Adamo v Nemet No. Scciv-01-273

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ADAMO v NEMET

[2001] SASC 281

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Perry and Bleby J

  1. DOYLE CJ           Ms Adamo was injured in a motor vehicle accident on 6 December 1998.  She was a passenger in the front seat of a motor car when the defendant drove into the rear of the motor car.  The Judge described the impact as a major impact.

  2. Ms Adamo’s claim for damages for personal injury was heard by a Judge of the District Court.

  3. The Judge formed an adverse view of Ms Adamo.  He found that she had concealed from doctors whom she consulted the fact that she had had problems with her neck, back and shoulder before the accident. The Judge found that parts of her evidence about her medical history were not true. He was not prepared to act on her evidence about the extent of her pain and disability at the time of trial. He awarded damages on the basis that the accident had aggravated symptoms attributable to a condition that existed before the accident, and that by the time of the hearing she was no worse off than she would have been had the accident not occurred.

  4. Ms Adamo appeals against the assessment of damages, and the findings that underpin it.

    The evidence about Ms Adamo’s condition

  5. What follows is an outline only. In particular, I have not dealt in detail with Ms Adamo’s complaints about her condition.

  6. Ms Adamo was 33 years old at trial. She was not married. In March 1999 she and her sister bought a house. The commitment that this entailed, coupled with her good work record, suggested that she would want to work if she could. In October 1994, about 4 years before the accident, she began working for Cheap as Chips as a shop assistant. The work was described by the Judge as “fairly heavy”. In July 1997 she became an assistant manager, and worked in that capacity until the time of the accident. The work involved quite a lot of lifting of stock and reaching overhead.

  7. In her evidence-in-chief Ms Adamo said that she had no difficulty carrying out her work. In particular, she said that before the accident she had no problems with, or symptoms from, any parts of the body that were injured in the accident, namely her back and shoulders.

  8. The accident was on a Saturday. Ms Adamo felt some soreness in her neck and at the top of her shoulders, but did not seek medical treatment. She carried on as normal over the weekend. On the Monday, she found it difficult to drive to work. She had trouble turning because her back hurt. She worked that day with difficulty. She went to work on the Tuesday, but her neck and back pain got worse, and she went home at about 11 am.

  9. She consulted her general practitioner, Dr Neroni. She had consulted him before. He arranged x-rays. He referred her to Dr Meegan, an occupational physician, and to a firm of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adamo v Nemet No. Scciv-01-273 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 281
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Adamo v Nemet, the appellant, Ms Adamo, appeals against the assessment of damages awarded to her and the findings that underpin it. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. Ms Adamo suffered injuries in a motor vehicle accident and seeks to challenge the damages awarded to her, claiming that the Judge did not properly consider the evidence regarding her condition and its impact on her life.

The court was required to decide whether the Judge erred in his assessment of the damages awarded to Ms Adamo and whether the findings that underpin the damages award were correct. This involved examining the evidence presented by Ms Adamo and the expert opinions given regarding her condition, particularly focusing on the extent of her injuries and the impact they had on her ability to work and carry out daily activities.

The court held that it was not prepared to interfere with the Judge's order. The appeal was dismissed, with the judges agreeing that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by the Chief Justice. The court found that the Judge had adequately considered the evidence presented and made the appropriate findings regarding the damages awarded to Ms Adamo. The appeal was therefore dismissed.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeal, with the appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Adamo appeals against the assessment of damages, and the findings that underpin it. The evidence about Ms Adamo’s condition What follows is an outline only. In particular, I have not dealt in detail with Ms Adamo’s complaints about her condition. Ms Adamo was 33 years old at trial. She was not married. In March 1999 she and her sister bought a house. The commitment that this entailed, coupled with her good work record, suggested that she would want to work if she could. In October 1994, about 4 years before the accident, she began working for Cheap as Chips as a shop assistant. The work was described by the Judge as “fairly heavy”. In July 1997 she became an assistant manager, and worked in that capacity until the time of the accident. The work involved quite a lot of lifting of stock and reaching overhead. In her evidence-in-chief Ms Adamo said that she had no difficulty carrying out her work. In particular, she said that before the accident she had no problems with, or symptoms from, any parts of the body that were injured in the accident, namely her back and shoulders. The accident was on a Saturday. Ms Adamo felt some soreness in her neck and at the top of her shoulders, but did not seek medical treatment. She carried on as normal over the weekend. On the Monday, she found it difficult to drive to work. She had trouble turning because her back hurt. She worked that day with difficulty. She went to work on the Tuesday, but her neck and back pain got worse, and she went home at about 11 am. She consulted her general practitioner, Dr Neroni. She had consulted him before. He arranged x-rays. He referred her to Dr Meegan, an occupational physician, and to a firm of physiotherapists called “Roberts Physiotherapy”. Ms Adamo was complaining of neck and back pain initially. A report from Dr Meegan of 11 January 1999 states that Ms Adamo told him she experienced neck pain immediately, then over a couple of days thoracic and low back pain, the low back pain settled after about a week but the neck and thoracic pain were on-going. She complained of mid thoracic pain, particularly at the T6 and T8 level. X-rays excluded a suspected crush fracture of those vertebrae, but disclosed underlying Scheuermann’s disease at those levels, which Dr Meegan thought had been aggravated by the accident. Ms Adamo was also complaining of neck or cervical pain. The complaints of thoracic and neck pain continued in subsequent months. In the report of 11 January 1999 Dr Meegan expressed the opinion that Ms Adamo was suffering from cervical soft tissue injury, and aggravation of Scheuermann’s disease at the T6 and T8 level. He expected her symptoms to improve over 6 to 12 weeks, but noted that in some cases symptoms after motor vehicle accidents could persist for up to 6 months and in some cases for a year or two. However, he was hopeful that she would settle quite well and return to work in the near future. Scheuermann’s disease is a developmental abnormality, and not truly a disease. The evidence before the Judge was that it was a condition that could exist without causing any symptoms. However, according to Dr Kelly, a specialist in occupational medicine called by the defendant, it was a condition that could be aggravated, and become painful, as a result of fairly heavy manual work. Dr Kelly said that once this occurred it was likely that the symptoms would recur if the aggravating influence, such as heavy work, were to be repeated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ PERRY J BLEBY J
Under all the circumstances, I am not prepared to interfere with the Judge’s order.Conclusions For those reasons the appeal must be dismissed. I agree with Doyle CJ that this appeal should be dismissed. I have nothing to add to his reasons, with which I also agree. I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by the Chief Justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ, PERRY J, BLEBY J

Full text does not contain this section.