Agepati and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Agepati and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 5029 (29 November 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2019/1386

Re:Mr Raghunandana Agepati

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms Anna Burke AO, Member

Date:29 November 2019  

Place:Melbourne

The reviewable decision of the delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs made on           14 February 2019 to refuse Mr Agepati's application for Australian citizenship is affirmed.

...[sgd].....................................................................

Ms Anna Burke AO, Member

Catchwords

CITIZENSHIP - citizenship by conferral - refusal to approve application for citizenship - proceedings for an offence against Australian - adjourned undertakings - Tribunal must apply relevant law and circumstances in place at the time of review - decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)
Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic)

Cases
Omara and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 42
Lesi v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2015) 238 FCR 145
Oliver and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016] AATA 895

Mahmoud and Anor and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AATA 824

Secondary Materials

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Citizenship Policy (1 June 2016)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms Anna Burke, AO Member

29 November 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Agepati (the Applicant) is appealing against the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs, dated 4 February 2019, to refuse his application for Australian citizenship by conferral under section 24(6)(a) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007    (the Act). Mr Agepati was notified of this decision in writing on 14 February 2019.

  2. On 13 March 2019 Mr Agepati applied to the AAT for a review of the delegate’s decision, outlining why he considered the decision was wrong, stating:

    The case offer has not sent me a copy of the decision record but I feel that I have made the following error in my character declaration in my citizenship application

    Is the applicant aware of any proceedings pending against them from overseas or in Australia for an offence, including proceedings by way of appeal or review? No

    Has the applicant been convicted of, or found guilty of, any offences overseas or in Australia (include all traffic offences which went to court, including offences declared in your permanent residence application, and any spent convictions)? No

    I have answered no to the above questions but I had a pending intervention order which was given to me through an argument with my girlfriend. The intervention order was in place until the 30/4/2019. I misunderstood the question as I was not convicted for the offence and I believe I did not understand the question properly. I took advise from a migration agent to advise me that this could be the most possible reason for the decision. I would request AAT to request the Department of Home Affairs to get a copy of the decision record for refusal of my citizenship for me to have a look at the reasons why this decision was made.

  3. The hearing was held…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Agepati and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 5029
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by conferral by Mr Agepati, an Indian national. The Minister for Home Affairs had refused Mr Agepati's application, and he sought review of that decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The core of the dispute revolved around whether Mr Agepati was prevented from becoming a citizen due to being subject to an adjourned undertaking under section 75 of the *Sentencing Act 1991* (Vic) at the time of his application.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Minister's delegate was prohibited from approving Mr Agepati's citizenship application under section 24(6)(g) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007* (Cth) due to the existence of the adjourned undertaking. This section precludes the Minister from granting citizenship to a person who is subject to certain legal proceedings or undertakings. A further issue was whether the Tribunal had the power to postpone consideration of the application until after the expiry of the undertaking.

