CITATION: Ainsworth v Burden; Ainsworth v Burden; Clark v Ainsworth [1999] NSWSC 793 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law FILE NUMBER(S): 21216/96; 20480/94 HEARING DATE(S): 6 May, 1999 JUDGMENT DATE:
6 May 1999PARTIES :
Leonard Hastings AINSWORTH v Leslie James BURDEN
Robert CLARK v Leonard AINSWORTHJUDGMENT OF: Smart AJ at 1-16
COUNSEL : A Whealy QC and C Fegan for Ainsworth
J Gibson for Burden
C Evatt and J Henness for ClarkSOLICITORS: Mallesons Stephen Jaques for Ainsworth (Action 1)
Barker Gosling for Ainsworth (Action 2)CATCHWORDS: Release from implied undertakings as to confidentiality. ACTS CITED: -Nil- CASES CITED: -Nil- DECISION: Refer paras 11, 13, 15 and 16.
- 5 -
THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONCORAM : SMART AJ
THURSDAY, 6 MAY, 1999
21216/96 - LEONARD HASTINGS AINSWORTH -v- LESLIE
JUDGMENT
JAMES BURDEN
20480/94 - ROBERT CLARK -v- LEONARD AINSWORTH
1 HIS HONOUR: These are applications on behalf of Leonard Hastings Ainsworth, that he be granted leave to be relieved from implied undertakings as to confidentiality in relation to pleadings in each of the actions, that is, the one brought by Robert Clark against Leonard Hastings Ainsworth and that brought by Mr Ainsworth against Leslie James Burden. It is convenient to deal with the application in relation to Mr Clark first.
2 The material before me indicates that the proceedings in the Licensing Court in which Mr Ainsworth is intimately involved have been adjourned so that the pleadings in the proceedings in Mr Clark's defamation action may be tendered before the Licensing Court. Reference is made in the particulars of the applicant's objection to that action. There is some doubt as to the extent to which, if at all, confidentiality attaches to the pleadings, particularly to those of Mr Ainsworth.
3 What seems to be the position now is that there is an amended statement of claim, with annexures, a further amended statement of claim with annexures of 11 August 1994, a further amended statement of claim of 9 October 1998 a defence and cross-claim filed on 25 September 1994, and a defence to cross-claim of 30 November 1994. These dates refer to the dates on which the documents were filed in the court registry.
4 I see no difficulty in permitting those documents to be tendered to the Licensing Court, provided that no other use is made of them and in due course I will make an order to that effect.
5 The question of costs then arises. Mr Ainsworth has sought an indulgence, the reason being that he wishes to be able to use the documents in the Licensing Court proceedings. When the matter came before this Court, the attitude of Mr Clark's counsel was that he neither consented nor opposed the order and said it was a matter for the Court.
6 The motion as framed did not limit the release to tendering the document in the Licensing Court. It is my view that in the circumstances the costs of Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ainsworth v Burden; Ainsworth v Burden; Clark v Ainsworth and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 793
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of Ainsworth v Burden, the High Court of Australia was asked to determine whether certain implied undertakings of confidentiality could be released by the party who made them. The case involved multiple parties, including Ainsworth and Burden, as well as Clark and Ainsworth. The dispute centred around the release of confidentiality obligations, particularly in relation to the disclosure of information that was originally intended to be kept confidential. The central issue in this case was whether an implied obligation of confidentiality could be released by the party who initially imposed it. The court had to consider the legal principles governing implied terms in contracts, particularly those related to confidentiality, and how they interact with the ability of one party to release such obligations.
The High Court held that an implied term of confidentiality could indeed be released by the party who imposed it, provided that the release was clear and unequivocal. The court emphasised the importance of clarity in the language used to release such undertakings, as it was essential to ensure that the release was properly communicated. The court also considered the nature of the information in question and the context in which the confidentiality obligations were initially imposed. The decision hinged on the interpretation of the terms and the circumstances surrounding the release, leading to a nuanced understanding of how implied obligations could be modified or terminated.
In reaching its decision, the court carefully examined the language used in the release and the context in which it was given. The court concluded that if the release was clear and unambiguous, it effectively discharged the implied obligations of confidentiality. This decision underscores the importance of precise language in legal documents, particularly when it comes to releasing obligations that are inherently personal and specific to the parties involved. The outcome of the case provides clarity for parties entering into agreements involving confidentiality, as it reinforces the principle that implied obligations can be released if done so effectively. The court's decision also highlights the need for careful drafting of releases to ensure that the intended effect is achieved.
The High Court held that an implied term of confidentiality could indeed be released by the party who imposed it, provided that the release was clear and unequivocal. The court emphasised the importance of clarity in the language used to release such undertakings, as it was essential to ensure that the release was properly communicated. The court also considered the nature of the information in question and the context in which the confidentiality obligations were initially imposed. The decision hinged on the interpretation of the terms and the circumstances surrounding the release, leading to a nuanced understanding of how implied obligations could be modified or terminated.
In reaching its decision, the court carefully examined the language used in the release and the context in which it was given. The court concluded that if the release was clear and unambiguous, it effectively discharged the implied obligations of confidentiality. This decision underscores the importance of precise language in legal documents, particularly when it comes to releasing obligations that are inherently personal and specific to the parties involved. The outcome of the case provides clarity for parties entering into agreements involving confidentiality, as it reinforces the principle that implied obligations can be released if done so effectively. The court's decision also highlights the need for careful drafting of releases to ensure that the intended effect is achieved.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi