ALDI Foods Pty Ltd v Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application numbers 1879153 and 1879154 (both class 32) – ALBY (Logos) - in the name of Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd

Delegate:

Jock McDonagh

Representation:

Opponent: Spruson & Ferguson, Attorneys

Applicant: O’Sullivans Attorneys

Decision:

2019 ATMO 118

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - Section 52 opposition: ss 42(b), 44 and 60 considered – no grounds established – trade marks may proceed to registration

Background

  1. This matter relates to oppositions under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to the registration of trade marks filed by Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd (‘the Applicant’). Relevant details of the opposed application are set out below.

Application No

       1879153  1879154

Trade Marks

(‘the Trade Marks’)

Filing Date:        

11.10.2017 (‘the Priority Date’)

Goods:

Class 32: Alcohol-free beer; Alcoholic beers; Beer; Beer-based cocktails; Bitter beer; Black beer; Dark Beer; De-alcoholised beer; Fruit beers; Ginger beer; Ginger beer (alcoholic); Ginger beer (non-alcoholic); Low alcohol beer; Malt beer; Malt-containing beverages (beers); Malt-containing beverages (non-alcoholic, except beers); Non-alcoholic beers; Non-alcoholic beverages (except non-alcoholic beer); Pilsner beer; Root beer

  1. The Trade Marks were examined in compliance with section 31 of the Act and were advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 8 March 2018. ALDI Foods Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) filed Notices of Intention to Oppose the registration of the Trade Mark on 8 May 2018 and Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘the Statement’) on 10 May 2018.  Thereafter the Applicant filed Notices of Intention to Defend on 22 May 2018.

  2. The parties then filed evidence as provided by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’). This evidence was the same as that filed in the matter of trade mark application 1836102, for the word mark ALBY.

  3. The parties were advised of their right to be heard or to make written submissions.  The parties elected to defer hearing the matter until such time as the opposition to application 1836102 had been decided. The parties agreed that the decision made for application 1836102 would be applicable to these oppositions and the submissions made for that hearing would be applicable to deciding these oppositions.

  4. I am a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks and I am to decide the oppositions as required by s 55 of the Act which provides that, unless the proceedings are discontinued, dismissed, or have lapsed under s 54A the Registrar must, at the end, decide:

    (a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or

    (b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;

    having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the   application was opposed has been established. 

    In doing so I take account of       the written record comprised of the materials mentioned in the preceding paragraphs including my decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ALDI Foods Pty Ltd v Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ALDI Foods Pty Ltd opposed the registration of the trade mark "ALBY" by Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd in Class 32 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The opposition was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the grounds of opposition, as pleaded by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, had been established. Specifically, the delegate considered whether the trade mark "ALBY" was identical or deceptively similar to any earlier registered trade marks owned by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, and whether these earlier marks were used in relation to the same or similar goods or closely related services. The delegate also had to determine the relevant date for establishing the grounds of opposition, which is the date of filing of the application for registration.

The delegate's reasoning, detailed in Annexure 1, concluded that ALDI Foods Pty Ltd had not established any of the grounds of opposition. The delegate applied the principle that the grounds of opposition must be established as at the date of filing of the application for registration. Evidence presented by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd regarding its use of the "ALDI" trade mark in relation to private label beer, and the Applicant's evidence concerning the development and marketing of the "ALBY" trade mark, were considered.

As no grounds of opposition were established, the delegate decided to register the trade mark "ALBY" in the name of Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd, subject to the usual one-month period for appeal. Costs were awarded against the Opponent, ALDI Foods Pty Ltd.

Background

Background to the litigation

ALDI Foods Pty Ltd opposed the registration of the trade mark "ALBY" by Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd, established in 2002, filed an application to register the trade mark "ALBY" on 24 August 2017, which was subsequently advertised for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks. The Opponent, ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose on 26 September 2017 and a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 6 October 2017. Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd then filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 27 November 2017.

The Opponent's opposition was based on section 44 of the Act, asserting that the trade mark "ALBY" was substantially identical or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark owned by the Opponent. The Opponent claimed that it and ALDI Pty Ltd were partners in ALDI Stores, a limited partnership, and that the ALDI trade mark had been used in relation to retail services in Australia since 2001. The majority of products retailed under the ALDI trade mark were sold under exclusive 'private label' brands. Since 2003, the retail services provided under the ALDI trade mark had included the retail of packaged beer under various private labels, none of which included the ALDI trade mark. The word ALDI appeared on these beers by way of a statement on the label indicating that the private label brand was the property of ALDI Stores and ALDI Foods Pty Ltd.

Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd, through its marketing team, developed the trade mark "ALBY" as a distinctive and new brand that would resonate with consumers. The trade mark was chosen because it was a person’s name and could be linked to The Albion Brewery, WA's first brewery. Market testing performed prior to the launch in 2017 showed strong performance for the trade mark "ALBY". The trade mark was considered a diminutive or abbreviated form of the suburb name ALBION, or the name ALBERT, and was not substantially identical or deceptively similar to the ALDI trade mark. The Applicant argued that the trade marks were distinct and that the use of "ALBY" would not cause confusion among consumers.

This case concerns an opposition to the registration of a trade mark filed by Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd. ALDI Foods Pty Ltd opposed the registration of the trade mark "ALBY" on the grounds that it was deceptively similar to their own registered trade mark "ALDI." The Trade Mark was examined and advertised as accepted for possible registration on 24 August 2017. ALDI Foods Pty Ltd filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose on 26 September 2017, and subsequently filed a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 6 October 2017. Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd then filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 27 November 2017. Both parties filed evidence and written submissions in accordance with the Trade Mark Regulations 1995. The matter was heard in Canberra on 18 March 2019 by Jock McDonagh as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. ALDI Foods Pty Ltd did not appear at the hearing but provided written submissions, while Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd was represented by Martin O’Sullivan of O’Sullivans Attorneys.

The procedural steps in this case involved the initial examination and advertisement of the trade mark, followed by the filing of opposition and defence notices by the respective parties. The opposition was based on the argument that the trade mark "ALBY" was deceptively similar to ALDI Foods Pty Ltd’s registered trade mark "ALDI." The hearing officer considered the evidence and submissions from both parties before reaching a decision. The decision noted that the grounds of opposition must be established at the time of the application for registration, and that ALDI Foods Pty Ltd had not successfully demonstrated any grounds for opposition. Consequently, the trade mark applications were to proceed to registration, subject to any potential appeal by the Opponent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The time at which the grounds of opposition must be established is the date of filing of the application for registration.[4][4] See Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595Evidence The evidence consists of the following declarations: The Lentini declaration indicates:· the Opponent, ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, and ALDI Pty Ltd are partners in ALDI Stores - a limited partnership;· trade marks registered in the name of the Opponent are used by ALDI Stores under licence;· the ALDI trade mark has been used in relation to retail services in Australia since 2001;· the majority of products retailed under the ALDI trade mark are sold under exclusive 'private label' brands;· since 2003, the retail services provided under the ALDI trade mark have included the retail of packaged beer under a range of private labels (“the Private Labelled Beer”) that do not include the ALDI trade mark;· the word ALDI appears on the Private Labelled Beer by way of a statement on the label stating the private label brand is the property of ALDI i.e. ALDI Stores and ALDI Foods Pty Ltd; and· since 2003 the Private Labelled Beer has been promoted and retailed by ALDI Stores and certain of those beers have received awards. The Collison declaration states:· The Applicant was established in Western Australia in 2002 and is one of Australia’s largest brewers producing a substantial amount of award-winning beer and cider each year under a range of brands.· The Applicant’s marketing team developed the Trade Mark following a creative process and in accordance with an objective to develop a brand that was distinctive and new but also had a “personality” that would resonate with consumers. ALBY was chosen by the Applicant mainly because it was a person’s name and could also be linked to The Albion Brewery - WA’s first brewery. These characteristics made ALBY attractive from a marketing perspective because it humanized the brand. ALBY also performed strongly in market testing undertaken by Applicant prior to its market launch in 2017.· The Trade Mark is a diminutive or abbreviated form of the suburb name ALBION, or the name ALBERT. In regard to the latter, reference was made to the film maker Alby Mangels, and Cyclone Alby The Knowles declaration relies on the declarant’s long experience as an occasional purchaser of alcoholic beverages, attendance at professional events at licensed premises, and extensive experience as a former trade mark examiner of applications for relevant goods. The Knowles declaration details the methods of selling the goods the subject of the application and how they are typically ordered by consumers. It highlights the predominance of verbally ordering the goods. I now turn to the grounds of opposition.Section 44 – Identical etc. trade marks Section 44 of the Act relevantly states: Therefore, to found its ground of opposition under s 44(1) the Opponent has to establish to my satisfaction the existence of at least one trade mark registration or application for registration of a trade mark that is owned by a person other than the Applicant and which:· has a priority date earlier than that of the opposed trade mark; and·is registered or made in respect of the same or similar goods or closely related services; and·is substantially identical or deceptively similar to the opposed trade mark.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The time at which the grounds of opposition must be established is the date of filing of the application for registration.[2][2] See Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595Decision Section 55(1) of the Act provides:Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrarmust, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services thenspecified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which theapplication was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. Subsection (3) does not apply to these proceedings. For the reasons provided in Annexure 1, the opponent has not established any grounds of opposition. The Trade Mark applications may accordingly proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration of the Trade Mark shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued.Costs It is usual for costs to follow the event, and I see no reason to depart from that principle here. I award costs against the Opponent under section 221 of the Act in the terms of Schedule 8 of the Regulations. Costs for application 1879154 do not include Items 7 to 16 inclusive.Jock McDonaghHearing OfficerOppositions and HearingsTrade Marks and Designs2 August 2019ANNEXURE A TODECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS DATED 2 AUGUST 2019TRADE MARKS ACT 1995DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONSRe:Opposition by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application number 1836102 (class 32) - ALBY - in the name of Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd This matter relates to an opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to the registration of a trade mark filed by Gage Roads Brewing Co Ltd (‘the Applicant’). Relevant details of the opposed application are set out below. The Trade Mark was examined in compliance with section 31 of the Act and was advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 24 August 2017. ALDI Foods Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the registration of the Trade Mark on 26 September 2017 and a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘the Statement’) on 6 October 2017. Thereafter the Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 27 November 2017. The parties then filed evidence as provided by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’). The parties were advised of their right to be heard or to make written submissions. The parties elected to be heard, and also filed outline written submissions prior to the hearing. I heard the matter by in Canberra on 18 March 2019 as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The Opponent did not appear but provided written submissions for the hearing prepared by Spruson & Ferguson, Attorneys. The Applicant was represented by Martin O’Sullivan of O’Sullivans Attorneys who also provided written submissions in support of his submissions made at the hearing. Grounds of Opposition

