Adams (a pseudonym) v The Queen; Bradley (a pseudonym) v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Criminal)

ADAMS (a pseudonym) v THE QUEEN; BRADLEY (a pseudonym) v THE QUEEN

[2021] SASCA 147

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice Doyle and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

9 December 2021

CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - JUDICIAL DISCRETION TO ADMIT OR EXCLUDE EVIDENCE - PREJUDICIAL EVIDENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE - PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES NOT AMOUNTING TO MISCARRIAGE - IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PARTICULAR GROUNDS OF APPEAL - IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE - STRIKING OUT AND WARNING TO JURY TO DISREGARD EVIDENCE

Application for permission to appeal and appeal against conviction.

The appellants were convicted by a jury of the offences of aggravated serious criminal trespass in a place of residence, aggravated assault causing harm, aggravated robbery, and false imprisonment as participants in a joint criminal enterprise to commit those offences.

In September 2017, a group of masked people entered and ransacked a residential property in Two Wells. Three cars and three motorbikes were stolen. An occupant was restrained, threatened with a knife, told to hand over phones, keys, and money, and was beaten and tasered.

The prosecution’s case was that the offence was committed by a group of six people in a joint criminal enterprise. The appellants denied being involved in the offending and the issue at trial was whether they could be identified as parties to the joint criminal enterprise.

The prosecution relied on evidence adduced at trial from an accomplice of the appellants that, inter alia, the offending was suggested to the accomplice by one of the appellants and the accomplice participated in the offending because he was asked to by that appellant’s brother, who was the national sergeant of an outlaw motorcycle gang.

The appellants challenge the admissibility and treatment of that evidence, and rely on three grounds of appeal: first, that the trial judge erred in admitting the evidence because it was not relevant and prejudicial in that it suggested to the jury that the appellants were involved or associated with the [redacted] motorcycle club and more likely to have committed the offence; secondly, in the alternative, that the trial judge erred in refusing to declare a mistrial or by not withdrawing the evidence from the jury; and thirdly, in the further alternative, that the trial judge’s directions to the jury as to the evidence were inadequate.

Held, per the Court, granting permission to appeal but dismissing the appeals:

1.      The trial judge did not err in admitting the impugned evidence of the appellant’s brother’s membership of the outlaw motorcycle gang. The evidence was relevant, and there was no significant potential for unfair prejudicial use by the jury against the appellants.  In any event, any such potential was outweighed by the probative value of the evidence.

2.      The trial judge did not err in refusing to declare a mistrial or alternatively not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adams (a pseudonym) v The Queen; Bradley (a pseudonym) v The... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASCA 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Adams (a pseudonym) v The Queen* and *Bradley (a pseudonym) v The Queen*, the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered appeals against convictions for offences related to a home invasion. The prosecution's case relied on the evidence of an accomplice, Mr Daley, who testified about the appellants' involvement in the planning and execution of the offences, supported by circumstantial evidence. The central dispute on appeal concerned the admission of evidence relating to the first appellant's brother's membership in an outlaw motorcycle gang and its potential prejudicial effect on the jury.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the trial judge erred in admitting the evidence of the first appellant's brother's gang membership, whether this admission created a significant risk of unfair prejudice to the appellants, and if so, whether this risk was outweighed by the evidence's probative value. Additionally, the Court had to determine if the trial judge erred in refusing to declare a mistrial or withdraw the evidence, and whether the directions given to the jury regarding the use of this evidence were adequate to prevent a miscarriage of justice.

The Court reasoned that the impugned evidence was relevant to establishing the appellants' connection to the plan and the motive for retrieving vehicles, particularly as Mr Daley testified that the plan was initiated at the request of the first appellant's brother, who was his superior in the motorcycle club. The Court found that the trial judge's directions to the jury on the permissible and impermissible uses of this evidence were clear, correct, and comprehensive, effectively mitigating any potential for unfair prejudice. Consequently, the Court concluded that there was no miscarriage of justice and dismissed the appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, per the Court, granting permission to appeal but dismissing the appeals:

1. The trial judge did not err in admitting the impugned evidence of the appellant’s brother’s membership of the outlaw motorcycle gang. The evidence was relevant, and there was no significant potential for unfair prejudicial use by the jury against the appellants. In any event, any such potential was outweighed by the probative value of the evidence.

2. The trial judge did not err in refusing to declare a mistrial or alternatively not withdrawing the evidence.

3. The trial judge’s directions as to the permissible and impermissible uses of the impugned evidence were clear, correct, and comprehensive. There was no miscarriage of justice.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The prosecution case on the issue of identity comprised two parts. An accomplice, Mr Daley, gave direct evidence of the involvement of the appellants in the planning and execution of the offences. There was also a body of circumstantial evidence probative of the appellants’ presence and involvement. The evidence of Mr Daley Mr Daley’s evidence was that he became aware of the plan to commit the home invasion on 7 September 2017. He said that he received a text message from Ms Adams suggesting that they catch up at her place. He arrived at Ms Adams’ house at around lunchtime. In addition to Ms Adams, her partner (AB) and Ms Bradley were also present. Mr Daley said that Ms Adams spoke to him and Ms Bradley “about picking up some cars from Two Wells”. While Ms Adams did not say anything at that point about whose property it was, Mr Daley’s evidence was that she mentioned her brother’s knowledge of the plan. Mr Daley’s evidence also included reference to his connection with Mr Adams through their involvement in the [redacted] motorcycle club. Mr Daley’s evidence in this respect was as follows:Q. Did you ask her or did she say anything about anyone else knowing about it.A. Yes, her brother.Q. And who’s her brother.A. [Mr Adams].Q. Have you previously known [Mr Adams] yourself.A. Yes, I have.Q. How did you know [Mr Adams].A. I was in a motorcycle club with him.Q. And what motorcycle club was that.A. [Redacted].Q. What was the state of your relationship with [Mr Adams] at that time.A. We was in the club together. We lived together.Q. Did you agree to help [Ms Adams] moving some cars.A. Yes.Q. And why was that.A. Only because her brother asked us to.Q. And why is it if her brother asked you to you decided that was appropriate.A. He was my national sergeant at the time. Mr Daley’s evidence was that he then returned to his house where he was hosting a birthday party for Ms Adams’ daughter. Various people attended, including Ms Adams, Ms Bradley, Mr Cahill, AB and IG. There was further discussion about the moving of cars. Each of the people just mentioned were involved in the discussion, although Mr Cahill was “in and out of the conversation”. The discussion included reference to the need to “grab” JA when they arrived at the property. Mr Daley said that his understanding was that the occupants of the Two Wells property “had some money problems with people I knew and that’s why we were retrieving some vehicles”. Mr Daley then described a group of them gathering in the early hours of the following morning and driving in two cars to the property in Two Wells. The group consisted of Mr Daley, Mr Cahill, AB, IG and the two appellants. He also described the offending that occurred once at the property. On Mr Daley’s evidence, he knew Ms Adams, her boyfriend and her brother. Ms Adams informed him of the plan, was party to the various conversations about the plan (including the need to grab JA when they arrived at the property) and participated fully in the offending, including the movement of vehicles after they had left the Two Wells property.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In our view, her Honour’s directions as to the permissible and impermissible uses of the impugned evidence of Mr Daley were clear, correct and comprehensive. They were sufficient to eliminate any risk of prejudicial reasoning on the part of the jury. It follows that the appellants have not established any inadequacy in the trial judge’s directions that was productive of a miscarriage of justice.Conclusion For the reasons set out, we grant Ms Bradley an extension of the time within which to seek permission to appeal and grant both appellants permission to appeal. However, we dismiss their appeals.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.