Aei Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AEI Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No. 2) [2023] FCA 277  

File number(s): NSD 950 of 2022
Judgment of: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 28 March 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 30 March 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory application seeking orders for non-standard discovery – inspection of mobile phones – whether order is necessary or desirable – application granted for discovery of limited categories and delivery up and examination of mobile phones
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 14.01, 20.21, 23.01
Cases cited:

AEI Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin [2022] FCA 1384

Career Step, LLC v TalentMed Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 492

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 33
Date of hearing: 28 March 2023
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr S Prince SC with Mr A Davis
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Chamberlains
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr J Simpkins
Solicitor for the Defendant: Kennedys

ORDERS

NSD 950 of 2022
BETWEEN:

AEI INSURANCE GROUP PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND:

CRAIG MARTIN

Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

THAWLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 MARCH 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Discovery

1.The defendant provide discovery of the following categories of documents:

(a)Communications (whether by email, text, letter or otherwise) or records of any phone call on or after 1 August 2022 between the defendant and:

(i)any client of AEI (being those listed in Annexure A to these orders) (AEI Client);

(ii)any employee or agent of any AEI Client;

(iii)any insurer in respect to any policy of insurance held by any AEI Client; and

(iv)any repairer or insurer or other person in respect of any insurance claim made by any AEI Client.

(b)Emails to, from or copied to c.martin@mabrokers.com.au involving any AEI Client (including by their employees, servants or agent).

(c)Any phone record, itemised telephone call or SMS list in respect of mobile phone service [REDACTED] for the period 1 August 2022 to 24 February 2023.

(d)Any diary entry or other document, recording any meeting or communication between the defendant and any AEI Client from 1 August 2022.

2.Any further list of documents by the defendant is to be served by 4:00pm on 18 April 2023.

Delivery and Examination of Mobile Phone

3.The defendant deliver to the offices of the plaintiff’s solicitors in Sydney by 2:00pm on 28 March 2023 the Oppo AX5 Android Smartphone with International Mobile Equipment Identity number 862877040284760 (the AEI Mobile).

4.The defendant inform the plaintiff by 3:30pm on 28 March 2023 of any username and password for any messaging, storage or email system which the defendant has used at any time during the period 1 August 2022 to 24 February 2023 that was connected to, or accessed by, the AEI Mobile.

5.Counsel for the plaintiff and defendant confer, with a view to agreeing by 4:00pm on 28 March 2023 an independent court-appointed expert and orders necessary to give effect to the reasons given appointing an independent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aei Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Aei Insurance Group Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, sought discovery and inspection of mobile phones and related communications from Martin, the defendant, due to concerns over the potential misuse of sensitive information. The plaintiff's case centred on the alleged improper use of confidential data from their clients by the defendant, potentially facilitating fraudulent activities. The plaintiff argued that the inspection of the defendant's mobile phones and related communications was necessary to uncover evidence that could substantiate their claims. The defendant, on the other hand, contested the necessity of such an extensive inspection, arguing that it was overly broad and intrusive, potentially violating privacy rights.

The court was tasked with determining whether the requested discovery and inspection of the defendant's mobile phones were necessary or desirable in the context of the litigation. Specifically, the court had to assess the relevance and proportionality of the requested discovery, considering both the plaintiff's need for information and the defendant's right to privacy. The court also had to consider the balance of convenience, which weighed the potential harm to the parties if the orders were or were not made.

The court granted the plaintiff's application for non-standard discovery in part, allowing for the inspection of limited categories of documents and the delivery up and examination of specific mobile phones. The court found that the plaintiff had demonstrated a sufficient need for the information to substantiate their claims, and that the inspection was proportionate to the issues at hand. The court emphasised the importance of protecting privacy but recognised the necessity to ensure that sensitive information was not misused. The court also highlighted the importance of maintaining a balance between the parties' rights and the needs of the litigation.