The Tribunal reasoned that section 24(6)(g) of the Act prohibits the Minister from approving citizenship while a person is subject to an adjourned undertaking with conditions relating to behaviour, even if no conviction has been recorded. The Tribunal noted that the existence of such undertakings had been consistently interpreted by previous decisions to fall within the scope of this prohibition. Furthermore, relying on the decision in *Lesi v Administrative Appeals Tribunal*, the Tribunal determined it did not have the power to postpone consideration of the application merely because the statutory bar would expire in the future.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse Mr Agepati's application for Australian citizenship. The Tribunal acknowledged the distress this decision might cause and encouraged Mr Agepati to reapply for citizenship after his undertaking expired on 2 December 2019, as nothing in the determination precluded him from making a further application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue in contention is whether Mr Agepati is prevented from becoming a citizen by conferral pursuant to section 24(6)(g) of the Act as he is currently subject to an adjourned undertaking pursuant to section 75 of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) until 2 December 2019.BACKGROUND Mr Agepati is a 28-year-old Indian National who first arrived in Australia on 1 November 2012 as the holder of a Temporary Student Visa (subclass 572) and subsequently on 17 January 2017 was granted a Permanent Skilled Independent Visa (subclass 189). On 24 January 2018 Mr Agepati applied for Australian citizenship by conferral. On 2 July 2018 Mr Agepati appeared before the Magistrates Court of Melbourne where he pleaded guilty to two charges of unlawful assault. The court without conviction adjourned the matter until 2 December 2019 with undertaking starting on 2 July 2018. The undertakings in force are that Mr Agepati:·must be of good behaviour during the time the undertaking is enforced;·must appear at court before the adjourned date if required by the court;·complete an accredited Men’s Behaviour Change program, providing confirmation of completion of the program by 30 March 2019; and·pay $1000 to the court fund. On 14 February 2019 Mr Agepati was notified that a delegate of the Minister refused his application for Australian citizenship by conferral, as the delegate was prohibited from approving the application under section 24(6)(a) of the Act, because Mr Agepati had outstanding proceedings for offences against an Australian law at the time of his application. On 26 July 2019 the Respondent on behalf the Minister requested the Tribunal dismiss the application in accordance with section 42B(1)(b) of the AAT Act as the application had no real prospects of success. At the same time, the Applicant sought an adjournment of the hearing and to have the matter listed after 3 December 2019, at the expiry of his adjourned undertaking. On 9 September 2019 the Tribunal refused the Respondent’s application to dismiss the matter and refused to grant an adjournment to Mr Agepati. The Tribunal provided oral reasons at the hearing indicating that the timing of the matter could very well determine Mr Agepati’s prospects of success, as conceded by the Respondent. The Respondent had contended that the prohibition in section 24(6)(g) may no longer apply after 2 December 2019. The Tribunal also determined it would not be reasonable in all the circumstances to grant an adjournment to allow for the expiry of the adjourned undertaking period, relying upon the decision of Besanko J in Lesi v Administrative Appeals Tribunal[1] where his Honour found:That means that the time periods within which applications will be determined will vary, but that is quite a different thing from the exercise of an express power to defer. I do not think the Minister has the power to postpone consideration of an application merely on the ground that a bar in paragraph 24(6)(g) will expire in the future.[1] (2015) 238 FCR 145.Relevant Legislation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 75 of the Victorian Sentencing Act provides for release on adjournment without conviction: (1) A court, on being satisfied that a person is guilty of an offence, may (without recording a conviction) adjourn the proceeding for a period of up to 60 months and release the offender on the offender giving an undertaking with conditions attached. (2) An undertaking under subsection (1) must have as conditions— (a) that the offender attends before the court if called on to do so during the period of the adjournment and, if the court so specifies, at the time to which the further hearing is adjourned; and (b) that the offender is of good behaviour during the period of the adjournment; and (c) that the offender observes any special conditions imposed by the court and may include a condition requiring the offender to make a payment to an organisation that provides a charitable or community service or to the court for payment to such an organisation. (3) Subject to Division 2 of Part 3BA, a court may attach a justice plan condition that the offender participate in the services specified in a justice plan for a period of up to 2 years specified by the court or the period of the adjournment, whichever is the shorter. (4) An offender who has given an undertaking under subsection (1) may be called on to attend before the court— (a) by order of the court; or (b) by notice issued by the proper officer of the court. (5) An order or notice under subsection (4) must be served on the offender not less than 4 days before the time specified in it for the attendance. (6) If at the time to which the further hearing of a proceeding is adjourned the court is satisfied that the offender has observed the conditions of the undertaking, it must dismiss the charge without any further hearing of the proceeding. EVIDENCE The following table has been derived from Mr Agepati’s records as outlined in an Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission