Addenbrooke Pty Limited v Duncan (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Addenbrooke Pty Limited v Duncan (No 6) [2015] FCA 793

Citation: Addenbrooke Pty Limited v Duncan (No 6) [2015] FCA 793
Parties: ADDENBROOKE PTY LIMITED (ACN 055 973 576) v TRAVERS WILLIAM DUNCAN, PETER GRAY and SOUTHERN CROSS EQUITIES PTY LTD (ACN 071 935 441); SOUTHERN CROSS EQUITIES PTY LTD (ACN 071 935 441) v CASCADE COAL PTY LTD (ACN 119 180 620), ARTHUR PHILLIP PTY LTD (ACN 100 908 101) and RICHARD JONATHON POOLE; PETER GRAY v CASCADE COAL PTY LTD (ACN 119 180 620)
File number: NSD 2243 of 2012
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 5 August 2015
Catchwords: TRADE AND COMMERCE – whether a potential investor in a placement of shares made by a private company was misled as to the true purpose of the capital raising – whether material facts were concealed from the potential investor – whether the investor relied upon the positive statements made to it and whether it relied upon those with whom it dealt to disclose certain facts – whether those facts were material to the investor
Legislation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), ss 12DA, 12GF, 12GB and 12GM
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 1041E
Date of hearing: 2–6, 10 and 16–18 June 2014
Date of last submissions: 6 May 2015
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 442
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr FM Douglas QC, Mr G O'Mahoney and Mr JG Simpkins
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Gye Associates Lawyers
Counsel for the First Defendant: Mr CRC Newlinds SC and Mr GES Ng
Solicitor for the First Defendant: Yeldham Price O'Brien Lusk
Counsel for the Second and Third Defendants and the Cross-Claimants in the First and Second Cross-Claims: Mr AJ Payne SC and Mr JAC Potts
Solicitor for the Second and Third Defendants and the Cross-Claimants in the First and Second Cross-Claims: Speed & Stracey
Counsel for the First Cross-Defendant in the First Cross-Claim and the Cross-Defendant in the Second Cross-Claim: Mr J Williams and Mr T O'Brien
Solicitor for the First Cross-Defendant in the First Cross-Claim and the Cross-Defendant in the Second Cross-Claim: TressCox Lawyers
Counsel for the Second and Third Cross-Defendants in the First Cross-Claim: Mr K Andronos
Solicitor for the Second and Third Cross-Defendants in the First Cross-Claim: Torq Murray Law

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2243 of 2012

BETWEEN:

ADDENBROOKE PTY LIMITED (ACN 055 973 576)
Plaintiff

AND:

TRAVERS WILLIAM DUNCAN
First Defendant

PETER GRAY
Second Defendant

SOUTHERN CROSS EQUITIES PTY LTD (ACN 071 935 441)
Third Defendant

and between:

SOUTHERN CROSS EQUITIES PTY LTD (ACN 071 935 441)
Cross-Claimant on the First Cross-Claim

AND:

CASCADE COAL PTY LTD (ACN 119 180 620)
First Cross-Defendant on the First Cross-Claim

ARTHUR PHILLIP PTY LTD (ACN 100 908 101)
Second Cross-Defendant on the First Cross-Claim

RICHARD JONATHON POOLE
Third Cross-Defendant on the First Cross-Claim

AND BETWEEN:

PETER GRAY
Cross-Claimant on the Second Cross-Claim

AND:

CASCADE COAL PTY LTD (ACN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Addenbrooke Pty Limited v Duncan (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 793
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Addenbrooke Pty Limited initiated legal proceedings against Travers William Duncan, Peter Gray, and Southern Cross Equities Pty Ltd, asserting that they had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct and negligence under the Australian Corporations Act. The case involved a capital raising by a private company, Cascade Coal, and the subsequent sale of Cascade Coal to White Energy. The crux of the dispute was whether Addenbrooke, a potential investor, was misled regarding the purpose of the capital raising and whether material facts were concealed. The court had to determine whether Addenbrooke relied on the statements made by Duncan and Gray regarding the disclosure of certain facts.

The court examined the evidence and testimonies to ascertain if Denis O'Neil, a representative of Addenbrooke, was misled by Duncan's statements at the 19 November meeting. It was found that O'Neil's decision to invest was based on his belief in the potential profitability of the investment, particularly due to the likely sale of Cascade Coal to White Energy. The court concluded that even if O'Neil had been informed about the involvement of the Obeids, it would not have affected his investment decision. The court also rejected Addenbrooke's attempt to amend its Originating Application and Statement of Claim to include a criminal offence under section 1041E of the Corporations Act due to the late timing and serious consequences of such an amendment. The court further dismissed the Cross-Claims as they were contingent on Addenbrooke's success against the other defendants.

In light of the findings, the court dismissed all claims against Duncan, Gray, and Southern Cross Equities Pty Ltd. Addenbrooke was ordered to pay the costs of Duncan, Gray, and Southern Cross Equities Pty Ltd, including the costs that these parties would incur from the cross-defendants. Additionally, Southern Cross Equities Pty Ltd and Peter Gray were ordered to pay the costs of the cross-defendants from the Cross-Claims. The court emphasized that even if the defendants were found liable, Addenbrooke's claim faced significant hurdles, particularly in proving causation. Consequently, the court dismissed the entire proceeding and made orders regarding the costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to amend the Amended Originating Application and the Second Amended Statement of Claim in accordance with the amendments set out in MFI-11 be refused.

