AIG18 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

AIG18 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 169

File number: MLG 177 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 18 February 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION -  protection visa – judicial review of decision of Immigration Assessment Authority – whether applicant denied procedural fairness – where files relating to previous visa applications not before Authority – whether applicants claims for protection properly considered – consideration of fast track review process – no error found
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 473CB, 473DB, 473DC, 473DE, 473GB
Cases cited:

ABT17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2020) 269 CLR 439

BIS17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FedCFamC2G 730

CQR17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 269 FCR 367

CUZ17 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 3074

EVS17 v Minister for Immigration (2019) 268 FCR 299

High Court in Plaintiff M174/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 264 CLR 217

Republic of Nauru v WET040 (No 2) (2018) 93 ALJR 102

Selvadurai v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 34 ALR 347

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 90
Date of hearing: 10 February 2025
Place: Melbourne
Applicant: In person
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr Plitsch; Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

MLG 177 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

AIG18

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE FORBES

DATE OF ORDER:

18 FEBRUARY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant’s application for judicial review filed 23 January 2018 be dismissed.

2.The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs in accordance with the scale prescribed in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE FORBES

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 10 January 2018 the Immigration Assessment Authority (the Authority) affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a protection visa.  By an application dated 16 January 2018 the applicant seeks judicial review of the Authority’s decision.

  2. The application for judicial review identifies eight grounds of error. Each of those grounds and my findings in relation to each are set out later in these reasons.

  3. Suffice to say, at the judicial review hearing before me on 10 February 2025, the self-represented applicant (who was assisted by a Mandarin interpreter) did not make any substantive submissions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AIG18 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a citizen of the People’s Republic of China, sought judicial review of the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (Authority) to affirm the Minister’s refusal to grant him a protection visa. The applicant had previously applied for and been refused a protection visa on two occasions. This was his third application. The applicant claimed he feared harm for reasons of his religion, membership of a particular social group, imputed political opinion, and because of the release of his personal information on the Department of Immigration and Border Protection website. The Authority reviewed the decision and found that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution and there was not a real risk of significant harm upon his return to China. The Authority found the applicant’s claims not credible and inconsistent. The applicant sought to have the Authority’s decision reviewed on the basis that the Authority was not provided with certain files relating to his previous visa applications and therefore was denied procedural fairness.

The legal issues in the case were whether the Authority was denied procedural fairness by not having the files relating to the applicant’s previous visa applications, and whether the Authority properly considered the applicant’s claims for protection. The court considered whether the failure to refer the relevant files to the Authority was unreasonable and, if so, whether it was a material error that affected the Authority’s decision. The court also examined whether the Authority properly considered the applicant’s claims for protection.

The court found that the failure to refer the relevant files to the Authority was not unreasonable, as the files were not considered relevant to the review. The court found that the Authority properly considered the applicant’s claims for protection and found them not credible and inconsistent. The court held that there was no error in the Authority’s decision and dismissed the application for judicial review.

