Ahmed v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ahmed v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1571

MIGRATION – application for protection visa – well-founded fear of persecution in Somalia for reason of race, or alternatively, for reason of membership of a particular social group – review of the Refugee Review Tribunal’s decision under s 476(1)(e) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – the Tribunal found that a clan member was targeted for personal gains – whether the Tribunal failed to consider that there might be multiple effective causes for the harm feared.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 36(2), s 476(1)(e), s 430(1)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) Sch 2, Subclass 866

Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (1951), Art 1

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Abdi (1999) FCA 299 referred to
Omar Mohamed Mohamed v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (unreported, Federal Court of Australia, Emmett J, 19 May 1999) [1999] FCA 688 not followed
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Sarrazola(1999) 166 ALR 641 considered
Rajaratnam v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1111 applied

MUSTAFE MOHAMOUD AHMED v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
N174 OF 2000

MATHEWS J
8 NOVEMBER 2000
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALESDISTRICT REGISTRY

N174 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

MUSTAFE MOHAMOUD AHMED
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MATHEWS J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 NOVEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1)The application is allowed.

2)The decision of the refugee Review Tribunal is set aside and the matter remitted to the Refugee Review Tribunal to be reconsidered according to law.

3)The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALESDISTRICT REGISTRY

N174 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

MUSTAFE MOHAMOUD AHMED
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MATHEWS J

DATE:

8 NOVEMBER 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mr Ahmed, seeks judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) dated 17 February 2000 in which the Tribunal affirmed a decision of the respondent’s delegate that the applicant was not entitled to a protection visa.

  2. In order to be eligible for a protection visa, an applicant must meet the criteria set out in s 36(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) and Subclass 866 in Sch 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). Both provisions require that the applicant for a protection visa be a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention as amended by the Refugees Protocol (“the Convention”). Article 1 of the Convention defines a “refugee” as any person who “… owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ahmed v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1571
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ahmed v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs concerns Mr Ahmed, a Somali national who applied for a protection visa in Australia. Mr Ahmed claimed that he had a well-founded fear of persecution due to his race or membership in the Bajuni Clan, a minority group in Somalia. His application was denied by the delegate and subsequently by the Refugee Review Tribunal. The Tribunal found that any harm inflicted on the Bajuni was due to resource acquisition and pecuniary interests rather than persecution for a Convention reason.

The legal issues in this case revolve around the interpretation of the applicable law and its correct application to the facts as found by the Tribunal. The primary issue is whether the Tribunal erred in concluding that harm inflicted on the Bajuni was not for a Convention reason. The applicant argued that the Tribunal failed to consider multiple effective causes for the harm, the possibility of future targeting due to traditional Somali genealogies, and whether increased vulnerability to harm satisfied the requirement of a causal nexus with a Convention reason.

The court found that the Tribunal made an error of law in concluding that harm inflicted on the Bajuni was not for a Convention reason. The court held that the Tribunal did not consider the possibility of multiple effective causes for the harm, as established in Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Sarrazola. The court also noted that the Tribunal did not adequately address the possibility of future targeting and the increased vulnerability of the Bajuni. The decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Refugee Review Tribunal for reconsideration.

In summary, the court ordered that the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal be set aside, the matter be remitted for reconsideration, and the respondent pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1) The application is allowed.

2) The decision of the refugee Review Tribunal is set aside and the matter remitted to the Refugee Review Tribunal to be reconsidered according to law.

