Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd v SA Police

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

ADVERTISER NEWSPAPERS PTY LTD v SA POLICE & ANOR

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Besanko

8 February 2006

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - IN GENERAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

Appeal against two orders made under Evidence Act 1929, s 69A – first, order suppressing publication of submissions made in proceedings under Domestic Violence Act 1994, s 4 – secondly, order refusing to revoke suppression order – public interest in publication of information related to court proceedings – consequential right of news media to publish such information – grounds for making suppression order – held, suppression order necessary to prevent undue hardship to witness to proceedings and her children – however, unclear whether terms of suppression order went further than warranted – appellant given opportunity to make further submissions in relation to terms of suppression order.

Evidence Act 1929 ss 69A, 69B; Domestic Violence Act 1994 s 4; Supreme Court Rules 1987 rr 97.17, 97.18, referred to.
Herald & Weekly Times Ltd v Director of Public Prosecutions (2003) 86 SASR 70; R v Lennon (1985) 38 SASR 356; G v The Queen (1984) 35 SASR 349; Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd v Draper (2004) 90 SASR 160; Cheatle & Sturdy v Davy (1989) 51 SASR 155; State of South Australia v Carter (1991) 161 LSJS 325, considered.

ADVERTISER NEWSPAPERS PTY LTD v SA POLICE & ANOR
[2006] SASC 36

Magistrates Appeal

  1. BESANKO J: This is an appeal against two orders made under s 69A of the Evidence Act 1929 (“the Evidence Act”). The first order was a suppression order made on 14 November 2005 and the second order was an order made on 21 November 2005 refusing to revoke the suppression order. The appeal is brought pursuant to s 69A(8) of the Evidence Act 1929. 

  2. The appellant is The Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd (“The Advertiser”).  The proceedings in which the order was made were proceedings in the Magistrates Court between South Australia Police (“the Police”) and Mr Mark John Stevens.  The Police and Mr Stevens were named as respondents to the appeal.  The Police appeared on the hearing of the appeal and opposed the orders sought by The Advertiser.  Mr Stevens indicated to the Court that he did not contest the appeal and he did not appear on the hearing of the appeal.

    The proceedings in the Magistrates Court

  3. The proceedings were proceedings for a domestic violence restraining order and they were brought by the Police against Mr Stevens under s 4 of the Domestic Violence Act 1994 (“the Domestic Violence Act”).  The complaint which commenced the proceedings was dated 14 November 2005 and the protected person named in the complaint was Mr Stevens’ wife, Lisa Marie Stevens.  The order was sought for the benefit of Ms Stevens and her three young children, who are also the children of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd v SA Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd initiated an appeal against two orders made by the Magistrates Court under the Evidence Act 1929, section 69A. The first order suppressed the publication of submissions made during proceedings under the Domestic Violence Act 1994, section 4. The second order refused to revoke the suppression order. The primary issue was the public interest in publishing information related to court proceedings, particularly in relation to a domestic violence case. The consequential right of the news media to publish such information was also considered. The court was tasked with determining whether the suppression order was necessary to prevent undue hardship to the witness and her children, and if the terms of the suppression order went further than was warranted.

The court found that the suppression order was necessary to prevent undue hardship to the witness and her children. However, it was unclear whether the terms of the suppression order went further than was warranted. The absence of reasons or a transcript of the hearing on 14 November 2005 made it difficult to ascertain the exact scope of the order. The court decided to give Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd an opportunity to present evidence of the submissions made on 14 November 2005. If the appellant chose to do so, the parties would be given the opportunity to make further submissions in relation to the terms of the suppression order.

The court adjourned the appeal to allow the parties to consider the reasons provided. The decision emphasised the importance of balancing the public interest in the publication of court proceedings with the need to protect the privacy and safety of witnesses, particularly in sensitive cases such as domestic violence. The court’s approach highlighted the need for clear and justifiable reasons when imposing suppression orders and the necessity of considering the proportionality of such orders in relation to the specific circumstances of the case.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd v SA Police concerns an appeal against two orders made under the Evidence Act 1929, Section 69A, which pertain to the suppression of publications related to proceedings under the Domestic Violence Act 1994, Section 4. The initial order suppressed the publication of submissions made in the domestic violence proceedings, and a subsequent order refused to revoke the suppression order. The central issue revolves around the public interest in the publication of information related to court proceedings and the consequential right of the news media to publish such information.

The factual events leading to this legal dispute began when The Advertiser, a newspaper, sought to publish submissions made in the domestic violence proceedings. These submissions were made under the Domestic Violence Act, which allows for the protection of witnesses and their children. The respondents, SA Police, sought a suppression order under the Evidence Act to prevent the publication of these submissions, citing the potential undue hardship to the witness and her children. The primary consideration in granting such an order is to protect the well-being of the individuals involved.