The final orders of the court were that the application for judicial review be dismissed and that the applicant pay the Minister’s costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Having considered the written and oral submissions advanced on behalf of the Minister, I am satisfied that the decision of the Authority was not affected by judicial error. Accordingly, the application will be dismissed. BACKGROUND The applicant is a citizen of the People’s Republic of China. On 12 September 2017 the applicant lodged an application for a protection visa (subclass 866) wherein he expressed claims to fear harm for reasons of his religion, his membership of a particular social group, his imputed political opinion and because of the release of his personal information on the website of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection. On 2 November 2017, a delegate of the Minister (the delegate) refused to grant the visa, finding that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution and there was not a real risk of significant harm upon his return to China. The delegate’s decision on 2 November 2017 was the third occasion on which the applicant had been refused a protection visa. The applicant first applied for a protection visa on 1 August 2011. That application was refused by a delegate on 15 August 2011 and the refusal was subsequently affirmed by the then Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) on 8 December 2011. On 6 November 2013, the applicant was permitted to make a second application for a protection visa. Again, that application was refused by a delegate in a decision dated 8 January 2015. The RRT affirmed that delegate’s decision on 9 February 2015. On 26 July 2017, the applicant was identified as a “fast track applicant” and was therefore permitted to make a third application. On 12 September 2017, the applicant applied for the visa which is the subject of these review proceedings. The claims for protection advanced in support of this most recent application were:(a)that the applicant was a practitioner of Falun Gong, a religious practice regarded as illegal in China. The applicant claimed that his involvement with Falun Gong had caused him harm in the past;(b)that the applicant had borrowed money from loan sharks and members of the Triad, who started hurting and persecuting him when he was unable to repay the debts; and(c)the applicant’s personal information had been disclosed in a data breach by the Department in 2014. The applicant claimed that his creditors and the Chinese police might have access to this information and cause him harm. Prior to the refusal of this third visa application, the applicant attended an interview with the delegate on 16 October 2017. As I discussed later in these reasons, at that interview the applicant was asked questions about his previous visa applications and the earlier RRT decisions which affirmed the refusals. After the delegate’s refusal of the visa application on 2 November 2017, the application was referred to the Authority for review pursuant to Part 7AA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The materials provided by the Department to the Authority for the purposes of the review did not contain the files relating to the applicant’s first or second applications. The referred materials did, however, contain the two RRT decisions from 2011 and 2015 and the delegate’s most recent decision which included observations arising from the delegate’s interview with the applicant in October 2017.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons set out in its decision published on 10 January 2018, the delegate’s decision was affirmed and the application for a protection visa was refused.Authority’s decision At paragraphs [11] to [24] of her outline of submissions filed on 28 January 2025, counsel for the Minister summarised the Authority’s reasons. I have carefully read the Authority’s reasons and accept counsel’s summary as comprehensive, fair and properly referenced. I adopt it for the purposes of this judgment. 11.The Authority noted that it had been provided with the review material under s 473CB of the Act, and no new information had been provided: [3]-[4]. It noted the existence of the two non-disclosure certificates, issued under s 473GB of the Act, and in exercising its discretion under sub-s (3), determined: [5]:11.1.not to have regard to two of the three documents, because they were irrelevant to the review; and11.2.not to release the information in the third document, as the document did not contain any information in addition to what was already before it, and the information had been put to the applicant in the protection visa interview already.12.The Authority noted that the applicant had applied for protection three times, and in the first visa application he claimed to fear harm as a Falun Gong practitioner and because of an unpaid debt, and in the second visa application and the current application he claimed in addition to the matters raised in the first visa application that he was part of the data breach in 2014: [9]. While the Authority did not have the first application or the second application before it, it had the Tribunal decisions and the claims that were recorded in the decisions were discussed at length with the applicant at the protection visa interview with the delegate on 16 October 2017. In the absence of any information to the contrary, the Authority considered that the accounts of the applicant’s claims in the Tribunal decisions were reliable; [10]13.The Authority then considered the applicant’s Falun Gong claim, and noted several inconsistencies in the evidence given by the applicant at his various hearings and interviews with respect to his claim to fear harm on the basis of his Falun Gong practice, including that:13.1.he claimed to start practicing in 2006 in his first Tribunal hearing, but claimed he started in 2001 in his second Tribunal hearing: [13]. The applicant was unable to provide an explanation for this discrepancy during his interview with the delegate, but confirmed that the 2001 date was correct: [14]. When the delegate put to him that he had claimed in his second Tribunal hearing to start practicing in 2006 because a friend had provided him with the materials after a period of detention in China, the applicant responded that he would only like to talk about the data breach: [15].13.2.he claimed in his first Tribunal hearing that he practised alone and seldom participated in organised activities, but in his second Tribunal hearing and his written submissions to the delegate in his third application, he claimed to attend a special place after work three days per week and listen to lectures as Falun Gong meetings and groups from 2001: [16]. When asked about this inconsistency