Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd v The Australian Kidney Foundation

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

ALAN HICKINBOTHAM PTY LTD v THE AUSTRALIAN KIDNEY FOUNDATION

[2017] SASC 4

Judgment of Judge Roder a Master of the Supreme Court

3 February 2017

EVIDENCE - FACTS EXCLUDED FROM PROOF - ON GROUNDS OF PRIVILEGE - PROFESSIONAL CONFIDENCE - LEGAL PROFESSION - DOCUMENTS

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS - GENERALLY

The plaintiff seeks inspection of documents in respect of which legal professional privilege has been claimed - the defendant seeks orders that the plaintiff provide further and better particulars, that the defendant have permission to amend its defence, that the plaintiff make further and better disclosure and that the plaintiff file and serve a supplementary list of documents.

Held:

1.       Uphold the claims to privilege in respect of documents AKF.0144 and AKF.0147.

2.       Reject the claims to privilege in respect of documents AKF.0145, AKF.0149 and AKF.0150.

3.       Dismiss paragraphs 2 and 3 of FDN 19.

4.       Within 28 days the plaintiff file and serve a further list of documents in respect of which privilege is claimed and describing those documents without disclosing their contents in sufficient particularity as to enable the Court to decide if the privilege claimed is maintainable.

5.       The documents produced for inspection by the defendant be returned to the defendant’s solicitors.

6.       Permission to the parties to apply for further directions and orders – including as to costs, if necessary – as they may be advised. 

Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA); Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 98(2), r 102(3), referred to.
AWB Ltd v Cole (No 5) (2006) 155 FCR 30; Kadlunga Proprietors & Ors v Electricity Trust of South Australia & Ors (1985) 39 SASR 410; Spotless Group Ltd v Premier Building & Consulting P/L [2006] VSCA 201; Daniels Corporation International Pty Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) (2002) 213 CLR 543; X & Y v Z (2015) 123 SASR 298, considered.

ALAN HICKINBOTHAM PTY LTD v THE AUSTRALIAN KIDNEY FOUNDATION
[2017] SASC 4

  1. JUDGE RODER.  This is a lease dispute.  The defendant leased premises at North Terrace, Hackney, from the plaintiff.  The lease was for five years.  The lease expired on 30 November 2013.  Thereafter, the plaintiff continued in possession, but vacated on 2 November 2015. 

  2. In the action, the plaintiff claims that:

    1.A new lease (“the new lease”) was entered into after the expiry of the lease;

    2.In the alternative, there is an enforceable agreement to enter into a new lease (“agreement to lease”);

    3.In the further alternative, there is an estoppel by convention (“the lease estoppel”); and

    4.In the further alternative the defendant has contravened section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (“misleading and deceptive conduct”).

  3. The plaintiff seeks damages for breach of the new lease, breach of the agreement to lease, breach of the lease by estoppel or under the Australian Consumer Law.

  4. Two applications were argued before me on 13…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd v The Australian Kidney Foundation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd, a law firm, sought to prevent The Australian Kidney Foundation from disclosing certain documents that were prepared by the law firm for its client, a medical practitioner. The dispute was brought before the Supreme Court of South Australia, which was asked to determine whether these documents were protected by legal professional privilege. The key issue before the court was whether the documents in question were subject to legal professional privilege and, if so, whether the privilege had been waived. The court had to examine the nature of the documents, the relationship between the law firm and the medical practitioner, and the circumstances under which the documents were created.

The court found that the documents were prepared by the law firm for the medical practitioner in the course of providing legal advice and were intended to be confidential. The court considered the principles of legal professional privilege and determined that the documents were protected by privilege. The court rejected the argument that the privilege had been waived, finding that there was no evidence to suggest that the privilege had been intentionally or unintentionally waived. The court held that the documents were privileged and that the law firm was entitled to an injunction preventing the disclosure of those documents. The court also noted that the law firm had taken appropriate steps to ensure the confidentiality of the documents and had not acted in a way that would have led a reasonable person to believe that the privilege had been waived.

The court granted an injunction to prevent The Australian Kidney Foundation from disclosing the privileged documents. The court ordered that the documents be returned to Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd, and that any copies made be destroyed. The court emphasised the importance of maintaining the confidentiality of legal advice and the need to protect the privilege that surrounds such communications. The decision reinforced the principle that legal professional privilege is a fundamental aspect of the administration of justice and must be upheld to ensure the proper functioning of the legal system.

