AG(CQ) P/L v A&T Promotions P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

AG(CQ) P/L v A&T Promotions P/L & Anor [2010] QCA 83

PARTIES:

AG(CQ) PTY LTD as trustee for the AG(CQ) FAMILY TRUST
ACN 121 034 893
(second defendant/appellant)
v
A&T PROMOTIONS PTY LTD as trustee for the TOOWOOMBA UNIT TRUST
ACN 103 910 854
(plaintiff/first respondent)
ALAN LESLIE IKIN as trustee for the MACKAY TRUST
(first defendant/second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 6217 of 2009
SC No 9586 of 2008

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

13 April 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

12 November 2009

JUDGES:

McMurdo P, Holmes JA and McMeekin J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made.

ORDERS:

1.    Appeal allowed

2.    Set aside orders 3, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the judgment below, substituting different declarations and orders in their place:

IT IS DECLARED THAT –

1. AG(CQ) Pty Ltd has an interest as equitable mortgagee in Lot 1 on SP 209449, in the County of Carlisle, Parish of Howard, being all of the Land contained in title reference 50753455 ("the Land");

2. A&T Promotions Pty Ltd has an interest as equitable mortgagee in the Land;

3. AG(CQ) Pty Ltd’s interest in the Land as equitable mortgagee takes priority over A&T Promotions’ interest in the Land.

AND IT IS ORDERED THAT –

4. Alan Leslie Ikin, whether by himself, his employees or his agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from dealing with the Land in a manner which is contrary to the interest of AG(CQ) Pty Ltd and/or A&T Promotions Pty Ltd set out in 1 to 3 above;

5. A&T Promotions Pty Ltd, whether by its officers, employees or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from dealing with the Land in a manner which is contrary to AG(CQ) Pty Ltd’s interest as declared at 1 and 3 above;

6. A&T Promotions Pty Ltd pay AG(CQ) Pty Ltd’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings at first instance and of this appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – UNREGISTERED INTERESTS – EQUITABLE ESTATES AND INTERESTS – PRIORITY BETWEEN EQUITABLE INTERESTS – GENERALLY – where second respondent held equitable title in a parcel of land – where the parcel of land was awaiting sub-division and was incapable of registration – where second respondent granted the first respondent an equitable mortgage in the land – where second respondent granted the appellant a separate later equitable mortgage over the same land – whether the rule of priority for the equitable interest first created is one of first or last resort – whether equitable interests of the first respondent and appellant equal – whether the first equity in time should triumph

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s 199

Abigail v Lapin (1934) 51 CLR 58; [1934] AC 491; UKPCHCA 1, considered
Barnes v James (1902) 27 VLR 749, considered
Butler v Fairclough (1917) 23 CLR 78; [1917] HCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AG(CQ) P/L v A&T Promotions P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QCA 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute between AG(CQ) P/L and A&T Promotions P/L regarding equitable interests in a parcel of land. The parcel of land was unregistered and awaiting subdivision, rendering it incapable of registration. The dispute centred around the priority of equitable mortgages held by the parties over the same parcel of land. The appellant, AG(CQ) P/L, claimed priority of its equitable mortgage over that of A&T Promotions P/L, the first respondent. The second respondent, who held the equitable title to the land, had granted both respondents separate equitable mortgages over the same land. The court was required to determine whether the rule of priority for the equitable interest first created was one of first or last resort and whether the equitable interests of the parties were equal.

The court considered the principles of equitable interests and the priority between them. It examined the nature of the equitable mortgages and whether the equitable interest of the party who first created the equitable mortgage should prevail. The court found that the equitable interests of AG(CQ) P/L and A&T Promotions P/L were equal and that the rule of priority for the equitable interest first created was one of first resort. This means that the first equitable interest in time should triumph. Consequently, AG(CQ) P/L’s equitable mortgage took priority over that of A&T Promotions P/L.

