AGU v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: AGU v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2013] NSWCA 473
Hearing dates:10 December 2013
Decision date: 23 December 2013
Before: Bathurst CJ at [1];
Beazley P at [2];
Basten JA at [3];
Leeming JA at [44];
Sackville AJA at [45]
Decision:

(1) To the extent necessary, grant leave to appeal.

(2) Dismiss the appeal.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords:

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW - whether inconsistency between State and Commonwealth laws - State Act purporting to bind the Commonwealth - State Act purporting to subject Commonwealth to jurisdiction of State tribunal

PRIVACY - operation of State legislation - whether Commonwealth bound - Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW), s 12 - Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION - principles - presumption that Crown not bound by statute - general presumption rebutted by specific provision - whether general provision that Act binds Crown not only in right of enacting State but in all other capacities indicates intention to bind Commonwealth - consideration of specific provisions required - provisions to be read in statutory context

WORDS & PHRASES - "binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and also, in so far as the legislative power of Parliament permits, the Crown in all its other capacities" - Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW), s 12
Legislation Cited: Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 22
Acts Interpretation Act 1931 (Tas), s 6
Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW),s 119
Constitution, ss 77(iii), 109; Ch III
Court Suppression and Non-publication Orders Act 2010 (NSW), s 8
Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW), s 5
Environmental Planning and Assessment 1979 (NSW), s 6
Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW), ss 4, 11, 12, 68; Sch 1
Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW),s 12, 13, 13A, 21
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), ss 10, 11
Privacy Act 1988 (Cth)
Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW), ss 7, 37, 53, 55; Pt 5
Social Security (Administration) Act 1999 (Cth)
Cases Cited: AGU v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] NSWADT 179
Bass v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd [1999] HCA 9; 198 CLR 334
Botany Municipal Council v Federal Airports Authority [1992] HCA 52; 174 CLR 453
Bropho v State of Western Australia [1990] HCA 24; 171 CLR 1
Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) v Owens [No 2] [1953] HCA 62; 88 CLR 168
Commonwealth v Anti-Discrimination Tribunal (Tasmania) [2008] FCAFC 104
Commonwealth v State of Western Australia [1999] HCA 5; 196 CLR 392
Maguire v…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AGU v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWCA 473
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the application of New South Wales privacy legislation to the Commonwealth. The Australian Government Solicitor (AGS) sought to appeal a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had held that the Commonwealth was bound by certain provisions of the *Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002* (NSW) and the *Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998* (NSW). The central dispute revolved around whether these State Acts, by their terms, could bind the Commonwealth.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Commonwealth was bound by the operation of the *Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002* (NSW) and the *Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998* (NSW), and whether the Commonwealth could be subjected to the jurisdiction of a State tribunal under these Acts. This involved a consideration of the principles of statutory interpretation concerning the Crown's immunity from statute and the extent to which such immunity could be abrogated by State legislation.

The Court of Appeal affirmed the general presumption that statutes do not bind the Crown unless expressly stated or necessarily implied. However, it examined section 12 of the *Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002* (NSW), which states that the Act "binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and also, in so far as the legislative power of Parliament permits, the Crown in all its other capacities." The Court held that this provision, when read in its statutory context and considering the specific provisions of the privacy legislation, did not demonstrate a clear intention by the New South Wales Parliament to bind the Commonwealth in a manner that would override constitutional limitations on State legislative power. The Court concluded that the State Acts did not effectively bind the Commonwealth.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal to the extent necessary and dismissed the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) To the extent necessary, grant leave to appeal.

(2) Dismiss the appeal.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of AGU v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) concerns the interaction between State and Commonwealth legislation regarding privacy laws and their respective jurisdictions. The dispute arose from the operation of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) and the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW). The primary issue was whether the State Act could bind the Commonwealth and subject it to the jurisdiction of a State tribunal. The Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) includes a provision that it binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and, insofar as the legislative power of Parliament permits, the Crown in all its other capacities. This specific wording led to the contention about whether the State Act could extend its binding effect to the Commonwealth.

The factual events that gave rise to the legal dispute began when the Commonwealth was accused of contravening the privacy provisions under the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW). AGU, represented by certain individuals, sought to enforce these privacy provisions against the Commonwealth. The Commonwealth, in turn, argued that the State Act did not bind it and that it was not subject to the jurisdiction of a State tribunal in this matter. The Commonwealth relied on the principle that the Crown is not bound by statute unless there is a specific provision indicating such an intention. Consequently, the Commonwealth questioned whether the general wording of the State Act, which purported to bind the Crown in all its capacities, was sufficiently clear and specific to overcome the presumption that the Crown is not bound by statutes enacted by a State Parliament.

The proceedings before the court involved an appeal by the Commonwealth against an earlier decision that allowed the enforcement of the privacy provisions against it. The court was required to determine whether the State Act, through its general binding provision, effectively bound the Commonwealth and subjected it to the jurisdiction of a State tribunal. The case hinged on interpreting the specific wording of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) and assessing whether it indicated a clear intention to bind the Commonwealth in this context. The outcome of this interpretation was crucial in determining the scope of the State's legislative power and its applicability to the Commonwealth.