by the delegate, the applicant declined to comment: [16]. The Authority found the inconsistencies about the date the applicant commenced Falun Gong and whether he seldom participated in Falun Gong activities or regularly attended Falun Gong lectures, were significant: [17].13.3.in his submissions to the delegate in his third application and in the hearing before the Tribunal for the second application, he claimed that he had been taken by a police officer on three occasions because of his Falun Gong practice, whereas his evidence to the Tribunal on the first occasion was that he had been detained by police because of debts twice, and Falun Gong the third and final time: [18]. When asked about this inconsistency by the delegate, the applicant declined to comment: [18]. The Authority found that it was not credible that the applicant would not know how many times he had been taken by a police officer in China because of his Falun Gong activities: [19].14.The Authority found it significant that the applicant was unable to provide much detail at either of the Tribunal hearings about the Falun Gong activities in which he claimed to have been involved since 2001 or 2006. In particular, the Authority noted that the applicant had been unable to name the central Falun Gong book (Zhuan Falun written by Falun Dafa’s founder, Li Hong Zhi) in his previous hearings or before the delegate, and the applicant stated he had not seen this book: [20]. It further found that it was “not credible that, if the applicant was a genuine Falun Gong practitioner and had been involved in Falun Gong from either 2001 or 2006, and had read the Falun Gong books as he claimed at the hearing on 10 November 2011, he would not know the central text setting out the beliefs of Li Hong Zhi for Falun Gong when asked about it in 2011”: [21].15.The Authority noted the delegate had put to the applicant that it was implausible that he was convicted of incitement to overthrow the state, for possessing and spreading Falun Gong material, yet no action was taken against him from August 2006 until his departure from China in June 2008, and that fraudulent documents can be easily obtained in China. Noting the applicant had told the first Tribunal that the prosecution did not succeed and the significant inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence otherwise, the Tribunal placed little weight on the document purportedly issued by the People’s Prosecutor of Daoli District: [22].16.The Authority identified other inconsistencies regarding key matters such as the reasons the applicant gave for why he left China, why he did not depart China earlier if he was being persecuted for his faith and why he was able to obtain a passport, his reasons for not wanting to return to China (he stated in the second Tribunal hearing that it was because he liked Australia), why he did not apply for a protection visa until three years after his arrival in Australia, and after he was detained as an unlawful non- citizen and his evidence that despite attending Falun Gong meetings, he never undertook the five key exercises: [23]. The Authority considered the applicant’s claim that a stroke in mid-2011 made it difficult for him to recall information, but rejected this explanation: [24]. The Authority noted that the applicant had attended two Tribunal hearings in November 2011 and February 2015 (both after the occurrence of the stroke) without any apparent difficulty: [24].17.The Authority concluded that the applicant was not a Falun Gong practitioner in China or Australia, and was accordingly not satisfied that he had been persecuted in China on the basis of being a Falun Gong practitioner. As such, the Authority was not satisfied that there was a real chance that the applicant would be persecuted for reason of being a Falun Gong practitioner if returned to China: [25].18.The Authority then considered to the applicant’s claims to fear harm on the basis of his debts in China. In his visa application, the applicant said that he borrowed 500,000 RMB in 2005, which with interest would now be 900,000 RMB: [26]. It noted that the delegate at the protection visa interview on 16 October 2017 raised with the applicant that his evidence at the second Tribunal hearing on 5 February 2015 was that he owed 900,000 RMB in 2005 and that amount was outstanding in 2015 and the second Tribunal referred to the implausibility that the debt could remain exactly the same in 2005 and 2015. The Authority did not find it credible that the loan did not increase between 2005 and 2015 and that the total amount claimed to be outstanding was 900,000 RMB in 2005 and in 2015: [28]. The Authority also did not accept as credible that the applicant would not have made attempts to repay part of the loan: [29].19.The Authority noted that the applicant stated to the first Tribunal that, after he was sued in China in relation to the debt, the Chinese court mediated the issue, he told them he could pay his debt by selling his vehicles, a written agreement was drafted to document when the debt would be repaid and before the mediated repayment date, he was arrested by a court official. The Authority considered the applicant’s failure to repay the debt by selling his vehicles when he had the opportunity to do so indicated that he did not have any fear concerning a debt: [30]. The Authority considered it unlikely that the applicant did not tell his son of his financial issues if he feared harm and persecution, and because the son was a dependent in the second application: [31]-[32].20.The applicant had indicated to the delegate that he does not have any family or friends in Australia who are financially successful and he also indicated that since entering Australia, he has not sought to repay any of his debt. However, in his engagement with the compliance officer on 11 July 2017, the applicant indicated that his brother-in-law could financially support him in Australia. The Authority noted that the delegate also referred the applicant to department records which showed that his daughter-in-law put up a $20,000 bond in August 2017 to secure his release from immigration detention. That the applicant had not made attempts to repay the debt to reduce the risk or chance of harm and that family members here in Australia would assist given the personal risk to the applicant was put to the applicant by the delegate as suggesting he did not have a debt: [33].21.The Authority considered it reasonable to expect that if the applicant’s life was at risk or he was at risk of serious or significant harm, he would have attempted to repay, or at least reduce, the debt in China to reduce the risk or chance of harm to himself. Given his family had offered to financially support him Australia, if he had a fear of harm because of the debt he would