On 14 November 2005, the initial suppression order was made without a transcript or reasons provided, leading to the appellant's contention that the order might have been broader than necessary. The court acknowledged the necessity of the suppression order to prevent undue hardship to the witness and her children but also recognised the possibility that the order might have extended beyond what was warranted. Consequently, the court decided to give The Advertiser an opportunity to present evidence of the submissions made on 14 November 2005. If The Advertiser chooses to proceed, the court will allow the parties to make further submissions regarding the terms of the suppression order.

The Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd sought to challenge two orders made under the Evidence Act 1929, s 69A in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The first order suppressed the publication of submissions made in proceedings under the Domestic Violence Act 1994, s 4, and the second order refused to revoke the suppression order. The matter came before the Supreme Court on appeal against the decisions made by the Magistrates Court. The appellant, Advertiser Newspapers, argued for the public interest in the publication of information related to court proceedings and contended for a consequential right to publish such information. The appeal before the Supreme Court centred on the necessity and scope of the suppression order, particularly whether it went beyond what was warranted to prevent undue hardship to the witness and her children. The court recognised the importance of balancing the rights of the media with the welfare of individuals involved in the proceedings.

During the proceedings, it was noted that the appeal was difficult to assess due to the absence of reasons or a transcript from the hearing on 14 November 2005. Consequently, the court found it unclear whether the terms of the suppression order were justified or had exceeded what was necessary. To address this uncertainty, the Supreme Court gave the appellant an opportunity to present evidence of the submissions made on 14 November 2005. If the appellant chose to proceed with this, the court would allow further submissions from the parties regarding the terms of the suppression order. The Supreme Court ultimately decided to adjourn the appeal to allow the parties to consider the court's reasons and potentially make further submissions. This procedural step was taken to ensure that the suppression order was appropriately tailored and justified under the circumstances.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The difficulty in this case is that, in the absence of reasons or a transcript of the hearing on 14 November 2005, it is unclear whether the order actually made goes further than is warranted. I will give The Advertiser the opportunity of putting forward evidence of the submissions made on 14 November 2005. If it chooses to do so, I will give the parties the opportunity, consistent with these reasons, to make further submissions in relation to the terms of the suppression order.Conclusion I will adjourn the appeal so that the parties may consider these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Advertiser Newspapers Pty Ltd v SA Police, the court addressed several critical issues concerning suppression orders under s 69A of the Evidence Act 1929, particularly focusing on the necessity of such orders to prevent undue hardship to witnesses and their children. The court started by considering whether the suppression order was necessary to prevent undue hardship to the witness and her children. The court found that such an order was indeed necessary to protect the witness and her children from potential harm. However, the court was cautious to note that it was unclear whether the terms of the suppression order went further than warranted by the need to prevent such hardship. The court emphasized that the protection of the witness and her children was paramount, but the order should not be more extensive than necessary.

Turning to the public interest in the publication of information related to court proceedings, the court balanced this against the need to protect the witness and her children from undue hardship. The court acknowledged the public's right to be informed about court proceedings but held that in this case, the necessity to protect the witness and her children from potential harm outweighed the public interest in publication. This decision underscored the principle that while transparency in court proceedings is important, the welfare and safety of individuals involved in the proceedings can take precedence under certain circumstances.

The court then examined the appropriate grounds for making a suppression order under s 69A of the Evidence Act 1929. It reiterated that such orders should be made when necessary to prevent undue hardship to a witness or their family. The court's reasoning here was rooted in statutory interpretation and the legislative intent behind s 69A, which aims to protect individuals from harm while balancing this with the public interest in open justice. The court did not elaborate extensively on the authorities it relied on, but its interpretation aligned with established principles in Australian law concerning the protection of witnesses and their families.

Regarding the consequential right of the news media to publish information related to court proceedings, the court clarified that such a right is not absolute and can be constrained when necessary to prevent undue hardship to a witness and their children. The court did not find that the news media had an unqualified right to publish information in this case, given the potential harm to the witness and her children. This decision highlighted the limited scope of the media's right to publish when it conflicts with the protection of individuals involved in court proceedings.

The court also considered the scope of any consequential right the news media might have to publish information related to court proceedings. It held that while there is a right to publish, it is not without limitations, particularly when the publication could cause undue hardship to a witness and their children. The court's approach here was to balance the right to information with the need to protect individuals from harm, reaffirming that the protection of witnesses and their families can justify restrictions on publication.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while suppression orders under s 69A of the Evidence Act 1929 are necessary to prevent undue hardship to witnesses and their children, such orders should be carefully tailored to avoid going further than necessary. The court also established that the public interest in publication is not absolute and can be outweighed by the need to protect individuals from harm. Additionally, the consequential right of the news media to publish information related to court proceedings is limited when such publication could cause undue hardship to a witness and their children. This decision reinforces the balance between the principles of open justice and the protection of individuals involved in court proceedings.