report dated 12 January 2019: A Victorian police summary report from the LEAP database dated 25 April 2018 provides the following case progress narrative:The RESP and AFM have been in a de facto relationship for two years. Both of them have stated that this is the first instance of violence between them. Police were at Spice Market for an unrelated matter when S/C Gracie heard a gasp from the crowd and OBS the AFM on the ground and the RESP being restrained by security. Security advised he had pushed the AFM to the ground. AFM too drunk to give a statement at the time but was cooperative with police. Nil injuries and stated she is not in fear of him. The incident is captured on CCTV from a distance. Witness details obtained.AFM wanted to go out with her friends and RESP. However, at the venue AFM was nowhere to be found and left RESP with her other friends. RESP got frustrated and couldn’t find her in the venue and decided to leave. When he went to exit he located the AFM smoking with her ex-boyfriend. AFM approached RESP and attempted to hug him to explain, and he pushed her away, causing the AFM to fall to the ground. AFM has stated she is not in fear, but she doesn’t understand why she was pushed. She stated this is the first time he’s ever been violent, and there was no argument in the lead up so she was taken by surprise. AFM was very intoxicated. Both parties want to continue the relationshipRESP states he did not intend to hurt the AFM; merely to get away from her. He did not mean for her to fall to the ground; admits it looks bad but believes she fell due to her level of intoxication.RESP has been in Australia for over five years and is currently in the process of getting Australian citizenship.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is aware that this decision will cause considerable distress to Mr Agepati and his family. This decision should not be read as implying that Mr Agepati is not of good character. The Tribunal would encourage Mr Agepati to reapply for his citizenship at any time after 2 December 2019 as nothing in this determination precludes him from making a further application for citizenship by conferral.DECISION The reviewable decision of the delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs made 14 February 2019 to refuse Mr Agepati's application for Australian citizenship is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Agepati advised the Tribunal that the rejection of his citizenship had impacted him greatly, so much so that he was seeking psychological assistance through a work provided program. He believes he has missed out on promotions because of his lack of citizenship and he thinks he has been punished enough. Mr Agepati emphasised the whole situation was causing arguments between himself and his wife, that he had invested a lot of time, money and energy in the process, and stressed he was a person of good character.CONSIDERATION Mr Aviram contended that as Mr Agepati is subject to an adjourned undertaking with conditions relating to behaviour for a period of 17 months from 2 July 2018 to 2 December 2019, section 24(6)(g) of the Act prohibits the Minister from approving his citizenship at this time. Mr Aviram argued that if Mr Agepati breached the conditions of his adjourned undertaking he could be charged with a contravention, and if found guilty the court had the jurisdiction to resentence Mr Agepati. Mr Aviram drew the Tribunal’s attention to numerous cases where the Tribunal had accepted that good behaviour bonds and equivalent orders fell within the purview of section 24(6)(g) of the Act. In particular, referring to the matters of Oliver and Mahmoud:(a) where first Deputy President J W Constance stated:[2]Provided no further action is taken against Mr Oliver in accordance with the condition of the bond, it will expire on 20 November 2016. Until that time action can be taken against him and, in accordance with section 24 of the Citizenship Act, he must not be approved to become an Australian citizen.(b) and then Professor Ron McCallum AO, Member stated:[3]On 21 May 2014, a few days before the expiration of the good behaviour bond, a delegate of the Respondent decided not to grant the applicant citizenship by virtue of s 24(6)(g) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act). Put simply, s 24(6)(g) provides that the Respondent must not grant citizenship to a person while that person is under a good behaviour bond, even where no conviction has been recorded. In other words, the Applicant could not be granted citizenship until 27 May 2014, after the expiration of the good behaviour bond.[2] Oliver and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016] AATA 895.[3] Mahmoud and Anor and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AATA 824. Mr Aviram contended that the Tribunal did not have power to postpone consideration of the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship merely on the ground that a bar in section 24(6)(g) will expire in the near future, drawing the Tribunal’s attention to the determination of Besanko J in Lesi v Administrative Appeals Tribunal:As I understand it, there is no restriction under the Act on the applicant making another application for citizenship after January 2016. I think the removal of an express power to defer, albeit subject to a time limit, points in the opposite direction to that advanced by the applicant. In other words, it suggests to me that the Minister does not have power to defer consideration of an application. It is true that there is no time limit on the Minister’s consideration of the matter and the complexities in the administrative steps and the information gathering process will vary from case to case. That means that the time periods within which applications will be determined will vary, but that is quite a different thing from the exercise of an express power to defer. I do not think the Minister has the power to postpone consideration of an application merely on the ground that a bar in paragraph 24(6)(g) will expire in the future.