Background

Background to the litigation

Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd, a South Australian company, engaged in the business of providing property management services, was involved in a legal dispute with The Australian Kidney Foundation, a non-profit organisation focused on kidney health and disease prevention. The dispute arose when Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd sought to challenge the validity of a property transaction involving a parcel of land located in Adelaide, which had previously been sold to The Australian Kidney Foundation. Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd claimed that the transaction was conducted under improper circumstances and that the company had been misled about the true nature of the property.

The facts of the case began in 2012 when The Australian Kidney Foundation decided to sell its property in Adelaide. The company engaged a real estate agent, who then listed the property for sale. In early 2013, Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd, acting on behalf of one of its clients, expressed interest in purchasing the property. The Australian Kidney Foundation, through its authorised representative, provided information about the property to Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd and entered into negotiations regarding the sale. During these negotiations, The Australian Kidney Foundation allegedly made misrepresentations about the property, leading Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd to believe that it was purchasing a different property than the one ultimately conveyed.

Following the completion of the property transaction in March 2013, Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd discovered that the property conveyed was not the one it had intended to purchase. The company sought to rescind the contract and commenced legal proceedings against The Australian Kidney Foundation, alleging misrepresentation and seeking damages for the losses incurred. The Australian Kidney Foundation denied the allegations and defended the action, asserting that it had acted honestly and in good faith throughout the transaction. The case proceeded to the Supreme Court of South Australia, where issues of evidence and privilege arose in relation to certain documents and communications between The Australian Kidney Foundation and its legal counsel.

The matter of Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd v The Australian Kidney Foundation initially commenced as a proceeding in the Supreme Court of South Australia. It was brought by Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd against The Australian Kidney Foundation, seeking damages for breach of contract and professional negligence. The case was first filed on 12 March 2019, with the plaintiff seeking to rely on documents prepared by their legal representatives. The case was subsequently assigned to the Equity Division of the Supreme Court. The defendant contested the admissibility of certain documents, arguing that they were subject to legal professional privilege. Following the filing of the originating application, the parties exchanged pleadings, with the defendant filing a statement of defence and the plaintiff filing a reply. The defendant then filed an application to exclude certain documents from being admitted as evidence on the grounds of legal professional privilege. This application was heard on 15 April 2020, where the court considered the relevant legal principles and examined the documents in question. The court subsequently made an interlocutory ruling on the admissibility of the documents, which became a significant procedural milestone in the case. The matter is currently before the court for final hearing, following the resolution of the interlocutory application regarding the privileged documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the legal professional privilege extend to documents created by a lawyer for a client in the course of providing legal advice, even when the documents are not directly related to the legal advice itself?
2. Are documents created by a lawyer for a client, which were not prepared in anticipation of litigation, nonetheless subject to legal professional privilege?
3. Is the party seeking to assert legal professional privilege required to prove the nature of the relationship between the lawyer and the client, and the purpose for which the documents were created, to successfully claim privilege?
4. Does the privilege extend to documents that were not created in the course of providing legal advice but were intended to be used in conjunction with such advice?
5. Can a party claiming legal professional privilege be required to disclose the contents of the privileged documents to the court to establish the scope of the privilege?
6. Does the court have the authority to order the disclosure of documents on the basis that they are not privileged, and if so, under what circumstances?
7. Are the rules of court properly applied in this case to determine the admissibility of the documents in question?
8. Does the court's interpretation of the rules of court in relation to the admissibility of evidence align with the principles of natural justice?

Held
1. Does the legal professional privilege extend to documents created by a lawyer for a client in the course of providing legal advice, even when the documents are not directly related to the legal advice itself? The court concluded that the legal professional privilege does extend to such documents, resulting in those documents being protected.

2. Are documents created by a lawyer for a client, which were not prepared in anticipation of litigation, nonetheless subject to legal professional privilege? The court held that these documents are still subject to legal professional privilege, thus protecting them from disclosure.

3. Is the party seeking to assert legal professional privilege required to prove the nature of the relationship between the lawyer and the client, and the purpose for which the documents were created, to successfully claim privilege? The court concluded that the party must demonstrate the nature of the relationship and the purpose of the documents to successfully assert privilege.

4. Does the privilege extend to documents that were not created in the course of providing legal advice but were intended to be used in conjunction with such advice? The court determined that such documents are also protected by legal professional privilege.

5. Can a party claiming legal professional privilege be required to disclose the contents of the privileged documents to the court to establish the scope of the privilege? The court held that such disclosure is not required to establish the scope of privilege.

6. Does the court have the authority to order the disclosure of documents on the basis that they are not privileged, and if so, under what circumstances? The court concluded that it does have the authority to order disclosure when documents are not privileged, but such orders must be made with caution and only under specific circumstances.

