ALEXANDRINA COUNCIL V STRATH HUB PTY LTD
[2003] SASC 382
Land and Valuation Division
BLEBY J:
Introduction
The town of Strathalbyn is within the area of the Alexandrina Council. The Council’s Development Plan provides for an area of approximately 160 hectares immediately to the north of the existing township area to be zoned as Residential (Golf Course) Zone (“the Zone”). It is an unusual zone, not merely providing for a limited range of possible development for which consent is likely to be given, but requiring a substantial degree of co-ordination and integration of various developments throughout the Zone.
The only objective provided in the Development Plan for the Zone is:
“Objective 1: Housing and tourist accommodation development in association with a golf course, conservation area and public linear parks along the Angas River and Middle Creek, ……….”
The objective goes on to provide for compliance with certain standards not presently relevant.
Principles 1 – 4 of the Principles of Development Control for the Zone provide:
“1 Development should be consistent with Concept Plan Fig R(GC)/1.
2Development of residential allotments should not occur unless integrated with the provision of an eighteen hole golf course.
3Residential development should not be commenced north of the Stage 1 Development Line shown on Concept Plan Fig R(GC)/1 until all eighteen holes of the golf course have been developed and are in use.
4A maximum of 70 hectares within the zone should be developed for residential purposes.”
For present purposes “development” includes the division of an allotment: s 4(1) and s 5(1), Development Act 1993.
Concept Plan Fig R(GC)/1 appears below:
The land comprising the Zone is presently undeveloped apart from a heritage listed dwelling and associated garden area and outbuildings. Otherwise it is undulating grazing land containing a number of remnant indigenous trees, mainly along the drainage lines. The existing dwelling is located within Policy Area B.
Other relevant Principles of Development Control for the Zone are as follows:
“8Where residential allotments directly adjoin the golf course, dwellings should be designed to address both the golf course and the access street.
9Public open space should be provided within the residential areas on each side of the Angas River which is of a size, shape and gradient to meet community needs.
10Where land which has a frontage to the Angas River and Middle Creek is to be divided, public open space should be provided in the form of a reserve having a width of at least 25 metres from each river bank.
11An area of public open space should be provided within Policy Area C in accordance with Concept Plan Fig R(GC)/1.
……………….
Policy Area A
19Development in Policy Area A on Concept Plan Fig R(GC)/1 should be for the purpose of a linear park, revegetation, water management, a golf course and associated facilities.
20Residential or commercial development should not occur within Policy Area A shown on Concept Plan Fig R(GC)/1.
Policy Area B
21A golf clubhouse, tourist accommodation, restaurants, conference…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alexandrina Council v Strath Hub Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] SASC 382
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the Commissioner had made a demonstrable error of principle in his application of the Development Plan's essential features to Strath Hub's proposal. It was noted that a Development Plan is not merely a document of legal obligations but rather a guide containing planning objectives and principles that must be applied sensibly and flexibly. The court acknowledged that while the Development Plan is not rigid, its objectives and principles must not be ignored unless there are exceptional circumstances. The court emphasized the central role of the Development Plan in the planning regime and highlighted that under the Development Act, a development can only be approved if it aligns with the Development Plan.
After careful consideration, the court found that the Commissioner had indeed erred in his application of the Development Plan's principles. The Commissioner had not adequately considered the essential features of the Development Plan, leading to a decision that did not align with the planning objectives and principles. Consequently, the court ruled that the Commissioner's decision was flawed and required correction. The court clarified that while it was reluctant to interfere with planning decisions, it would intervene where there was a fundamental departure from proper planning principles.
The court allowed the appeal and set aside the Commissioner's decision, directing the council to reassess the proposal in accordance with the Development Plan's principles. The council was instructed to provide detailed reasons for its decision, ensuring that it properly considered the Development Plan's objectives and principles in its reassessment.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Nevertheless, on an appeal, as this is, under s 30 of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993, on what is essentially a matter of planning judgment, the grounds on which this Court can interfere are limited. In City of Mitcham v Freckmann (No 2) (2000) 76 SASR 145 Debelle J, with whom Doyle CJ and Nyland J agreed, said, at 148 [15]:“This Court is reluctant to interfere with the Environment Court’s conclusions upon essentially planning issues. It will interfere only where the court has made an identifiable and egregious blunder, has made a demonstrable error of fact or principle, or the circumstances are in some other respect quite exceptional. ….. This Court is reluctant to substitute its planning opinion for that of the Environment Court and will be minded to do so only where the appellant is able to demonstrate some fundamental departure from proper planning principles: Ampol Road Pantry Pty Ltd v Brighton City Corporation (1993) 62 SASR 165 at 173.”Consideration of the appeal In my opinion there was, on the part of the Commissioner, a demonstrable error of principle in his application of the essential features of the Development Plan to this proposal. True it is that a Development Plan is not a document setting out legal obligations: Hassen v District Council of Murray Bridge (1984) 35 SASR 448. It contains statements of planning objectives and principles to be applied sensibly and flexibly to particular circumstances. However, that does not mean that its objectives and principles may be ignored because it may seem convenient to do so in a particular case. In Corporation of the Town of Walkerville v Adelaide Clinic Holdings Pty Ltd (1985) 38 SASR 161 King CJ said, at 187:“The Development Plan is the focal point of the planning regime instituted by the 1982 Act. Its central importance is emphasized by the disappearance of regulations from the scheme. The Plan provides the objectives and principles upon which development planning is to be based. It is the charter by whose guiding principles future development is to be planned.”The Chief Justice was then speaking of a Development Plan under the Planning Act 1982. What he said then has even greater force under the Development Act 1993. It must be remembered that when King CJ wrote those words the only obligation of a planning authority under s 47(9) of the Planning Act was to “have regard to” the provisions of the Development Plan so far as they were relevant to the decision. That meant that a planning authority, having had regard to the Development Plan, could nevertheless depart from it: South Australian Planning Commission v Dorrestijn (1984) 36 SASR 355 at 370 – 371: Corporation of the Town of Walkerville v Adelaide Clinic Holdings Pty Ltd (supra) at 187. Under the Development Act a development can only become an approved development if “a relevant authority has assessed the development against” the provisions of the Development Plan and has granted consent: s 33(1)(a). That requirement means that the planning authority must form a judgment as to whether and the extent to which the development conforms to the Plan. If the assessment is that the development is seriously at variance with the plan, consent must be withheld: Ibid s 35(2). Between being seriously at variance with and complying in all respects with a Development Plan there will be a range of possibilities. In some cases the exercise of planning judgment will result in consent. In other cases it will not.