3) The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Ahmed says that he has a well-founded fear of persecution for reason of his race, or alternatively his membership of a particular social group, namely the Bajuni Clan, a minority clan in Somalia. FACTUAL BACKGROUND The applicant arrived in Australia on 18 June 1998 using a forged United Arab Emirates (UAE) passport in a false name. He destroyed this passport after passing through immigration clearance. He later produced what he said was his Somali passport and his birth certificate. These showed that he was born at Kismayo on 10 January 1976. On 23 July 1998 the applicant applied for a protection visa. In his application he made the following statement:“Why did you leave that country?I left Somalia in 1992 as I had to flee the increasingly volatile civil war. I fled by myself by boat from the port of Kismanyo to Yemen. I was 16 at the time. My family dispersed at this time and fled to alternate places. I made the decision to leave Somalia myself. My clan was being slaughtered. I am a member of the Baajuun Clan and the Baajuun Clan was being killed by the Majeerten Clan in open fighting. At the time of my departure in 1992 the Majeerten were committing most of the killings but other clans were involved in the inter-clan warfare. There was a major incident that made me as a sixteen year old decide to leave. I saw the body of my uncle who had been killed in the fighting and there were some clan members who were killed around this time that I was close to. I saw many fatalities during the fighting prior to my departure in 1992. I was having nightmares everyday, and I felt that I could be the next one to be killed. I was terrified.What do you fear may happen to you if you go back to that country?I fear ongoing persecution if I return to Somalia. I believe this fear is ‘real’ and ‘substantial’. I am a member of the Baajuun Clan. They have lived predominantly in the south of Somalia around Kismanyo. There [sic] strength and numbers have been decimated as a consequence of the civil war. They are a low caste clan. There is no one that I could live amongst in my clan. I do not have any sense of protection in this region. Before the war clans co-existed and there was no animosity but now the clans are uncomfortable and tension exists. I have no family in Somalia, no home, and clan’s[sic] have there [sic] own militia’s [sic] and screen people from other clan’s [sic] to test for animosity and difference. There is no formal government to provide protection for Somali clan members. The Baajuun have been so extensively decimated that they have no collective strength in Somalia.Thus if I returned to Somalia any part of the country I would be screened and I would be seen to be from the Baajuun Clan and more than likely executed or persecuted.The Baajuun clan is a low caste clan and this because of our lower status my fears are even greater.Many clans do not believe that the Baajuun clan is from the dominant Somali race and has its origins elsewhere.I would be identified in Somali as Baajuun because of my accent and I would be asked to cite my lineage and I could not because I am Baajuun.Who do you think may harm/mistreat you if you go back?Other clans would harm and mistreat me. Somalia has been broken up by the dominant clans and as a consequence armed militias patrol each area. There is no central government. Because of my clan and status I believe I face a real chance of persecution by other dominant clans in Somalia.I also believe I would no [sic] be protected by any one as there is a lack of central government and no organised police force.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MATHEWS J
On 24 March 1999 the respondent’s delegate refused the grant of a protection visa to the applicant. On 6 April 1999 the applicant sought review of this decision from the Tribunal. On 29 July 1999 he attended the Tribunal and gave evidence on his own behalf. On 17 February 2000 the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant him a protection visa. THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal in its decision set out the claims made by the applicant in his various statements and interviews. It also quoted extensively from independent material as to the situation in Somalia, particularly relating to the Bajuni clan. This material indicates that the Bajuni is a small group of approximately 3,000 to 4,000 people who are predominantly sailors and fishermen. They live in small communities along the southern coastline of Somalia. They are racially distinctive, with lighter skin and hair than other Somalis. Being a small clan, the Bajuni do not have their own militia and have no means of protecting themselves. The material indicates that during the fighting which took place when President Barre was ousted in 1991 the Bajuni were victimised by local clans and many fled to Kenya. In its “Findings and Reasons” the Tribunal discussed the document examiner’s reservations as to the authenticity of the applicant’s birth certificate. As the passport was based on this certificate, the Tribunal found that it could not rely upon either document as evidencing the applicant’s identity. However it was prepared to accept that he was a Somali national. The Tribunal made generally unfavourable findings as to the applicant’s credibility. It expressed reservations as to whether he was a member of the Bajuni clan at all. In this regard it pointed to a number of inconsistencies and anomalies in the accounts which the applicant had given of his background in Somalia. However, the Tribunal went on to consider whether, in the event that it was wrong and the applicant was in fact a member of the Bajuni clan, he had a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason should he return to Somalia. In this regard it made the following findings:“The independent evidence before the Tribunal and which I accept states that the Bajuni ‘do not seem to have been targeted for personal or political attack during the fighting’ and that ‘because of their maritime mobility they have not been in as much danger as other Somali minorities’. Furthermore the independent evidence suggests that some Bajuni earned money transporting refugees from Brava and Kismayu in their fishing boats. The applicant in fact initially stated that he travelled to Yemen in this way although he later stated that the Bajuni were not engaged in such activities. However there is conflicting independent evidence before the Tribunal stating that the Bajuni may have been targeted by other Somali clans ‘because of their lack of standing in traditional Somali genealogies’. Given this conflicting evidence I accept that the Bajuni encountered problems during the early stages of the conflict in Somalia.Independent evidence before the Tribunal and set out in this decision which I accept states that the Bajuni were previously vulnerable because of the presence of armed militia ‘who typically steal their equipment and resell it at exorbitant prices’ and ‘sometimes their catch is taken away with little or no recompense’. As the Court states in MIMA v Abdi (1999) FCA 299:‘In many cases the basis for an applicant’s fear will arise from a struggle relating to territory, property or power and not to warfare for reasons of clan or race where the objective is to harm a person because of clan membership. This may be so in Somalia where the existence of shifting alliances tends to indicate that the persecution under consideration at any particular time may not be directed towards clan membership as such, but rather to other considerations incidentally associated with clan membership such as control over land or resources.’In the case of Omar Mohamed Mohamed v MIMA (unreported, Federal Court of Australia, Emmett J, 19 May 1999) the applicant contended that he was subjected to selective harassment because he was a member of a weak clan. The Court held that persecution of small or weak groups was not, of itself, persecution for a Convention reason:-‘Harm arising out of such a war may be disproportionately directed to those unable to defend themselves, whether they be individuals or smaller weak groups. A defenceless person in such circumstances, however, is not at risk by reason of membership of such a group but simply because he or she occupies the territory or has the resource which is sought by the persecutors. The fact that such a person is defenceless to resist the claim by the more powerful group and is unable to defend it does not render the conflict that might arise conflict for a Convention reason. It is a most unfortunate circumstance of human life that that be so. However I do not consider that persecution of weak people in order to obtain what they have, because it is easier to recover what they have from them than from a stronger group, is persecution for a Convention reason.’I find that the purpose of the harm inflicted on the Bajuni was to gain resources and pecuniary interests and was not on the basis of clan or for any other Convention reason.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MATHEWS J