2. The whole of this proceeding be dismissed.

3. The First and Second Cross-Claims be dismissed.

4. The plaintiff pay the costs of the first defendant (Travers William Duncan), the second defendant (Peter Gray) and the third defendant (Southern Cross Equities Pty Ltd) of and incidental to this proceeding (including the costs which those parties are ordered to pay to the cross-defendants pursuant to Order 5 and Order 6 below).

5. The cross-claimant in the First Cross-Claim (Southern Cross Equities Pty Ltd) pay the cross-defendants’ costs of and incidental to that Cross-Claim.

6. The cross-claimant in the Second Cross-Claim (Peter Gray) pay the cross-defendant’s costs of and incidental to that Cross-Claim.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am of the view that Denis O’Neil did not pay close attention to what Duncan said at the 19 November meeting and did not make his decision to invest based upon the circumstance that the funds to be raised by the placement were to be spent on infrastructure or consultancy fees. Nor did he rely on anything said by Gray. Nor did he count on Gray carrying out a due diligence. Nor did he expect Gray to tell him all there was to know about the proposal. It did not matter to him whether others were skimming off substantial sums in the enterprise. What mattered to him was whether he was likely to make a substantial profit from the investment. He made a judgment about that based upon his knowledge of the people involved and the fact that Cascade Coal was likely to be sold to White Energy. In my judgment, had he been told the truth about the involvement of the Obeids at that time, it would have made no difference to the decision which he made.CONCLUSIONS The findings which I have made in respect of Denis O’Neil are sufficient to dispose of this proceeding. They are fatal to all of the statutory causes of action relied upon against Duncan and Gray for misleading and deceptive conduct and to the negligence action brought against SCE and Gray (see esp pars 175 ff of the Second Amended Statement of Claim). In Closing Submissions, Senior Counsel for Addenbrooke sought to amend its Originating Application and the Second Amended Statement of Claim in order to raise a cause of action for contravention of s 1041E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Breach of that section constitutes a criminal offence. I was not disposed to allow that amendment because of the serious nature of the consequences of breach and because the application to amend had been raised so late. Further, the defendants may have conducted their case differently had s 1041E been in the ring earlier. I remain of the view that Addenbrooke’s amendment application should be refused. The two Cross-Claims only come into play if Addenbrooke is successful in its claims against SCE and Gray. It has failed against those parties. For this reason, both Cross-Claims must be dismissed. As to costs, Addenbrooke must pay the costs of Duncan, SCE and Gray. SCE and Gray must pay the costs of the remaining cross-defendants of and incidental to the Cross-Claims. I think that I should make an order requiring Addenbrooke to reimburse the cross-claimants the amount of those costs. That is, the costs which Addenbrooke must pay to SCE and Gray should include the costs which those parties will be ordered to pay to the cross-defendants. Before leaving the matter, I wish to note that, even if Addenbrooke had persuaded me that the defendants were liable, there remained very serious obstacles in the way of its claim, principally in the area of causation. Because of the findings which I have made, it is not necessary to discuss these questions. There will be orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 16 February 2009, by letter dated that day, on the letterhead of Cascade Coal, John McGuigan wrote to the Executive Director, Mineral Resources of the DPI, submitting an expression of interest for the Mt Penny Exploration Area in response to the request published by the DPI on 9 January 2009. That letter was in the following terms, omitting formal parts:Re: Expression of Interest – Mt Penny Exploration AreaCascade Coal Pty Limited (“Cascade Coal”) is pleased to submit an Expression of Interest for the Mt Penny Exploration Area in response to the request published by the Department of Primary Industries on 9 January 2009.Cascade Coal has been specifically established to engage in greenfields exploration and developments within the coal sector preferably in New South Wales. You will note from the materials attached that the shareholders of Cascade Coal have significant experience in the coal sector and have been associated with large scale developments of coal properties in Australia and overseas. Cascade also currently has an active exploration program and holds a number of highly speculative tenements in Victoria referable to Brown Coal deposits.The shareholders of Cascade are committed to developing a coal project and have committed to inject sufficient capital to meet the up front fees and initial Program of Works as required in the event that Cascade is successful with its application. In this regard the shareholders have secured an underwriting from the investment bank Arthur Phillip Pty Ltd to underpin their commitment.In addition having regard to both the experience and expertise of the shareholders in raising substantial development capital in the coal sector the shareholders are confident that the necessary capital to enable the development of the above areas will be raised on a timely basis. Our submission for the area addresses in some detail the relevant exploration program, the proposed mine development methodology, the relevant infrastructure, the required mitigation of greenhouse gasses, other environ-mental concerns and the benefits to local and regional communities.We look forward to the opportunity of discussing the attached expressions of interest with you. Our nominated contact person is Michael Johnstone who may be contacted on [phone numbers omitted]. The Expression of Interest document is a document of 31 pages in which Cascade Coal set out its plans for the Mt Penny tenement as well as details of the shareholders of Cascade Coal. These shareholders were identified in the Expression of Interest document as Messrs Kinghorn, John McGuigan, Atkinson, Poole and Duncan. The document also contained details of Cascade Coal’s work program and mining methods intended for the site. Messrs Duncan, Kinghorn, John McGuigan and Atkinson were appointed directors of Cascade Coal on 19 February 2009. In May 2009, the DPI prepared a confidential evaluation of the expressions of interest received in respect of a number of NSW coal areas. In that document, in respect of Mt Penny, the author of the document recorded that it (the DPI) had received expressions of interest from four entities including MMNL and Cascade Coal. The author said that the submission made by MMNL was considered to be far superior in terms of its proposed technical program and additional financial contributions of $25,000,000 upon the grant of an exploration licence. The author went on to make favourable comments about MMNL’s program of exploration and conceptual mine development proposals. The evaluation team considered that the MMNL expression of interest was superior to other expressions of interest.