Air Products and Chemicals Inc v Linde Aktiengesellschaft

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

official notice

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Applications       :  No. 601105 & No. 602620 in the name of AIR PRODUCTS AND CHEMICALS INC

Title:  Air separation process

Action: S.59 oppositions under the 1952 Act by LINDE AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT; hearing.

Decision:  Issued            .  Opposition to 601105 failed, application to proceed to sealing. Improvement invention not obvious because of surprising results. Grounds of opposition to 602620 established, claims not fairly based,  opportunity given for applicant to propose amendments. Common general knowledge discussed re obviousnsess and novelty.

patents act 1990

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Re:Patent Applications No. 601105 & No. 602620 by AIR PRODUCTS AND CHEMICALS INC and opposition under S.59 of the Patents Act 1952 by LINDE AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT.

background

Convention applications 601105 & 602620, for patents for inventions relating to an air separation process, comprise complete specifications lodged on 21 April 1989 and 13 December 1988 respectively, with priority claimed from applications lodged in the United States on 29 April 1988 and 14 December 1987 respectively. The applications were advertised accepted on 30 August 1990 and 18 October 1990, and opposed on 30 November 1990 and 18 January 1991. After both parties served their evidence, the matter was heard in Melbourne on 9-11 August 1993; the applicant was represented by Dr John Emmerson, QC, and Mr David Rainey, patent attorney; the opponent was represented by Mr Bruce Caine, of Counsel, and Mr Greg Noonan, patent attorney. The applicant's US patent counsel, Mr Willard Jones II and one of the inventors, Dr Douglas Bennett, were also present at the hearing.

application  no. 601105

the specification

The specification of 601105 indicates that the invention relates to a cryogenic process for the separation of air into its constituent components of oxygen, nitrogen and argon.  The process involves cryogenic distillation in an integrated multi-column system having a high pressure column, a low pressure column and an argon sidearm column.  In each of these columns, a liquid phase stream and a vapour phase stream are intimately contacted thereby allowing mass transfer.  The improvement of the invention is the use of a structured packing in place of distillation trays in the low pressure and argon sidearm columns; this results in increased argon recovery.  The specification details the three column distillation apparatus and the results of various tests using the structured packing.

Claim 1 reads as follows:

"In a process for the separation of mixtures, which comprise oxygen, nitrogen, and argon, by cryogenic distillation in an integrated multi-column distillation system having a low pressure column and an argon sidearm column wherein the argon sidearm column integrally communicates with the low pressure column, and wherein each column of the integrated distillation system, a liquid phase stream and a vapour phase stream are intimately contacted thereby allowing mass transfer; the improvement for increasing argon recovery comprises effectuating the intimate contact of the liquid and vapour phase streams in the low pressure column and the argon sidearm column by utilizing a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Air Products and Chemicals Inc v Linde Aktiengesellschaft and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] APO 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Air Products and Chemicals Inc. opposed an application for a patent for an air separation process by Linde Aktiengesellschaft. The application was for an improvement to a cryogenic distillation process for separating air into its constituent components of oxygen, nitrogen, and argon. The process involved cryogenic distillation in an integrated multi-column system using structured packing instead of distillation trays to increase argon recovery. The opposition was based on several grounds, including novelty, obviousness, and non-compliance with section 40 of the Patents Act 1990. The opposition to application 601105 was unsuccessful, and the application was allowed to proceed to sealing. The court found that the claims were not obvious and that the invention was novel in the light of the Alekseev documents. However, the opposition to application 602620 was successful because claims 1-4 were not fairly based. The applicant was allowed 60 days to propose amendments to overcome the objection to the specification. Costs followed the event.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established