On 3 March 2000 the applicant applied for review of the Tribunal’s decision pursuant to s 476 of the Act. The application for review was later amended so as to include only one ground, under s 476(1)(e) of the Act, namely that the decision involved an error of law, being an error involving an incorrect interpretation of the applicable law or an incorrect application of the law to the facts as found. The particulars in support of this ground were as follows:“(a) Having effectively asked the question, “What if I am wrong?” as to its finds of the applicant’s lack of credit, the Tribunal erred in finding that harm “to gain resources and pecuniary interests” could not be persecution for a Convention reason.(b)The Tribunal did not consider the possibility of there being multiple effective causes to the harm feared.(c)the [sic] Tribunal failed to consider whether, despite their ability to physically return to the Kismayo region of Somalia, Bajani may currently or in the future be targeted because of “their lack of standing in traditional Somali genealogies”, and or have their ability to support themselves removed by the actions of more powerful clans.(d)The Tribunal failed to consider whether increased vulnerability to harm satisfied the requirement of a causal nexus between that harm and a “Convention reason”(e)The Tribunal failed to consider whether any ‘different’ treatment received by the Bajuni was indicative of persecution for a Convention reason.”ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION It was the contention of Mr Karp, who appeared for the applicant at the hearing of this application, that the Tribunal made errors of law in its conclusions about what took place in the past and what might happen in the future. These involve different considerations, and therefore need to be discussed separately.The past As the passage quoted at par [12] indicates, the Tribunal concluded that the Bajuni had not been persecuted for a Convention reason. Rather, the Tribunal found that any harm inflicted upon the Bajuni was to gain resources and to advance pecuniary interests. Mr Karp submitted that this was an erroneous conclusion in that the Tribunal did not consider the possibility that there might have been multiple effective causes for the harm feared. In this regard he relied on Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Sarrazola (1999) 166 ALR 641. In that case the Tribunal upheld the refusal of a protection visa on the basis that the harm which the applicant feared in her country of nationality was from criminals who were motivated by self-interest to recover money which they believed was owing to them by the applicant’s deceased brother. The Tribunal was not satisfied that this harm arose for a Convention reason. The Full Court found that the Tribunal had made an error of law under s 476(1)(e) of the Act. It had erroneously adopted the approach that a finding that the criminals were motivated by a desire to recover money was inconsistent with a finding that they were motivated by a desire to harm the applicant for a Convention reason. In this regard the Tribunal had failed to recognise that a person may be motivated to persecute another for more than one reason.