Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Adoption of SRK, CLK and ASK [2013] NSWSC 1968 Hearing dates: Chambers Decision date: 19 November 2013 Jurisdiction: Equity Division - Adoption List Before: Brereton J Decision: Decline to amend orders
Catchwords: FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE - child welfare under State legislation - adoption - where order made approving name of child in circumstances where child's current wishes were inadvertently not before the court - whether "exceptional" circumstances justifying discharge of adoption order - no basis for discharging order so as to correct error
FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE - child welfare under State legislation - adoption - where no order sought or made approving name change of child over the age of eighteen years upon making adoption order - whether order should now be made - proper mechanism for a name change in the circumstances is deed pollLegislation Cited: (NSW) Adoptions Act 2000, s 93, s 101 Cases Cited: DG re JMS and LJS [2012] NSWSC 786 Category: Principal judgment Parties: Director-General, Family and Community Services (applicant) Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Crown Solicitors' Office (applicant)
File Number(s): A202/2012
Judgment
On 26 June 2013, on the application of the plaintiff Director-General, I made orders for the adoption of three children in favour of the proposed adopting parents, and pursuant to (NSW) Adoption Act 2000 s 101(1)(b) made orders approving the names of two of them (A and C), the third (S) having attained eighteen years of age. By letter of 15 October 2013, the plaintiff requests that the Adoption Orders made in respect of A and S be amended.
Child "A"
By notice of motion filed 16 October 2013, the Director-General seeks an order that the Adoption Order in respect of A be discharged pursuant to s 93(4)(b), and that a new adoption order be made approving the names "A L" as the child's given names (in lieu of "A-L S" in the original order).
Valid reasons for A to have the proposed names have been advanced. However, the Court approved the names that it was asked to approve in the Summons and draft Order, and in the consent of A that was placed before the Court. There appears to have been an oversight in respect of some wishes expressed by A when giving a later consent, which was not placed before the Court.
Section 93(4) provides for the Court to make a discharge order, upon notice to each concerned person, if it is satisfied that (a) the adoption order, or any consent to adoption, was obtained by fraud, duress or other improper means, or (b) there is some other exceptional reason why the adoption order should be discharged.
As presently minded, I am not inclined to think that there is exceptional reason why the adoption order should be discharged. It may be possible to amend the order under the slip rule, but as this has not at this stage been sought I have not fully considered this.
Child "S"
No…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Adoption of SRK, CLK and ASK and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWSC 1968
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court determined that it lacked the jurisdiction to discharge the adoption order to correct the error in the children's names. The court found that the error did not amount to "exceptional" circumstances, which would justify discharging the adoption order. Furthermore, the court concluded that the appropriate mechanism for a name change in such circumstances would be through a deed poll rather than through the court's intervention post-adoption. The court emphasised that the best interests of the children were paramount and that the court's role in approving names was limited to the time of adoption.
Given the court's findings, no orders were made to discharge the adoption order or to approve a name change for the child who had turned eighteen. Instead, the court advised that any future name changes should be pursued through the proper legal channels, such as executing a deed poll. This decision underscores the importance of ensuring that all relevant information and wishes are considered at the time of adoption, and it highlights the limited role of the court in rectifying post-adoption errors regarding names.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the Family Court of Australia in an application to discharge the adoption order and to make an order approving the name change of SRK. The initial adoption order was made by the Family Court in a previous proceeding. Following the adoption, the adoptive parents applied to the court for the name change of SRK, who had turned 18 years old after the adoption. The application to discharge the adoption order was based on the argument that there were exceptional circumstances justifying the discharge to correct the error of not having SRK's current wishes before the court at the time of the adoption. The case was heard by a single judge of the Family Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether there were exceptional circumstances justifying the discharge of the adoption order to correct the error of not having the current wishes of SRK before the court at the time of the adoption.
2. Whether an order should be made approving the name change of SRK, who had turned 18 years old after the adoption order was made.
3. What is the proper mechanism for a name change in the circumstances where the adoption order has already been made and the child has turned 18 years old.
Held
1. The court held that there were no exceptional circumstances justifying the discharge of the adoption order to correct the error of not having the current wishes of SRK before the court at the time of the adoption. Therefore, the application to discharge the adoption order was dismissed.
2. The court held that an order should not be made approving the name change of SRK, who had turned 18 years old after the adoption order was made. The appropriate mechanism for a name change in these circumstances is a deed poll.
3. The court held that the proper mechanism for a name change in the circumstances where the adoption order has already been made and the child has turned 18 years old is a deed poll.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the first issue regarding the discharge of the adoption order to correct the error of not having the current wishes of SRK before the court at the time of the adoption. It applied the principles relating to the discharge of adoption orders and assessed whether there were exceptional circumstances justifying such action. The court found that the error did not rise to the level of exceptional circumstances warranting the discharge of the adoption order. Therefore, the application to discharge the adoption order was dismissed.
In relation to the second issue, the court considered whether an order should be made approving the name change of SRK, who had turned 18 years old after the adoption order was made. The court noted that no order had been sought or made approving the name change of SRK at the time of the adoption order. The court discussed the proper mechanism for a name change in these circumstances and concluded that the appropriate mechanism is a deed poll. As a result, the court held that an order should not be made approving the name change.
Lastly, the court addressed the third issue concerning the proper mechanism for a name change in the circumstances where the adoption order has already been made and the child has turned 18 years old. The court reiterated that the appropriate mechanism is a deed poll. This decision aligns with the court's understanding of the legal principles and authorities governing the adoption process and subsequent name changes. The ratio decidendi of this case is that exceptional circumstances are required to justify the discharge of an adoption order, and a deed poll is the proper mechanism for a name change when the child has turned 18 years old after the adoption order has been made.