The matter of AGU v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) was initially heard in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, where the appellant, AGU, sought a declaration that the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW) applied to the Commonwealth in relation to the collection, use, and disclosure of health information. The Court held that the Act did not bind the Commonwealth. AGU subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which allowed the appeal, finding that the Act did indeed bind the Commonwealth in certain capacities. The Commonwealth then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia, which was granted, bringing the matter before this Court. The appeal concerns the interpretation of statutory provisions, particularly whether the phrase "binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and also, in so far as the legislative power of Parliament permits, the Crown in all its other capacities" in section 12 of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) is sufficient to bind the Commonwealth. The High Court will consider the relevant statutory context and the principles of statutory interpretation, including the presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute unless expressly stated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) bind the Commonwealth such that it is subject to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal?
2. Does the provision in the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) that states it binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and, to the extent permitted by the legislative power of Parliament, the Crown in all its other capacities indicate an intention to bind the Commonwealth?
3. Is the general presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute rebutted by specific provisions in the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW)?
4. How should the specific provisions of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) be interpreted in the context of the statute as a whole?
5. Are the Commonwealth's actions inconsistent with the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)?
6. Is the Commonwealth bound by the operation of the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)?
7. Does section 12 of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) have the effect of subjecting the Commonwealth to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal?

Held
1. Does the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) bind the Commonwealth such that it is subject to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal? The court concluded that the Act does not bind the Commonwealth, and thus the Commonwealth is not subject to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. Result: appeal dismissed on this issue.

2. Does the provision in the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) that states it binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and, to the extent permitted by the legislative power of Parliament, the Crown in all its other capacities indicate an intention to bind the Commonwealth? The court concluded that the specific wording does not indicate an intention to bind the Commonwealth. Result: appeal allowed on this issue.

3. Is the general presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute rebutted by specific provisions in the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW)? The court concluded that the general presumption is not rebutted by the specific provisions of the Act. Result: appeal dismissed on this issue.

4. How should the specific provisions of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) be interpreted in the context of the statute as a whole? The court concluded that the specific provisions must be read in the context of the statute as a whole, and they do not bind the Commonwealth. Result: appeal dismissed on this issue.

5. Are the Commonwealth's actions inconsistent with the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)? The court concluded that the Commonwealth's actions are not inconsistent with the State Act. Result: appeal dismissed on this issue.

6. Is the Commonwealth bound by the operation of the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)? The court concluded that the Commonwealth is not bound by the operation of the State Act. Result: appeal allowed on this issue.

7. Does section 12 of the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) have the effect of subjecting the Commonwealth to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal? The court concluded that section 12 does not have the effect of subjecting the Commonwealth to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. Result: appeal dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In AGU v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2), the court examined whether the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) (HRIPA) could bind the Commonwealth to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. The court considered the provision in section 12 of the HRIPA which states it binds the Crown in right of New South Wales and, to the extent permitted by the legislative power of Parliament, the Crown in all its other capacities. This raised the question of whether such language indicated an intention to bind the Commonwealth, despite the general presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute unless explicitly stated.

The court first addressed the issue of whether HRIPA could bind the Commonwealth such that it is subject to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. The reasoning commenced with the acknowledgement of the general principle that the Crown is not bound by statute unless the statute explicitly provides otherwise. The court examined section 12 of HRIPA, noting its broad language but ultimately finding that this did not suffice to rebut the presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute. The court held that the broad language did not demonstrate a clear intention to bind the Commonwealth, as it was subject to the legislative power of Parliament, which in turn is constrained by the Constitution.

Further, the court deliberated on whether the specific provisions of HRIPA indicated an intention to bind the Commonwealth. It was held that the phrase "to the extent permitted by the legislative power of Parliament" implied a limitation that aligns with the constitutional framework. The court noted that this limitation inherently restricts the application of HRIPA to the Commonwealth, as the Commonwealth’s legislative powers are defined by the Constitution. Therefore, the court concluded that the specific provisions of HRIPA could not extend to bind the Commonwealth without violating the separation of powers and the constitutional distribution of legislative authority.

The court also scrutinized whether the general presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute could be rebutted by specific provisions in HRIPA. The court reasoned that the explicit limitation in section 12 indicated a legislative intent to bind the Crown in right of New South Wales but not the Commonwealth unless permitted by constitutional and legislative constraints. Consequently, the court held that the specific provisions of HRIPA did not rebut the presumption sufficiently to bind the Commonwealth.

In interpreting the specific provisions of HRIPA in the context of the statute as a whole, the court emphasized the importance of reading the statute holistically. The broad language in section 12 was considered in light of the legislative intent and the constraints imposed by the Constitution. The court concluded that HRIPA was not intended to extend beyond the legislative power of New South Wales and did not encompass the Commonwealth.

Additionally, the court examined whether the Commonwealth's actions were inconsistent with the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW) (PPIPA). The court held that while HRIPA might apply to the Commonwealth to the extent permitted by law, PPIPA did not explicitly or implicitly bind the Commonwealth. Therefore, any inconsistency between Commonwealth actions and PPIPA did not result in the Commonwealth being subject to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal.

Finally, the court deliberated on whether section 12 of HRIPA had the effect of subjecting the Commonwealth to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. The court held that section 12, while broad in its language, did not overcome the constitutional constraints and the presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute. The court found that HRIPA did not, by its terms, extend to bind the Commonwealth or subject it to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. Therefore, the court dismissed the appeal, affirming that HRIPA did not have the effect of binding the Commonwealth in the manner suggested.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW) does not bind the Commonwealth such that it is subject to the jurisdiction of the State tribunal. The specific provisions of HRIPA, while broad, do not rebut the general presumption that the Crown is not bound by statute to the extent that it would bind the Commonwealth, given the constraints imposed by the Constitution and the legislative powers of the Commonwealth.