Adiprodjo and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 1163

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2000/426

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      SWEE PENG ADIPRODJO         
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr J D Campbell, Member 

Date21 December 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal determines that: (a) the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to consider an application for an extension of time in relation to the claim of 9 October 1995 (the first claim); and  (b) the Tribunal does not grant an extension of time for the Applicant to make an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of the second claim for compensation dated 7 December 1998; and (c) in the event that jurisdiction was found to exist in relation to the claim of 9 October 1995, the Tribunal would not grant an extension of time for the Applicant to make an application to the Administrative Tribunal for review of the first claim for compensation dated 9 October 1995.          

…………………………

Dr J D Campbell
  Member
CATCHWORDS
WORKERS COMPENSATION – procedural matters – reviewable decisions – issue of reconsideration – history of reviewable decisions – extension of time – reasons for request – matters to be considered in relation to each of the claims – definition of remaining claim

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 38, 60, 62, 65
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, sections 25, 29

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen, Minister for Home Affairs & the Environment (1984) 7 ALD 315
Gallo v Dawson (1990) 93 ALR 479
Re Cao and Australian Postal Corporation [1999] AATA 995
Comcare v Willems (1996) 76 FCR 244

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr J D Campbell, Member

  1. Ms Swee Peng Adiprodjo ("the Applicant") in this matter seeks an extension of time in order that an appeal can be lodged with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") in relation to two claims for compensation lodged with the Australian Postal Corporation ("the Respondent") on 9 October 1995 and 7 December 1998.

  2. The issue of seeking an extension of time for these two claims arose from the lodgement of a further claim for compensation by the Applicant with the Respondent on 25 January 2000 which, it is argued by the Respondent, incorporated the issues of the earlier two claims and which is properly before the Tribunal, having been the subject of a denial of liability on 7 February 2000, a reconsideration on 1 March 2000 and an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 20 March 2000.

  3. A hearing was held before the Tribunal on 11 August 2000, at which the Applicant was represented by Mr Hassett, a solicitor of Hassett, Dixon Solicitors.  The Applicant presented oral evidence to the Tribunal.  The Respondent was represented by Mr Elliot of Counsel, instructed by Mr Hanger of Blake, Dawson, Waldron Solicitors.

  4. The following written material was placed in evidence before the Tribunal:
    Documents prepared pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 T1-T33 pp1-350

Issues

  1. The relevant issues before the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adiprodjo and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 1163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Adiprodjo and the Australian Postal Corporation was before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to consider an application for an extension of time to appeal the decisions of the Australian Postal Corporation in relation to three separate claims for workers' compensation. The Applicant, Adiprodjo, sought an extension of time to appeal the decisions of the Respondent, the Australian Postal Corporation, which had declined to accept liability for the Applicant's claims. The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether an extension of time should be granted for the appeals and whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the earlier two claims.

The Tribunal considered whether the Respondent's refusal to reconsider the earlier two claims was a reviewable decision under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. It also examined the relevant provisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and relevant case law, such as Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen and Gallo v Dawson. The Tribunal found that the decision to refuse reconsideration was a reviewable decision as it had the potential to affect the Applicant's rights and obligations under the Act.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal noted that the Applicant had not made a formal request for reconsideration within the required time frame and had indicated that she would not pursue the earlier two claims for personal reasons. The Tribunal held that the Applicant's failure to make a timely request for reconsideration, coupled with her decision not to pursue the earlier claims, meant that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to review these claims. The Tribunal further found that the Applicant's claim for post-traumatic stress disorder was not supported by the evidence and was unrelated to her compensable condition.

