Adelaide Hills Council v Gibson

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

ADELAIDE HILLS COUNCIL v GIBSON

[2006] SASC 181

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Sulan, The Honourable Justice Anderson and The Honourable Justice Layton)

23 June 2006

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY - GENERALLY - CONSIDERATION OF PLANNING SCHEMES

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - CONSENTS, APPROVALS AND PERMITS - INTERPRETATION AND CONSTRUCTION - GENERALLY

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - IN GENERAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT

Appeal against decision of Judge of the Land and Valuation Division of the Supreme Court - development application to divide land into two equal sized residential allotments - further application to erect a single dwelling on each allotment - both applications refused by Council - respondent appealed to Environment, Resources and Development Court - Commissioner upheld Council's decisions - respondent appealed to a single Judge of the Supreme Court - decision reversed - development approval granted - whether Judge erred in proper interpretation and application of Development Plan - whether proposal was for "low density" residential development - whether development was in keeping with "village character" of township - discussion of relevant locality - role of precedent in planning decisions generally - whether appellate court should interfere with decision of an expert tribunal - appeal allowed - decision of Council restored.

Development Act (SA) 1993  ; Adelaide Hills Council Development Plan 2005  , referred to.
Nadebaum v City of Mitcham [1995] EDLR 587; City of Charles Sturt v Hatch [1999] EDLR 485; Ampol Road Pantry Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Brighton (1993) 62 SASR 165, applied.
City of Charles Sturt v Hatch [1999] SASC 523, considered.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"Low density residential development", "Village character"

ADELAIDE HILLS COUNCIL v GIBSON
[2006] SASC 181

Full Court: Sulan, Anderson & Layton JJ

  1. SULAN J: I agree with the reasons of Anderson J.  I would allow the appeal and order that the decision of the Council to refuse the applications be restored.

    ANDERSON J:

    Background

  2. The appellant in this matter, Adelaide Hills Council (“the Council”), appeals from a decision of a Judge of this Court who allowed an appeal from a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources & Development Court of South Australia (“the ERD Court”) relating to a proposed development at Oakbank.

  3. The land which is the subject of the appeal is situated at 13 Elizabeth Street, Oakbank, and is vacant land except for one shed which is erected on the land.  The proposals before the Council for the development were two-fold.  An application was made under the Development Act (SA) 1993 seeking provisional development plan and land division consent for the creation of two allotments on the existing land.  That was called proposal ‘A’.  At the same time there was also an application for a provisional development plan consent for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adelaide Hills Council v Gibson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Adelaide Hills Council v Gibson, the developer appealed against the Council's refusal to approve a development application to divide land into two residential allotments and to erect a single dwelling on each allotment. The refusal was initially upheld by the Environment, Resources and Development Court but was subsequently overturned by a Judge of the Supreme Court, who granted the development approval. The Council appealed to the court, arguing that the Judge had erred in the interpretation and application of the Development Plan and that the proposal did not constitute "low density" residential development and was not in keeping with the "village character" of the township. The court examined whether the Judge properly considered the relevant planning schemes, the precedent of similar developments, and whether the appellate court should interfere with the decision of an expert tribunal.

The key legal issues involved the interpretation of the Development Plan, specifically the definition of "low density" residential development and the preservation of the "village character" of the locality. The court had to determine whether the Judge correctly applied the principles of the Development Plan and whether the precedent of other smaller allotments in the vicinity warranted a different outcome. The court also considered the role of precedent in planning decisions and the extent to which an appellate court should interfere with the decisions of an expert tribunal.