In light of its findings, the court allowed the appeal by AG(CQ) P/L. It set aside certain orders of the judgment below and substituted new declarations and orders in their place. The court declared that AG(CQ) P/L had an interest as an equitable mortgagee in the land and that its interest took priority over A&T Promotions P/L’s interest. The court also restrained Alan Leslie Ikin and A&T Promotions P/L from dealing with the land in a manner contrary to the interests of AG(CQ) P/L and A&T Promotions P/L. Finally, it ordered A&T Promotions P/L to pay AG(CQ) P/L’s costs of the proceedings at first instance and of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed

2. Set aside orders 3, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the judgment below, substituting different declarations and orders in their place:

IT IS DECLARED THAT –

1. AG(CQ) Pty Ltd has an interest as equitable mortgagee in Lot 1 on SP 209449, in the County of Carlisle, Parish of Howard, being all of the Land contained in title reference 50753455 ("the Land");

2. A&T Promotions Pty Ltd has an interest as equitable mortgagee in the Land;

3. AG(CQ) Pty Ltd’s interest in the Land as equitable mortgagee takes priority over A&T Promotions’ interest in the Land.

AND IT IS ORDERED THAT –

4. Alan Leslie Ikin, whether by himself, his employees or his agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from dealing with the Land in a manner which is contrary to the interest of AG(CQ) Pty Ltd and/or A&T Promotions Pty Ltd set out in 1 to 3 above;

5. A&T Promotions Pty Ltd, whether by its officers, employees or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from dealing with the Land in a manner which is contrary to AG(CQ) Pty Ltd’s interest as declared at 1 and 3 above;

6. A&T Promotions Pty Ltd pay AG(CQ) Pty Ltd’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings at first instance and of this appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

A&T Promotions Pty Ltd (A&T) held an equitable title to a parcel of land that was awaiting sub-division and was incapable of registration under the Torrens system. A&T granted an equitable mortgage to the first respondent, with the condition that if the first respondent did not pay an outstanding debt, the property would vest in them. Subsequently, A&T granted the appellant, AG(CQ) Pty Ltd, a later equitable mortgage over the same land. AG(CQ) initiated proceedings to determine the priority of its equitable interest over that of the first respondent. The primary judge found that the first respondent's equitable interest took priority over AG(CQ)’s, and AG(CQ) appealed this decision.

AG(CQ) Pty Ltd appealed the decision of the primary judge to the appellate court. The primary judge had determined the priority between the equitable interests of AG(CQ) and the first respondent in the parcel of land. The appeal was heard by the appellate court, which reviewed the findings and orders of the primary judge. The appeal involved questions about the rule of priority for equitable interests, whether the equitable interests were equal, and whether the first equity in time should prevail.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the rule of priority for the equitable interest first created in a situation where a parcel of land is awaiting sub-division and is incapable of registration under the Torrens system?
2. Are the equitable interests of AG(CQ) and the first respondent in the land equal?
3. Should the principle of 'first equity in time' prevail in determining the priority between the equitable interests?

Held
1. The court held that the rule of priority for the equitable interest first created in a situation where a parcel of land is awaiting sub-division and is incapable of registration under the Torrens system is not strictly one of first in time, but rather one of last resort.
2. The equitable interests of AG(CQ) and the first respondent in the land were not equal.
3. The principle of 'first equity in time' did not prevail in determining the priority between the equitable interests.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature of equitable interests and their priority when the land is awaiting sub-division and is not registered under the Torrens system. It found that the rule of priority for the equitable interest first created is not strictly one of first in time, but rather one of last resort. This means that the interest created first does not automatically take precedence over later interests. The court held that when determining the priority of equitable interests in such circumstances, the principle of 'first equity in time' should not necessarily prevail. Instead, the court considered the equities of the situation, including the conduct of the parties and the purpose of the equitable interests. In this case, the court found that AG(CQ) Pty Ltd's equitable interest took priority over the first respondent's interest, based on the equities of the situation. The court emphasised that the principle of 'first equity in time' is not an inflexible rule and that the equities of the case must be considered. The ratio of this case is that the priority of equitable interests in land awaiting sub-division and not registered under the Torrens system is not strictly determined by the order of creation, but rather by the equities of the situation. This decision departed from the strict application of the 'first equity in time' principle in certain circumstances.