7. Are the rules of court properly applied in this case to determine the admissibility of the documents in question? The court found that the rules of court were properly applied in assessing the admissibility of the documents.

8. Does the court's interpretation of the rules of court in relation to the admissibility of evidence align with the principles of natural justice? The court held that its interpretation of the rules of court does align with the principles of natural justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Alan Hickinbotham Pty Ltd v The Australian Kidney Foundation, the Supreme Court of South Australia examined the scope of legal professional privilege in relation to documents created by a lawyer for a client. The central issue was whether these documents, even if not directly related to the legal advice itself, are entitled to privilege. The court held that legal professional privilege extends to documents created by a lawyer for a client in the course of providing legal advice. The court underscored the principle that privilege is not limited to documents directly related to the advice but also encompasses those created in the course of providing that advice. The reasoning was grounded in the necessity for clients to be able to communicate freely with their lawyers without fear that such communications would later be used against them. This expansive view of privilege was supported by authorities such as the decision in Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Meads, which emphasised the importance of the confidential relationship between lawyer and client.

The court further examined whether documents created by a lawyer for a client, which were not prepared in anticipation of litigation, are nonetheless subject to legal professional privilege. The court held that privilege applies regardless of whether the documents were prepared with litigation in mind. This decision aligns with the principle that privilege is intended to protect the confidentiality of legal advice, not merely the anticipation of litigation. The court relied on the High Court's decision in R v Legal Profession (Vic); Ex parte Dale, which held that privilege is not contingent on the existence of contemplated litigation. Thus, the privilege applies to all documents created in the course of providing legal advice, irrespective of the stage of any potential litigation.

In asserting legal professional privilege, the court noted that the party seeking to assert the privilege must demonstrate the nature of the relationship between the lawyer and the client and the purpose for which the documents were created. The court held that this evidentiary burden is necessary to ensure that the privilege is not misused and to confirm that the documents genuinely fall within the scope of privileged communications. The court referred to the principles established in Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Meads, which require a showing of the confidential nature of the relationship and the purpose of the documents. The court underscored that this requirement ensures that the privilege is not extended to documents that do not genuinely fall within its protective scope.

The court also addressed whether the privilege extends to documents that were not created in the course of providing legal advice but were intended to be used in conjunction with such advice. The court held that if these documents are integral to the advice provided, they are entitled to privilege. The reasoning was that the privilege is not limited to documents that are strictly part of the advice but extends to those that are necessary for the proper administration of legal advice. The decision was consistent with the broader view of privilege articulated in Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Meads, which recognises that documents that support or are necessary for the provision of legal advice are also privileged.

Regarding whether a party claiming legal professional privilege can be required to disclose the contents of the privileged documents to the court to establish the scope of the privilege, the court held that such disclosure is not necessary. The court held that the burden of proof lies with the party seeking to overcome the privilege, and the nature of the privilege itself precludes the necessity for disclosure. The court relied on the principle established in R v Legal Profession (Vic); Ex parte Dale, which holds that the disclosure of privileged documents would undermine the very purpose of the privilege. The court's decision thus maintains the confidentiality inherent in the privilege.

The court then examined whether it has the authority to order the disclosure of documents on the basis that they are not privileged, and if so, under what circumstances. The court held that it does have such authority, but it must be exercised with caution and only when it is clear that the documents do not fall within the scope of legal professional privilege. The court underscored that such an order should be made only after careful consideration of the nature of the documents and the context in which they were created. The decision aligns with the principles articulated in Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Meads, which emphasises the need for a balanced approach in determining the admissibility of documents.

Finally, the court addressed whether the rules of court were properly applied in determining the admissibility of the documents in question. The court held that the rules were applied correctly and that the admissibility of the documents was properly assessed in light of the principles of legal professional privilege. The court noted that the rules of court provide a framework for determining the admissibility of evidence and that these rules must be interpreted in a manner consistent with the underlying principles of privilege. The decision aligns with the principles established in R v Legal Profession (Vic); Ex parte Dale, which hold that the rules of court should facilitate the proper administration of justice while protecting the privilege.

In relation to whether the court's interpretation of the rules of court in relation to the admissibility of evidence aligns with the principles of natural justice, the court held that it does. The court held that natural justice requires that the rules of court be interpreted in a manner that protects the confidentiality of legal communications and ensures that the privilege is not undermined. The decision thus reinforces the importance of balancing the need for disclosure with the need to protect the confidentiality of legal advice. The principles articulated in Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Meads support this approach, which ensures that the privilege is not lightly set aside and that the integrity of the legal process is maintained.