DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)
AL MOUSSAWI v PASSENGER TRANSPORT STANDARDS COMMITTEE
[2021] SADC 79
Judgment of his Honour Judge Burnett
7 July 2021
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - STATUTORY APPEALS FROM ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES TO COURTS
PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LICENSING OR REGULATION OF OTHER PROFESSIONS, TRADES OR CALLINGS
TRAFFIC LAW - PUBLIC TRANSPORT REGULATION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - LICENSING
The appellant was a taxi driver and an accredited person pursuant to s 27 of the Passenger Transport Act 1994 (SA) (the PTA).
An incident occurred whilst the appellant was driving his taxi cab, as a result of which the appellant was charged with indecent assault. The incident involved the appellant touching the thigh and the cheek of a female passenger, on each occasion for less than a second. The charges for indecent assault were later withdrawn by the police.
The Passenger Transport Standards Committee (the Committee) held a disciplinary hearing in relation to the conduct of the appellant and found that the appellant had breached the obligations imposed on him under the regulations under the PTA in a number of respects. The Committee determined, inter alia, that the appellant’s accreditation under the PTA should be suspended for a period of two years and further that once the suspension had been completed, he appear before the Committee for it to assess his fitness and propriety to hold accreditation.
In imposing the penalty, the Committee stated that it took into account that the incident:
1. resulted in serious criminal charges against the appellant which were discontinued by the police;
2. occurred while he was on duty as an accredited taxi driver;
3. was the second time a similar incident had occurred while he was on duty as an accredited taxi driver.
The appellant appealed the decision of the Committee, which appeal is heard by this Court sitting in its Administrative and Disciplinary Division. Pursuant to s 42E(3) of the District Court Act 1991, the Court must give due weight to the decision being appealed against and the reasons for it and not depart from the decision except for cogent reasons.
Held:
1. The appeal is allowed and the decision of the Committee as to penalty is rescinded.
2. In lieu therefore, the following orders are made: (1) the suspension of the appellant’s driver accreditation be for a period of 12 months commencing on 13 March 2020 and expiring on 12 March 2021 and (2) the appellant, if he has not already done so, is to undergo within 60 days of today’s date some form of counselling which addresses his inappropriate behaviour and is to provide proof of that counselling to the Committee as soon as possible thereafter.
3. The Committee had committed an error of the type described in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 and therefore there were cogent reasons to depart from the decision of the Committee: Commissioner for Consumer Affairs v McMurray (2017) 128 SASR 1 applied.
4. In…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Al Moussawi v Passenger Transport Standards Committee and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] SADC 79
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues in this case revolved around whether the Committee had committed an error in its decision-making process that warranted the appeal. The court examined whether the Committee had erred by relying on unsubstantiated previous incidents and charges that were withdrawn by the police. The court also considered whether the penalty imposed was appropriate and whether there was a distinction between the imposition of a suspension and the cancellation of an accreditation. The court applied the principles established in House v The King and Commissioner for Consumer Affairs v McMurray to determine whether there were cogent reasons to depart from the decision of the Committee.
The court found that the Committee had indeed committed errors in its decision-making process. Firstly, the Committee erred by placing reliance on previous incidents for which there was no evidence and which the appellant denied any involvement in. Secondly, the Committee erred by relying on charges that had been withdrawn by the police before any evidence at trial and verdict. The court held that these errors warranted the rescission of the penalty and the imposition of a new penalty. The court also noted that there was no evidence to justify a defacto disqualification, and thus, the requirement for the appellant to re-apply for accreditation upon the expiry of the suspension was inappropriate.
The court ordered that the appeal be allowed, and the decision of the Committee as to the penalty be rescinded. In its place, the court ordered that the suspension of the appellant's driver accreditation be for a period of 12 months, commencing on 13 March 2020 and expiring on 12 March 2021. Additionally, the appellant was required to undergo some form of counselling within 60 days of the court's decision, which addresses his inappropriate behaviour, and provide proof of that counselling to the Committee as soon as possible thereafter.
Orders
Orders of the court
Held:
1. The appeal is allowed and the decision of the Committee as to penalty is rescinded.
2. In lieu therefore, the following orders are made: (1) the suspension of the appellant’s driver accreditation be for a period of 12 months commencing on 13 March 2020 and expiring on 12 March 2021 and (2) the appellant, if he has not already done so, is to undergo within 60 days of today’s date some form of counselling which addresses his inappropriate behaviour and is to provide proof of that counselling to the Committee as soon as possible thereafter.
3. The Committee had committed an error of the type described in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 and therefore there were cogent reasons to depart from the decision of the Committee: Commissioner for Consumer Affairs v McMurray (2017) 128 SASR 1 applied.
4. In imposing the penalty, the Committee erred in placing reliance on the previous incident in circumstances where there was no evidence about that incident and the appellant had denied any culpability in relation to that incident.
5. The Committee also erred in placing reliance on the fact the incident resulted in serious criminal charges, when those charges had been withdrawn by the police. Although the mere fact that the charges may be relevant in imposing an interim suspension, the fact that they had been withdrawn before any evidence at trial and verdict, no adverse inferences or conclusion could be drawn about the fitness or character of the appellant from the mere fact of the charges.
6. The Committee erred in requiring the appellant to re-apply for accreditation upon the expiry of the suspension. There was no evidence before the Committee that justified a defacto disqualification. The Courts have recognised the distinction between the imposition of a suspension and the imposition of a cancellation of an accreditation, see Council of the Law Society of New South Wales v Zhukovska [2020] NSWCA 163; Farquharson v Director General, Department of Transport [1999] NSWADT 53 and Nursing & Midwifery Board of Australia v Roe [2018] WASAT 92.