In its decision, the court found that the Judge had erred in reversing the Council's decision. The court held that the Judge had not properly interpreted the Development Plan and had placed undue emphasis on precedent. The court noted that the Commissioner had already made findings based on the plan and evidence before him, and that the use of the "precedent" factor was merely to reinforce the findings that the proposals were "sufficiently at variance" to warrant their refusal. The court concluded that the Judge had overstepped the bounds of appellate review and had failed to give sufficient weight to the Council's expertise in planning matters. As a result, the appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Council was restored.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be allowed, the decision of the Judge of the Supreme Court be set aside, and the decision of the Council be restored. This means that the development application to divide the land and erect the dwellings was refused, and the Council's original decision stands.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I do not agree with that conclusion because it is my view that the Commissioner had already made findings based on the plan, and the evidence before him, before he added to those findings his view as to the potential for cumulative effect. In short, I do not consider it was the major or dominating influence on the Commissioner’s decision but merely added to his findings. I believe that the use of the “precedent” factor was to reinforce his finding that the proposals were “sufficiently at variance.. to warrant their refusal” [44].Evidence of Existing Smaller Allotments The learned Judge deals, in detail, with the question of allotments of what he calls “a similar size and dimension in Oakbank” and in relation to those proposals says at [44]:All that can be said about these proposals is that they could be perceived as part of a trend to subdivide larger vacant allotments in the township which might have an inevitable effect on the character and amenity of the locality. However, there is no evidence that the previous subdivisions and the erection of dwellings on them had had an adverse effect on the township’s character and amenity such as might justify the arrest of such a trend. There was no evidence that these proposals in themselves would have that effect. The respondent argued that there was in fact no evidence before the Commissioner on that issue. The appellant contends that that is not correct, and that one important overriding aspect is that the documents supporting the appeal which was lodged in the ERD Court emphasised how the respondent in this court wished to place significant weight on the fact of other recent developments of smaller allotments in the locality. In other words, the present respondent was seeking to advance its case by relying on various recent approvals given in relation to nearby smaller allotments. In a letter written by the developer to the ERD Court on behalf of the respondent, dated 8 December 2004, the respondent said:Prior to lodging this land division my client had made numerous approaches to the planning department of the Council with preliminary proposals to construct 2 or more dwellings upon her property. These approaches were based upon numerous other approved example developments in the immediate vicinity of this land. These had all met with negative verbal responses and culminated in written advice from Council [letter dated 25 August 2004, item 4]. copy attached] stating their latest position “a rather strong position in more recent times” in relation to medium density development, and that a formal application should be submitted in order to test this. – my underlining. In that letter, the respondent’s agents also said:I point out that my client’s land [indicated in green highlight item 9.] is ideally situated for village style development being an allotment adjoining the rear of those fronting the main street, and as such is much more appropriately positioned than the majority of the other medium density developments that have occurred recently, as indicated by pink highlighting on the attached plan item 9]. – my underlining.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Council decided that in relation to the first application, the allotments were not low-density and secondly that the proposal did not comply with the Council Wide Principle of Development Control 44 both as to the total area and the minimum road frontage. In relation to the second application, to approve the proposed dwellings, the Council decided that the proposal would adversely affect both the village character of the area and the township character of Oakbank.The Decision of the ERD Court The Commissioner directed himself as to the requirements of the Development Plan and concluded that there were two significant matters in relation to the appeal which he heard from the Council’s decision. The first was whether the proposal was a low-density residential development, and the second was whether the development was conducive to the retention and preservation of, and in keeping with, the existing village character of Oakbank. The Commissioner referred to low-density residential development in the context of the Country Township (Balhannah and Oakbank) Zone Objective 2 and Oakbank Village Policy Area Objective 1 which are set out earlier in paragraph 11. As the Commissioner pointed out in his reasons, there are no matters of assistance within the zone or policy area provisions as to the meaning of “low-density residential use”. He referred however to the Council Wide Land Division Principle 44(a) in relation to townships generally within the Council area. That principle specified 1,000 sqm site areas with 25 m frontages, but allowed for smaller allotments where those smaller allotments were to be connected to a sewer. The Commissioner said at [29]:There is no direct references or assistance within the Zone or Policy Area provisions as to the meaning of “low density residential use” or “expansion”. Council Wide Land Division Principle 44(a), with general application to the numerous country townships in the Council area, assists to some degree. It specifies 1000 square metre site areas and 25 metre frontages but allows for “smaller allotments” exceptions where each allotment is to be connected to sewer (applying in this case) and “if the character of the township is not adversely affected”. I take this reference to “township” to mean the whole of the defined township within the Country Township zoning boundaries. The degree to which smaller allotments might be acceptable is moot.The Relevant Locality The Commissioner examined the locality specifically having regard to smaller recently created allotments within the locality. He said at [31] of his reasons:Turning to the locality (A) context in Oakbank, there are a few, obviously more recently created allotments in the 450‑500 square metre range (such as in Exhibit A2); and one group of three allotments of 300 square metres each at the south-eastern end of Elizabeth Street, south of the main street. Frontages for these range from 10, 12 and up to 15 metres. However, the significant majority and the traditional allotment size are double or more those areas (ie 900-1100 square metres). Hence the question must be asked, would the proposed new allotments (and dwellings thereon) create density (and character) variance that departs significantly from the balance of the low-density development in the Policy Area and the Oakbank township as a whole? In considering this question, we are to be reminded that dwelling density (site area per dwelling) is only one aspect or a perception of what might be regarded as low-density development. So too, must be a consideration of frontage width and set back of dwellings to front boundaries as well as side boundary spacing between them, more so than depth which is a less readily perceived characteristic from the public (street) realm. – my underlining.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established