The Tribunal concluded that an extension of time should not be granted as the Applicant had not demonstrated sufficient grounds for the extension. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had not acted with due diligence in pursuing her claims and that the exercise of the Tribunal's discretion to grant an extension of time would not be reasonable in all the circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 7 February 2000 the Respondent declined liability under s.14 of the Act for any of the conditions nominated, and in particular stated that the first and second listed injuries had been the subject of earlier compensation claims and had been comprehensively dealt with (T128). Following a request for reconsideration from the Applicant's solicitors on 9 February 2000, the Respondent, following a review of all the evidence, advised the Applicant in a letter dated 1 March 2000 that the decision of the delegate of the Respondent of 7 February 2000 was affirmed (T131). On 20 March 2000 the Applicant made an application for review of this decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (T1).Applicant's evidence The Applicant described to the Tribunal the circumstances and symptomatology of the three episodes that have led to both her current claim for compensation and her earlier two claims. These were described to the Tribunal in the following terms: The Applicant submitted that the latest claim is a fair and responsible summation of the injuries that have been suffered and that the earlier two claims were simply to do with early manifestations of the injuries, which over time have widened and deepened in all respects. It was further submitted that there has been no external review of these extensive injuries which have been suffered and have been worsening since 1995. It was the Applicant's submission that the Tribunal grant the request for an extension of time to appeal the earlier two decisions, which in essence will bring all matters before it at a hearing. This in the Applicant's submission is the appropriate course of action in view of the difficulties that will arise in dealing with the issues raised only in part. The Applicant submits that it is necessary to define the ambit of the first two claims, as well as any consideration of any further aggravation since 1998. It was further contended that there are substantial issues involved, including substantial compensation if the Applicant is successful. It was further submitted that recognition of the inherent characteristics of the Applicant in terms of her ethnicity and relative educational achievements should be considered by the Tribunal.Submissions: The Respondent Counsel for the Respondent submitted that the first two compensation claims have been dealt with appropriately and that any extension of time should not be granted. In relation to the first claim of October 1995 Counsel submitted that there has been no reconsideration and therefore the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction in this matter. Counsel further submitted that even if the Tribunal deemed that a reconsideration had occurred, the Tribunal, in weighing the various factors which should be considered when exercising the discretion to grant an extension of time, should conclude that the exercise of such a discretion would not be reasonable in all the circumstances. Counsel similarly submitted that in relation to the second claim for compensation of December 1998, an extension of time should not be granted in the light of such factors as the Applicant not wishing to make an appeal within time, by the nature of the claim, the likelihood of success of the claim, the history of proceedings and the conduct of the parties. In this regard Counsel referred to earlier cases which have considered such issues, namely Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen, Minister for Home Affairs and the Environment (1984) 7 ALD 315 and Gallo vDawson (1990) 93 ALR 479.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to the third claim Counsel submitted that the first two elements clearly related to the earlier claims, which in his submission had been dealt with and finalised. In relation to the post traumatic stress disorder element of the claim, Counsel submitted that there was clearly no evidence contained within the evidentiary documents to support such a clinical diagnosis. In Counsel's view, the evidence of the Applicant appears to relate to complaints by the Applicant of unfair treatment by two managers in the work place and that such treatment is alleged to have caused the Applicant symptoms of stress, anxiety and depression.Consideration and findings In this matter the issues were thoroughly canvassed between the parties and each party was made aware of the other's position and their arguments as to how they justified adopting the position they postulated. The Tribunal, having considered the matters put before it and the evidence of the Applicant, makes the following findings of fact in relation to the claim for compensation dated 9 October 1995:1. the claim related to repetitive strain injury causing pain to neck, shoulder, arm, wrist and finger (right and left);2. the injury claimed related to a period commencing 4 July 1995 when the Applicant experienced pain in her fingers, wrist, arm, shoulder and neck which gradually increased over time to involve both shoulders and elbows and the lower back;3. liability for the injury in the Respondent's letter of 12 February 1996 was ceased on and from 18 November 1995;4. the Applicant was advised by the Respondent on 12 February 1996 to make a separate claim if stress was attributable to other causes in the work environment, eg personality differences at work;5. the Applicant was further advised on 12 February 1996 by the Respondent that there was no liability for the stress condition as it was not related to the Applicant's compensible condition;6. the Applicant was legally represented from at least late February 1996 and continued to do so for the period in which this claim was in process;7. an extension of time was granted to the Applicant's solicitors in early March 1996 and for the next 18 months there was an exchange of correspondence between the parties, with the Applicant's solicitors always indicating that a request for reconsideration would be made when the necessary medical reports were to hand;8. the Applicant did make a personal request for reconsideration to the Respondent on 22 November 1996, with the Respondent again speaking with the Applicant's solicitor, who again advised that the necessary papers would soon be ready;9. a formal request for a reconsideration of the decision of 12 February 1996 was never made by the Applicant's solicitors and the Respondent's letter of 29 August 1997 clearly indicated to the Applicant's solicitors that the claim would not be further considered because of the Applicant's failure to provide final documentation, and that reconsideration of the decision would only occur if such documentation is received and/or that there is a written request for a reconsideration; and10. the Applicant decided that for a number of personal reasons, she would not further pursue this claim.