on her completing the traineeship. Consequently, the court held that Ms Alistair fell under the exclusions provided in s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act, and thus, the application for reinstatement was dismissed.

The court made two primary orders: the application in existing proceedings filed by the Respondent on 11 February 2025 was granted, and the proceeding TD/2024/73 was dismissed. This decision highlights the importance of the terms and conditions of employment contracts in determining the applicability of specific exclusions under the Industrial Relations Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application in existing proceedings filed 11 February 2025 by the Respondent is granted.

2. The proceeding, being TD/2024/73, is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 315(1)(d) of the IR Act operates to exclude an employee from relief for unfair dismissal if, inter alia, they were employed for a specific period or specific task. The issue to be determined is whether Ms Alistair is excluded from relief for unfair dismissal by operation of s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act. Relevant Background Ms Alistair commenced employment as a Bus Driver Trainee Level 1 with the Council on 23 June 2023. Ms Alistair was employed on a temporary contract of employment for the purpose of her undertaking a traineeship in driving operations. Ms Alistair's contract of employment had a nominal termination date of 23 June 2025 with an option to terminate the contract earlier if she passed the requirements of her traineeship prior to that date. On 8 November 2023, Ms Alistair was suspended from her employment due to a number of allegations raised against her. The Council commenced an investigation and show cause process into the allegations against Ms Alistair and on 16 July 2024, Ms Alistair was terminated from her employment. On 16 July 2024, Ms Alistair filed an application for reinstatement. Ms Alistair contends that the dismissal was unfair on a number of grounds which are unnecessary to go into any further at this juncture. In response to Ms Alistair's application for reinstatement, the Council seeks that the application be dismissed for want of jurisdiction, on the basis that it contends that Ms Alistair was not protected from unfair dismissal on the basis of s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act because she was employed for a specific period and/or specific task.[1] [1] Brisbane City Council, 'Form 4 – Application in existing proceeding', Application in Alistair v Brisbane City Council, TD/2024/73, 11 February 2025, 4. The Commission issued directions on 21 January 2025 for the parties to file further submissions with respect to the Council's application and listed the application for hearing on 20 March 2025. At the hearing on 20 March 2025, the Council made submissions in respect to the statutory construction of "specific period or task" and referred to several recent authorities. These submissions will be discussed further below, however, it is suffice to say that the hearing was the first occasion in which the Council meaningfully developed its submissions with respect to the construction of s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act and the application of a recent relevant authority. Consequently, Ms Alistair was granted an adjournment of the hearing on 20 March 2025, in order for her to be able to properly consider her reply to the oral submissions made on behalf of the Council. Further directions were subsequently issued to permit the parties to file further written submissions in this regard. On 11 April 2025, Ms Alistair, through her support person, wrote to the Industrial Registry and sought a further oral hearing. That request was granted and a further oral hearing was listed on 19 May 2025. It is apparent from the contentions of the parties that regard must be had to the construction of s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act, including the term "specific period or task" and the term "labour market program" contained in s 315(1)(d)(ii) of the IR Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In this regard, Ms Alistair has failed to discharge the onus placed on her to establish that s 315(1)(d)(ii) of the IR Act applies. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, I consider, pursuant to s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act, that Ms Alistair was engaged for a specific period and/or specific task and consequently s 316 of the IR Act does not apply to her. Further, I do not consider that Ms Alistair's traineeship with the Council, without any further evidence, amounted to a "labour market program" pursuant to s 315(1)(d)(ii) of the IR Act. It is acknowledged that this decision will have the consequence of Ms Alistair not being given an opportunity to be heard with respect to why she contends she was unfairly dismissed. However, for the reasons outlined above, it is concluded that Ms Alistair falls into a class of employee referred to in s 315(1) of the IR Act who is excluded from the unfair dismissal regime. Order Accordingly, I make the following orders: 1.The application in existing proceedings filed 11 February 2025 by the Respondent is granted. 2.The proceeding, being TD/2024/73, is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The nature and scope of the training contract including the terms and conditions summarised above are relevant when considering whether s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act applies in these circumstances. Consideration The onus rests on the Council to establish that Ms Alistair is not entitled to the benefit of s 316 of the IR Act because she was an employee engaged for a specific period or task. The undisputed terms of the contract of employment have been referred to above. Those terms relevantly identify that the contract of employment is to operate for a period of time nominally expiring on 23 June 2025. The contract, however, does provide for other modes in which the contract of employment may be terminated earlier including, for instance, if the employee is deemed competent in their trade before the nominal expiry date. I consider the approach of the Full Bench of the Federal Court of Australia in Alouani-Roby is the correct approach to be applied in the circumstances of this matter. That is, it is considered that Ms Alistair's contract of employment, which is expected to terminate upon the expiry of a nominal term, is a contract for a specific period despite it referring to other modes of earlier termination of the contract by the parties. That is because the contract is expected to run for a nominal term, which is a specific period of time, regardless of whether the parties may utilise other modes to terminate the contract earlier.[25][25] Alouani-Roby (n 16) [52]. Accordingly, I consider that Ms Alistair was engaged for a specific period. Further, even if that conclusion is incorrect, I consider the contract of employment also amounts to an engagement for a specific task. The terms of the contract are such that the employment continues until the nominal date to permit Ms Alistair to complete the traineeship. Indeed, the operation of the contract of employment is contingent upon Ms Alistair executing the training contract and participating in and completing the traineeship. In this sense, Ms Alistair's employment was for the purpose of her completing the task of completing her traineeship. Indeed, the contract of employment could be terminated earlier if Ms Alistair was deemed competent in her trade prior to the nominal expiry date. Accordingly, once the task of the traineeship was completed so was the employment on those terms. On this basis, Ms Alistair was engaged for a specific task. Having established that s 315(1)(d) of the IR Act applies, consideration must be had as to whether the exception in s 315(1)(d)(ii) applies to the circumstances of this matter. It is uncontroversial that the employment ended before the end of the specific period and before the completion of the task. Consequently, the relevant consideration is whether Ms Alistair was participating in a "labour market program". Ms Alistair relied on an extract of an undated definition of "Labour Market Program" purportedly produced by the Australian Government in a publication titled "The Guides to Social Policy Law" as follows:[26] [26] Annabelle Alistair, 'Schedule A Response to Further Directions Order 5', Submission in Alistair v Brisbane City Council, TD/2024/73, 4 April 2025, [31] (emphasis in original).