Alexander Warr v Paull & Warner Body Builders

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
[2025] FWC 248

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Alexander Warr
v

Paull & Warner Body Builders

(U2024/14950)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT O’KEEFFE

PERTH, 28 JANUARY 2025

Applicant not an employee of the Respondent – application has no reasonable prospects of success - application dismissed pursuant to s.587 of the Act.

  1. On 9 December 2024 Mr Alexander Warr (the Applicant) applied under s.394 of the Fair Work Act (the Act) for a remedy for alleged unfair dismissal. On 24 December 2024 Paull and Warner Body Builders Pty Ltd (the Respondent) lodged a response to the application, indicating a jurisdictional objection that the Applicant was not an employee. The matter was allocated to my Chambers on 9 January 2025.

  2. Having examined the application and the response, it seemed clear to me that in fact the Applicant had been employed by a labour hire firm and that the Respondent was not the employer but rather the host firm.  Given this, on 10 January 2025 I caused my Chambers to write to the Applicant as follows:

    “Dear Mr Warr,

    Your application numbered U2024/14950 has been allocated to Deputy President O'Keeffe. The Deputy President has examined the application and the reply paperwork filed by Warner Body Builders. It appears that you were not an employee of Warner Body Builders but rather employed by a labour hire agency and allocated to work at Warner Body Builders.

    You should be aware that the case law on such labour hire arrangements is settled. In circumstances where an employee is employed (and paid) by a labour hire firm to perform work for a host / client firm no employment relationship is created between the employee and the host / client firm. The employment relationship is instead between the employee and the labour hire firm. For more information, please see the overview provided here: Labour hire workers ' Fair Work Commission

    If it is the case that you were an employee of the labour hire firm, there is a serious jurisdictional issue with your current application in that it is not made against your actual employer. Given this, can you please advise - by 4.00pm (AWST) Tuesday 14th

    January 2025 - as to whether you intend to:

    1. Continue with your current application; or
    2. Make a new application against the labour hire firm; or
    3. Undertake some other course of action.”

  3. On 14 January 2025 the Applicant responded as follows:

“Dear Mr Chambers/Ms Kerr

My sincere apologies I did realise this might be the case after submitting the application.

I believe that it is a loophole of sorts where client employers can dictate to the host employer as they see fit, whether unfair or not.

I am unsure if making a new application against the labour hire firm will have any effect whatsoever on the unfair decision made by Paull & Warner Body Builders.”

  1. Given the uncertainty created by this response, I caused my Chambers to write to the Applicant on 14 January 2025 as follows:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alexander Warr v Paull & Warner Body Builders and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FWC 248
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Fair Work Commission, Alexander Warr lodged an application for unfair dismissal against Paull & Warner Body Builders. The dispute arose from Mr Warr's employment, which he believed to be directly with Paull & Warner Body Builders, but in reality was with a labour hire firm. The Respondent contested the application on jurisdictional grounds, asserting that Mr Warr was not their employee. The Commission was required to determine whether the application could proceed against the Respondent or if it should be dismissed due to lack of jurisdiction. The central issue was whether Mr Warr had a valid employment relationship with the Respondent, which would confer jurisdiction on the Commission, or if the relationship was with the labour hire firm, thereby making the application against the Respondent invalid.

The Deputy President examined the application and correspondence between the parties, noting that Mr Warr was employed by a labour hire firm, not directly by Paull & Warner Body Builders. This established that the employment relationship was with the labour hire firm, not the Respondent. The Deputy President engaged with Mr Warr to clarify his intentions, seeking a response by specified deadlines. When Mr Warr failed to respond, the Deputy President concluded that the application had no reasonable prospects of success and was without jurisdiction. The Deputy President cited previous decisions that confirmed the Commission's power to dismiss applications that lack reasonable prospects of success or where the applicant fails to prosecute their claim.

Based on the jurisdictional objections and the failure of Mr Warr to respond to multiple requests for clarification, the Deputy President exercised the powers under section 587 of the Fair Work Act to dismiss the application. The dismissal was made without further correspondence as Mr Warr did not respond to the final notice. The Deputy President issued an order dismissing the application, emphasizing the importance of jurisdiction and the need for applicants to clarify their intentions and provide responses to the Commission's inquiries.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established