The orders required the defendant to provide specific categories of documents and to deliver a particular mobile phone to the plaintiff's solicitors by specified dates. The defendant was also required to disclose any usernames and passwords related to the mobile phone. The court appointed an independent expert to assist with the inspection process, ensuring that the examination was conducted in a manner that respected privacy and was proportionate to the needs of the case. The defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs associated with the interlocutory application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Discovery

1. The defendant provide discovery of the following categories of documents:

(a) Communications (whether by email, text, letter or otherwise) or records of any phone call on or after 1 August 2022 between the defendant and:

(i) any client of AEI (being those listed in Annexure A to these orders) (AEI Client);

(ii) any employee or agent of any AEI Client;

(iii) any insurer in respect to any policy of insurance held by any AEI Client; and

(iv) any repairer or insurer or other person in respect of any insurance claim made by any AEI Client.

(b) Emails to, from or copied to c.martin@mabrokers.com.au involving any AEI Client (including by their employees, servants or agent).

(c) Any phone record, itemised telephone call or SMS list in respect of mobile phone service [REDACTED] for the period 1 August 2022 to 24 February 2023.

(d) Any diary entry or other document, recording any meeting or communication between the defendant and any AEI Client from 1 August 2022.

2. Any further list of documents by the defendant is to be served by 4:00pm on 18 April 2023.

Delivery and Examination of Mobile Phone

3. The defendant deliver to the offices of the plaintiff’s solicitors in Sydney by 2:00pm on 28 March 2023 the Oppo AX5 Android Smartphone with International Mobile Equipment Identity number 862877040284760 (the AEI Mobile).

4. The defendant inform the plaintiff by 3:30pm on 28 March 2023 of any username and password for any messaging, storage or email system which the defendant has used at any time during the period 1 August 2022 to 24 February 2023 that was connected to, or accessed by, the AEI Mobile.

5. Counsel for the plaintiff and defendant confer, with a view to agreeing by 4:00pm on 28 March 2023 an independent court-appointed expert and orders necessary to give effect to the reasons given appointing an independent expert.

6. The matter be listed at 4:00pm on 28 March 2023.

7. The phone number identified in Order 1(c) be supressed in these orders and the transcript available to the public, pursuant to section 37AF of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) on the grounds mentioned in section 37AG(1)(a) of that Act.

8. The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the interlocutory application filed on 10 March 2023.

9. Liberty to apply on three days’ notice.

10. The matter be listed at 4:30pm on 30 March 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

1. Freightshift Pty Ltd

2. Dellmex Pty Ltd trading as Barellan Freighters

3. Lawroad Pty Ltd

4. A. Mackay & Son Truckin Pty Ltd trading as Alastair Mackay Transport

5. Bondwoods Transport Pty Ltd

6. Boardman Sand & Gravel Pty Ltd

7. Wilton's Transport Pty Ltd

8. STA Trucking Pty Ltd

9. Quickwell Express Pty Ltd

10. AJ & KG Frederiksen Pty Ltd

11. G.M Kelly & W.G Kelly trading as WGH & GM Kelly

12. S And J McMahon Transport (Qld) Pty Ltd trading as S & J McMahon Transport

13. Eastwells Haulage Pty Ltd

14. Gerard F and Sandra Morgan trading as GF & S Morgan Transport

15. Johnnie Bundy Liquids Pty Ltd

16. JM Treeby Holdings Pty Ltd trading as JMT Transport

17. Hanicourt Transport Pty Ltd

18. Bill Humphries Transport Pty Ltd

19. JVB Transport Pty Ltd

20. KEDPH Pty Ltd

21. John Patrick Gonzo trading as Market Gate Logistics

22. Ricjul Pty Ltd

23. WSCK Iacono Pty Ltd

24. All Truck Towing Pty Ltd

25. Harvey's Towing (QLD) Pty Ltd

26. The trustee for M & S Payment Family Trust trading as Mick's Bulk Haulage

27. Danlyn (QLD) Pty Ltd

28. Rebecca Dargusch ATF Dargusch Family Trust and Keep on Truckin

29. Bonica Holdings Pty Ltd

30. Fast Freight Transport Pty Ltd

31. Redline Express Pty Ltd

32. Woodsbey Transport & Contracting Pty Ltd

33. Ozzy Concrete Qld Pty Ltd

34. Fielding Way Services Pty. Ltd.

35. KH Brown Linehaul Pty Ltd

36. HLE Logistics Pty Ltd

37. Sapar Landscaping Supplies Pty Ltd

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.