Adelaide Steamship Company Limited v R (Cth)

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read
15 CLR 65

THE ADELAIDE STEAMSHIP COMPANY

APPELLANTS;

LIMITED AND OTHERS DEFENDANTS,

HIS MAJESTY THE KING AND THE

ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF THE

RESPONDENTS. COMMONWEALTH PLAINTIFFS,

ON APPEAL FROM A JUSTICE OF THE HIGH COURT. Trusts and combines-Combination or agreement in restraint of trade-Monopoly

-Intent to cause detriment to the public-Combination to raise prices-Onus of proof a8 to intent - Australian Industries Preservation Act 1906-1909 (No. 9 of 1906-No. 26 of 1909), secs. 4, 7, 15A.

In order to establish an offence under sec. 4 (1) (a) or sec. 7 of the Australian Industries Preservation Act 1906 there must be proved, not only an intent to restrain trade or commerce or an intent to monopolize some part of the trade or commerce with other countries or among the States, but also 16, 17, 20. an intent to cause detriment to the public.

The term "the public" in those sections is not limited to the consumers of any particular commodity, but includes also the producers of that commodity.

An agreement in restraint of trade is not necessarily detrimental to the public within the meaning of the Act, and,

The intent contemplated by those sections to cause detriment to the public is a real intention and not a mere constructive intention imputed from an intent to restrain or monopolize trade.

A mere combination of the producers of a commodity with the intention of raising the price of that commodity is not necessarily detrimental to the public.

15 CLR 66

In sec. 15A of the Australian Industries Preservation Act 1906-1909, which provides that the averments of the prosecutor contained in the information, declaration or claim shall be deemed to be proved in the absence of proof to the contrary, but SO that the averment of intent shall not be deemed suffi. cient to prove such intent, the word "averments" is confined to pure allega- tions of fact and does not extend to conclusions of mixed law and fact.

The question whether a price fixed is unreasonable for the purpose of an inquiry whether an agreement or combination is made or entered into with intent to cause detriment to the public is a mixed question of law and

That section has no application when the prosecutor elects to put the actual Quare, whether that section is invalid as being an attempted interference with the judicial power of the Commonwealth by seeking to impose upon Courts the duty of passing sentence without trial.

The proprietors of the majority of the coal mines in a mining district in New South Wales, believing that the prosperity of the district and their own individual interests were in danger by reason of excessive competition and the unremunerative prices obtained by them for coal, entered into an agreement substantially to restrict the output of their mines and to raise and fix the price of coal sold by them. In order to further this agreement the proprietors then entered into an agreement with a number of shipowners who did the bulk of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adelaide Steamship Company Limited v R (Cth) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1912] HCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Adelaide Steamship Company Limited v R (Cth)* involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of Isaacs J. The appeal concerned charges brought against the Adelaide Steamship Company Limited and other shipping companies, along with coal mine proprietors, under sections 4 and 7 of the *Australian Industries Preservation Act 1906-1909*. The core of the dispute revolved around an agreement between coal proprietors and shipowners that aimed to restrict coal output and fix prices, and whether this arrangement constituted an offence under the Act.

The legal issues before the High Court were primarily the interpretation of sections 4 and 7 of the *Australian Industries Preservation Act 1906-1909*. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether an intent to restrain trade or commerce, or to monopolise, was sufficient for an offence under these sections, or if an additional intent to cause detriment to the public was a necessary element. The Court also considered the meaning of "the public" in this context and whether an agreement in restraint of trade was automatically considered detrimental to the public. Furthermore, the applicability and validity of section 15A of the Act, concerning averments by the prosecutor, were in question.

The High Court reasoned that for an offence under section 4(1)(a) or section 7 of the Act, proof of an intent to restrain trade or commerce, or to monopolise, was insufficient on its own. It was essential to also prove a distinct intent to cause detriment to the public. The Court clarified that "the public" was not limited to consumers but encompassed producers as well. It rejected the argument that all agreements in restraint of trade were inherently detrimental to the public, noting that modern legal and legislative trends recognised that such agreements could sometimes be beneficial or neutral, and that the interests of producers and workers, alongside consumers, must be considered. The Court found that the intent contemplated by the Act must be a real, actual intention, not a constructive one imputed by law. Applying these principles to the facts, the Court held that the agreement between the proprietors and shipowners was not, on its face, made with the intent to restrain trade to the detriment of the public or to monopolise inter-State trade. Moreover, the Court found that no actual detriment to the public had been proven, and therefore, no intent to cause such detriment could be inferred. Consequently, the decision of Isaacs J. was reversed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established