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began its analysis by considering whether the trade mark "ALBY" was substantially identical or deceptively similar to any existing trade mark owned by the Opponent. Section 44(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 states that for a trade mark to be opposed, it must be substantially identical or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark. The court examined the evidence and found that the trade marks in question were not substantially identical or deceptively similar. The Opponent's trade marks were primarily associated with retail services, while the Applicant's trade mark was associated with packaged beer. Furthermore, the court noted that the Applicant's trade mark had a distinct personality and was linked to The Albion Brewery, making it less likely to be confused with the Opponent's trade marks.

The court also considered whether the trade mark "ALBY" had a priority date earlier than that of the Opponent's existing trade marks. The Applicant's trade mark had a priority date of 2017, while the Opponent's trade marks had been in use since 2001. The court found that the Applicant's trade mark did not have an earlier priority date, but this did not necessarily mean that the grounds for opposition were established. The court then proceeded to examine the other factors relevant to determining whether the Applicant's trade mark was substantially identical or deceptively similar to the Opponent's trade marks.

In considering whether the goods or services associated with the trade mark "ALBY" were the same or similar to those covered by the Opponent's existing trade marks, the court noted that the Applicant's trade mark was associated with packaged beer, while the Opponent's trade marks were associated with retail services. The court found that the goods and services were not the same or similar, which was a factor that weighed against the establishment of the grounds for opposition. The court also considered the evidence provided by the Knowles declaration, which highlighted the methods of selling the goods and how they were typically ordered by consumers. The court found that the evidence supported the conclusion that the goods and services were not the same or similar.

The court then examined whether the use of the word "ALBY" in the trade mark created a likelihood of confusion among consumers with the Opponent's existing trade marks. The court noted that the Applicant's trade mark was associated with packaged beer and had a distinct personality, which made it less likely to be confused with the Opponent's trade marks. The court also considered the evidence provided by the Collison declaration, which stated that the trade mark was chosen because it was a person's name and could be linked to The Albion Brewery. The court found that the evidence supported the conclusion that there was no likelihood of confusion among consumers.

The court also considered whether the trade mark "ALBY" was developed in bad faith with the intention to take unfair advantage of the distinctive character or reputation of the Opponent's existing trade marks. The court found that there was no evidence of bad faith on the part of the Applicant. The Applicant had developed the trade mark in accordance with an objective to develop a brand that was distinctive and new but also had a "personality" that would resonate with consumers. The court found that the evidence supported the conclusion that the trade mark was not developed in bad faith.

Finally, the court considered whether the trade mark "ALBY" contravened any other provisions of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court found that the trade mark did not contravene any other provisions of the Act. The court noted that the Applicant had complied with all relevant requirements for the registration of the trade mark, and there were no other grounds for opposing the registration.

In conclusion, the court found that the Opponent had not established any grounds for opposing the registration of the trade mark "ALBY." The court found that the trade marks were not substantially identical or deceptively similar, the goods and services were not the same or similar, there was no likelihood of confusion among consumers, and the trade mark was not developed in bad faith. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a trade mark will not be opposed if it is not substantially identical or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark, the goods and services are not the same or similar, there is no likelihood of confusion among consumers, and the trade mark was not developed in bad faith. The court followed prior authority in reaching its decision, and there was no departure from prior authority.