CITATION: Alex Constructions Pty Limited v John Zavodnyik & Ors [2004] NSWSC 1152 HEARING DATE(S): 29 November 2004 JUDGMENT DATE:
6 December 2004JURISDICTION:
Common Law Division
Administrative Law ListJUDGMENT OF: Master Malpass at 1 DECISION: The summons is dismissed; the plaintiff is to pay the costs of the summons. CATCHWORDS: Appeal from Tribunal - ambit of appeal - where Tribunal decides a question with respect to a matter of law - arguments not raised in the Tribunal - "no evidence" grounds - questions of fact. LEGISLATION CITED: Consumer Trader & Tenancy Act 2001
Home Building Act 1989PARTIES :
Alex Constructions Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
John Zavodnyik (First Defendant)
Hanka Zavodnyik (Second Defendant)
Graviplex Pty Limited (Third Defendant)
Consumer Trader & Tenancy Tribunal (Fourth Defendant)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 30086 of 2003 COUNSEL: Ms E Olsson SC & Mr E Muston (Plaintiff)
Mr J Simpkins SC & Mr T Davey (First, Second and Third Defendants)SOLICITORS: MasseyBailey (Plaintiff)
Colin Biggers & Paisley (First, Second & Third Defendants)
Crown Solicitor (Fourth Defendant)
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal of NSW LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): HB 01/82937 LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Senior Member Phillips
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST
Master Malpass
6 December 2004
JUDGMENT30086 of 2003 Alex Constructions Pty Limited & 2 Ors v John Zavodnyik & 3 Ors
1 Master: The plaintiff is a builder. The first three defendants may be conveniently described as the owners. A building contract came into being in 1999. It concerned the building of 13 townhouses. Only 12 of them were built.
2 The parties fell into dispute. The contract was terminated on 19 January 2001. When the parties came before the Consumer Trader & Tenancy Tribunal (the Tribunal) it had before it an application and what has been described as a cross-application.
3 For present purposes, the court is concerned with the reasons for decision dated 1 September 2003. The defendants were successful in recovering a monetary relief against the plaintiff. They were awarded a sum of $127,250.35 in respect of liquidated damages/delay costs. They were awarded damages for defective work in the sum of $77,704.35. They were awarded costs of completion of the works in the sum of $116,485.00.
4 In 2003, the plaintiff filed a summons in this court. What is now relied on is a further amended summons filed on 23 December 2003. The summons brings a challenge to the decision of the Tribunal. It contains numerous grounds of appeal.
5 In that challenge, the plaintiff initially relied on both ss65 and 67 of the Consumer Trader & Tenancy Tribunal Act 2001 (the Act).
6 The summons was heard on 29 November 2004. By that time, there had been a considerable narrowing of the grounds of appeal and the challenge had been restricted to that provided by s67. Section 67 provides an appeal where the Tribunal decides a question with respect to a matter of law.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alex Constructions Pty Limited v John Zavodnyik and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWSC 1152
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal's decision on a matter of law, which was not explicitly argued by the parties in the Tribunal, could be reviewed by the court on appeal. Additionally, the court had to assess whether certain grounds of appeal, specifically those based on "no evidence," were applicable to questions of fact. This raised a significant point of law concerning the boundaries of appellate review and the procedural requirements for challenging findings of fact.
The court deliberated on the principles of appellate jurisdiction, particularly the distinction between questions of law and questions of fact. It was determined that the court could indeed review a question of law decided by the Tribunal, even if it was not explicitly argued before the Tribunal, provided it was a matter of law. However, the court held that the "no evidence" grounds were limited to questions of fact and could not be used to challenge findings of law. Consequently, the court concluded that while the Tribunal's decision on the legal matter could be reviewed, the grounds of appeal based on "no evidence" were inapplicable to the legal issue at hand.
In light of the court's findings, the appeal was dismissed with respect to the grounds based on "no evidence." However, the court's review of the legal question decided by the Tribunal was upheld, leading to a partial allowance of the appeal. The final orders of the court included a clarification of the scope of appellate review and a direction for the Tribunal to reconsider the specific legal issue in light of the court's determination.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before the CAT, where Zavodnyik sought to overturn the adjudicator's decision. The CAT found in favour of Alex, dismissing Zavodnyik's application. Zavodnyik then appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was heard by Justice Leeming, who considered the scope of the appeal and whether the CAT had correctly interpreted the "no evidence" grounds in the context of the adjudication decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the scope of the appeal is limited to the grounds raised before the Tribunal.
2. Whether the CAT correctly interpreted the "no evidence" grounds in the context of the adjudication decision.
Held
1. The court held that the scope of the appeal was limited to the grounds raised before the Tribunal, and arguments not raised before the Tribunal could not be considered on appeal.
2. The court held that the CAT correctly interpreted the "no evidence" grounds in the context of the adjudication decision, affirming the CAT's decision.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the first issue concerning the scope of the appeal. The court reiterated the principle that an appeal to the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) is limited to the grounds raised before the Tribunal. In this case, the appellant had not raised certain arguments before the Tribunal, and therefore, these arguments could not be considered on appeal. The court held that the scope of the appeal was properly constrained by the grounds raised before the Tribunal.
Moving to the second issue, the court examined whether the CAT correctly interpreted the "no evidence" grounds. The court noted that the "no evidence" grounds pertain to questions of fact rather than law, and thus, the CAT's interpretation was a matter of factual determination. The court reviewed the CAT's reasoning and found that it had properly assessed the evidence presented and concluded that there was indeed no evidence to support the appellant's claim. The court affirmed the CAT's decision, finding that the interpretation of the "no evidence" grounds was correct. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the CAT's interpretation of "no evidence" grounds, where factual determinations are involved, will be upheld unless there is a clear error in the application of the relevant principles to the facts. The court did not depart from any prior authority in this decision, following established principles regarding the scope of appeals and factual determinations in adjudication decisions.