Agostino v Pham; Agostino v Phillpott

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
CITATION: AGOSTINO v PHAM; AGOSTINO v PHILLPOTT [2002] NSWCA 114
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40522/01; 40998/00
HEARING DATE(S): 10 April 2002
JUDGMENT DATE:
26 April 2002

PARTIES :


Elena Agostino
Tyet Mai Tran Pham
Jacob Phillpott
JUDGMENT OF: Sheller JA at 1; Heydon JA at 26; Foster AJA at 27
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION : District Court
LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :
DC 2034/99; DC 2035/99
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Gamble ADCJ
COUNSEL: S Norton SC/E E J Welsh - Appellant
J D Hislop QC/D J Russell - Respondent Phillpott
M J Neil QC/P J Gormly - Respondent Pham
SOLICITORS: L J Sharpe & Co - Appellant
Turner Whelan - Respondent Phillpott
Sparke Helmore - Respondent Pham
CATCHWORDS: MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accidents Act 1988 (NSW), s77, s79A - pre-existing condition - non-economic loss - failure by trial Judge to give proper reasons - appeal allowed - new trial ordered
LEGISLATION CITED: Motor Accidents Act 1988
Supreme Court Rules 1970
CASES CITED:
N/A
DECISION: 1. Appeals allowed; 2. Set aside the verdicts and judgments of Acting Judge Gamble of 29 November 2000; 3. Order that there be a new trial of both proceedings; 4. The respondents to pay the costs of this appeal; 5. The costs of the trial before Acting Judge Gamble be paid in accordance with the determination of the judge hearing the new trials.




                          CA 40522/01; CA 40998/00
                          DC 2034/99; DC 2035/99

                          SHELLER JA
                          HEYDON JA
                          FOSTER AJA

AGOSTINO v PHAM


AGOSTINO v PHILLPOTT

The appeals arose from a decision given by Acting Judge Gamble in the District Court in two sets of proceedings brought by the plaintiff to recover damages for injuries suffered in two separate motor vehicle accidents which occurred in 1997. The principal injury claimed was a lower back injury. The defendants contended that the pain suffered by the plaintiff was a manifestation of a lower back condition from which she had suffered from at least as early as 1995.

The trial Judge found in favour of the defendant in each action, holding that on the balance of probabilities the disabilities suffered by the appellant were not contributed to in any substantial way by the two motor vehicle accidents.

The central issue on appeal related to whether the trial Judge had erred in determining that the threshold requirements of the Motor Accidents Act 1988 (the Act) had not been satisfied. The plaintiff also argued that the trial Judge had erred in not awarding damages for economic loss and out of pocket expenses and for failing to give proper reasons for her decision.

Each defendant denied that the plaintiff's ability to lead a normal life had been significantly impaired for a continuous period exceeding 12 months, as was required by s79A(3) of the Act. Further, the defendant Philpott argued that the plaintiff's claim did not reach the threshold of 15 per cent for non-economic loss; s79A(4) of the Act.

HELD (per Sheller JA, Heydon JA and Foster AJA concurring)

1. A claim for non-economic loss involves…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Agostino v Pham; Agostino v Phillpott and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NSWCA 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceedings involved appeals by Agostino against the respondents, Pham and Phillpott, concerning claims for damages arising from motor accidents. The core of the dispute revolved around the assessment of non-economic loss, particularly in light of pre-existing conditions of the appellant. The appeals were heard by Sheller and Heydon JJA, and Foster AJA.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the trial judge, Acting Judge Gamble, had failed to provide adequate reasons for his findings regarding the appellant's pre-existing conditions and their impact on the assessment of non-economic loss. This failure, if established, would necessitate a review of the trial judge's verdicts and judgments.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge's reasons were insufficient to enable a proper understanding of how he had assessed the appellant's entitlement to damages for non-economic loss, especially in relation to the influence of pre-existing conditions. The court held that the reasons provided did not adequately explain the connection between the evidence presented and the conclusions reached concerning the appellant's injuries and their impact on his capacity to claim for non-economic loss under the *Motor Accidents Act 1988* (NSW). Consequently, the appeals were allowed, the previous verdicts and judgments were set aside, and a new trial was ordered for both proceedings. The respondents were ordered to pay the costs of the appeal, with the costs of the new trial to be determined by the judge presiding over those new trials.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeals allowed; 2. Set aside the verdicts and judgments of Acting Judge Gamble of 29 November 2000; 3. Order that there be a new trial of both proceedings; 4. The respondents to pay the costs of this appeal; 5. The costs of the trial before Acting Judge Gamble be paid in accordance with the determination of the judge hearing the new trials.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.