have at least approached them about financial assistance: [34]. Similar to the Falun Gong claim, the Authority did not consider that the applicant’s stroke affected his ability to give evidence: [35]. The Authority did not accept that the applicant had or has an outstanding debt in China, nor that he had come to the adverse attention of the Chinese authorities or any creditors or triads. Accordingly, the Authority concluded that there was not a real chance that the applicant would be persecuted on that basis: [35].22.In relation to the applicant’s claim he was at an increased risk of harm as his personal information could have been accessed by creditors or the Chinese police as a result of the data beach ([37]-[38]), the Authority accepted that the applicant had been subject to the data breach: [39]. However, in addition to having rejected the applicant’s claims about being a Falun Gong practitioner and having a debt, the Authority was not satisfied that the applicant’s information was accessed by others: [41]. Further, even if it was accessed by others, the Authority was not satisfied that the applicant would be adversely affected by access to his personal information: [41]-[42]. The Authority noted that the applicant has been in Australia for over ten years, and that there is no credible evidence that the Chinese authorities had any interest in the applicant when he departed China in 2008, nor would he be of interest on return: [43].23.The Authority did not accept that the applicant would suffer harm as a result of the data breach if he returns to China: [44]. Even if the Authority accepted that the applicant could be positively identified based on available information briefly released on the website in 2014, and the Chinese authorities were aware that the applicant had sought asylum in Australia, the Authority was not satisfied that the applicant would face a real chance of harm from the Chinese authorities due to being a failed asylum nor that he has a profile that would result in his being of interest to the authorities on his return as a result of the data breach: [45]24.The Authority was not satisfied, having regard to all of the evidence and the applicant’s claims, that the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution: [46]-[47]. In light of the factual findings in relation to the refugee criterion, the Authority was similarly not satisfied that there were substantial grounds for believing that there was a real risk that the applicant would suffer significant harm: [52].APPLICATION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Part 7AA scheme anticipates that the fast-track process will be conducted as a desktop review of the visa application “on the papers”. To facilitate that task, s 473CB requires:473CB Material to be provided to the Immigration Assessment Authority(1)The Secretary must give to the Immigration Assessment Authority the following material (review material) in respect of each FastTrack reviewable decision referred to the Authority under section 473CA:[…](c)any other material that is in the Secretary’s possession or control that is considered by the Secretary (at the time the decision is referred to the Authority) to be relevant to the review: At [3] - [5] of its reasons, the Authority set out the review material which had been referred to it. That material included the applicant’s third visa application lodged on 12 September 2017, his written statement dated 20 September 2017, the recording of the protection visa interview on 16 October 2017, the delegate’s decision on the third visa application and copies of the RRT decisions in relation to the applicant’s first visa application in 2011 and second visa application in 2015. The Authority also noted that the review material included two certificates under s 473GB of the Act which covered three documents, only one of which the Authority considered potentially relevant to the review. At [10] of its reasons, the Authority noted that although it had access to the RRT decisions in relation to the applicant’s first and second visa applications, it did not have the applications themselves. The Minister acknowledges that this begs the question whether Departmental files relating to the applicant’s earlier visa applications might have been relevant to the review. Specifically, the Minister concedes that questions arise as to whether[4]:(a)material held on the Department’s files was “relevant” such that no reasonable person could have concluded otherwise. If it cannot be said that the failure of the Secretary to refer the materials was unreasonable, then there is no breach;(b)if it is found that the failure to refer the material was unreasonable, then the question arises as to whether the failure to refer the material was a material error.[4] CQR17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 269 FCR 367 at 34 (CQR17) As previously mentioned, the Minister filed and read an affidavit of Laura Jean Groves affirmed on 27 January 2025. That affidavit annexed what Ms Groves described as a complete copy of the Departmental files for the first and protection visa applications – these being documents which did not form part of the material referred to the Authority. In her submissions to the court, Ms McInnis conceded that there was information contained within those files which could have been potentially relevant to the Authority’s review, particularly in relation to the applicant’s articulated claims for protection. Ms McInnis identified the following:(a)the applicant’s first visa application, in particular his response to Question 42 “Why did you leave that country?”[5]. There the applicant gave an explanation regarding his history of unpaid debt and his adoption of Falun Gong practice. He claimed to have been detained because of those debts and his association with the religion. The applicant said he came to Australia because he feared persecution and imprisonment;(b)in his first visa application the applicant presented two documents which purported to be from Chinese courts[6], one of which related to the enforcement of debts and the second which asserts that the applicant had been suspected of inciting to overthrow the state by sending brochures and DVDs of Falun Gong material. These documents were not before the Authority;(c)a copy of extracts from the applicant’s passport;(d)a “Compliance Client Interview” document[7] prepared on 21 July 2011 which recorded the applicant’s responses to questions asked of him when he was located in the community as an unlawful noncitizen; and(e)the applicant’s second visa application[8]. There, in answer to Question 43, the applicant stated “To escape the persecution by the authorities and harm by the creditors and their debt collectors”.[5] Court Book (CB) 219[6] CB 228-233[7] CB 281[8] CB 314