|
BRISBANE
20 February 2001
Re: Determination of Compensation -
Resumption for road purposes -
Acquisition of Land Act 1967.
(A99-44).
Alex Gow Pty Limited
v.
Brisbane City Council
APPLICATION FOR COSTS
Consequent upon the judgment of the decision on 5 October 2000 on compensation due in the above matter, the respondent Brisbane City Council submitted on 27 October 2000, an application for partial costs to be awarded in its favour to the extent of three-quarters of the respondent's costs of and incidental to the hearing and determination of the amended claim for compensation.
The claimant, Alex Gow Pty Limited, responded on 15 November 2000, submitting that there should be no order as to costs in favour of the respondent, and seeking costs to the claimant. At the handing down of the decision on 5 October 2000, both parties agreed that the matter of costs would be determined on the written submissions provided to the Court. The claimant has subsequently appealed the decision on the merits of the case.
The initial claim for compensation submitted by the claimant was $307,207 plus interest at $257,698, or a total of $564,905. That claim was amended during the hearing to $574,970.70 plus interest of $557,494.72 or a total of $1,132,465.40. The final submission by the respondent was for $51,207 plus disturbance items and interest. The disturbance items, excluding those in the $51,207, amounted to $39,401, giving a total amount by the respondent of $90,608.
The Court awarded compensation at $133,137, plus interest determined at $70,317.82, or a total amount of $203,454.82, plus interest at 6.75% per annum from the date of hearing on 2 May 2000 up to and including the date of final payment.
The Respondent's Claim -
The respondent argues that s.27(2) of the Acquisition of Land Act 1967 (the Act) provides guidance for the awarding of costs in such matters. In accordance with that guidance the respondent argues that the final amount determined by the Court is much nearer to the amount contended by the respondent, than that contended by the claimant. The half-way point between the amount contended was $332,789.35.
The respondent seeks support in guidance provided in Yalgan Investments Pty Ltd v. Albert Shire Council (1998) 17 QLCR 401, where the Land Appeal Court summarised relevant precedents, and said at p.408:
"(j)Section 27(2) of the Acquisition of Land Act 1967 should not be regarded as a legislative suggestion that, where the claim is substantially more than the amount awarded, and the amount put in evidence by the construction authority is not substantially less than the amount awarded, the Court should not merely refrain from awarding any costs to the claimant but should award costs to the authority. (Moyses and Others v. Townsville City Council (1979) 6 QLCR 271 at p.274).
(k)Where the Land Court is considering whether it should award costs to a constructing authority, it could be wrong to have regard merely to the amounts of the claim and of the award…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alex Gow Pty Limited v Brisbane City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] QLC 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the quantum of the claims, noting that the final compensation awarded was significantly lower than the initial claim by Alex Gow Pty Limited. The court also examined the conduct of the parties during negotiations and the reasonableness of the claims. The court highlighted the importance of not only the final positions taken by the parties but also the conduct leading up to the final claim. It found that while the claimant's initial claim was excessive, it had amended the claim during the hearing, and both parties had contributed to the delay in resolving the matter.
In conclusion, the court decided that the respondent was entitled to some costs but not to the full extent requested. The court ordered that Alex Gow Pty Limited pay 50% of the respondent's costs of and incidental to the hearing and determination of the claim for compensation. This decision was based on the court's discretion, considering the conduct of both parties and the eventual outcome of the compensation award.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi